A57969:948
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
[figure] › Chapter 9 › Section 9: Of the addition of Members to the Church.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. The argument must be thus formed. All these whom God intendeth shall edify and not ruin the Church, are to be only members of the visible Church: but all known hypocrites are such; Ergo. The proposition is false, for if we speak of Gods secret Intention and his decreeing Will; It is not a rule for the Church to square and to regulate them in the choosing or refusing Church-members, because God intendeth in his decreeing will, that many hypocrites, such as Judas and Dumas, shall be Church-members, and let our Brethren judge if they be fit materials to edify the Church. If we speak of Gods revealed will, the proposition also is false; for by our Brethren's Doctrine, it is Gods revealed will that the Church receive as Church-members latent hypocrites, such as Simon Magus, Acts 8. who are conceived to be regenerated, as the church, Acts 8. conceived Simon Magus to be a sound Believer, as our Brethren say, and yet latent hypocrites, are no less unfit materials to build the ⟨p. 265⟩Church, then known hypocrites. 2. We do not think that hypocrites fallen from their first love, and by scandalous living declaring themselves to be such should be kept in the Church. But so the Author allegeth, Revel. 2. That the Church of Ephesus falling from her first love, must be a false constituted Church, in which there were members fitter to ruin, then to edify the Church. And yet certain it is, Paul, Eph. 1. and Christ, Revel. 2. acknowledgeth the Church of Ephesus to be a true visible Church.
Answ. The argument must be thus formed. All these whom God intendeth shall edifie and not ruine the Church, are to be only members of the visible Church: but all knowen hypocrites are such; Ergo. The proposition is false, for if we speake of Gods secret Intention and his decreeing Will; It is not a rule for the Church to square and to regulate them in the choysing or refusing Church-members, because God intendeth in his decreeing wi•l, that many hypocrites, such as Judas and D•mas, shall be Church-members, and let our Brethren judge if they be fit materialls to edifie the Church. If we speake of Gods revealed will, the proposition also is false; for by our Brethrens Doctrine, it is Gods revealed will that the Church receive as Church-members latent hypocrites, such as Simon Magus,