A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
[9], 521 [i.e. 519] p. · 190k words · Wing R2395 · ESTC R19199
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But all the members cannot inflict lesser punishment; for neither women, nor aged children, nor the unofficed brethren, can rebukes, exhort, or, by the Word, openly convince the officers. Ans. The consequence is feeble, as appears from the nature of delegated power, which is committed by Christ to persons capable thereof, which women for their sex, children for the want of the exercise of understanding, cannot do. People have power to choose officers, therefore women have power to put in their voices. The Body of a Corporation may put out a Major upon desert; therefore women and children may do it. No, the wise God hath included the votes of women in the male.
But all the members cannot inflict lesser punishment; for neither women, nor aged children, nor the unofficed brethren, can rebuks, exhort, or, by the Word, openly convince the officers. Ans. The consequence is feeble, as appears from the nature of delegated power, which is committed by Christ to persons capable thereof, which women for their sex, children for the want of the exercise of understanding, cannot do. People have power to choose officers, therefore women have power to put in their voices. The Body of a Corporation may put out a Major upon desert; therefore women and children may do it. No, the wise God hath included the votes of women in the male.
Ans. Nay, but Mr. H. shall not so elude the Argument. Whatsoever the judging, binding and loosing Church of believers may do, that every member of the joint community may ⟨p. 255⟩do, in collegio, if the Keys be given to them (as Mr H. and Mr. Cotton say) as actual believers, giving Peters confession, Mat. 16. and therefore Mr. H. too suddenly says, The consequence (he would have said the major, for its a lawful Syllogism) is feeble; for women, children, sons come to ag• servants, which he left out, are formal and essential parts of the believing Church, to whom the Keys are given as to the first subject. If the Keys be not given to them as confessing and professing believers, because not to women, sons, servants, then not to all confessing and professing believers, as such; then not to all blessed, as taught by a teacher above flesh and blood, as Peter was,
. This shall cross the Principles of our Brethren (& the Truth and Scripture cannot but cross them) nor can it be denied, but women, sons come to age, servants, are no less members of that Church, than the multitude of male-believers, for they confess Christ, as Peter, are blessed, and built on the Rock, as well as Peter, and are no less conceived in charity, to have some spi•l good in them, as Mr. H. dictates, cap. 2. par. 1, 15, 16. and these must be visible Saints to whom Mr. H. his definition of visible Saints agrees; and therefore our brethren must either quit the principles they follow, or then a multitude of believers of visible Saints must be larger than the actual binding and loosing Church,
. and against their will this, Tell the Church, must be understood of, Tell some believers only, (if they will) The Officers; but, Tell not women, nor sons, nor servants, for they are no part of the binding and loosing Church; and, If he hear not the Church; that is, as the Hebraism there, If he obey not the Church, if he obey not some believers Men, and Heads of Families, not women, servants, •ons, Let him be to thee as a publican, &c.
Ans. Nay, but Mr. H. shall not so elude the Argument. Whatsoever the judging, binding and loosing Church of believers may do, that every member of the joynt community may ⟨p. 255⟩do, in collegio, if the Keyes be given to them (as Mr H. and Mr. Cotton say) as actual believers, giving Peters confession, Mat. 16. and therefore Mr. H. too suddenly sayes, The consiquence (he would have said the major, for its a lawful Syllogism) is feeble; for women, children, sons come to ag• servants, which he left out, are formal and essential parts of the believing Church, to whom the Keyes are given as to the first subject. If the Keyes be not given to them as confessing and professing believers, because not to women, sons, servants, then not to all confessing and professing believers, as such; then not to all blessed, as taught by a teacher above flesh and blood, as Peter was, Mat. 16. This shall cross the Principles of our Brethren (& the Truth and Scripture cannot but cross them) nor can it be denied, but women, sons come to age, servāts, are no less members of that Church, than the multitude of male-believers, for they confess Christ, as Peter, are blessed, and built on the Rock, as well as Peter, and are no less conceived in charity, to have some spi•l good in them, as Mr. H. dictates, cap. 2. par. 1, 15, 16. and these must be visible Saints to whom Mr. H. his definition of visible Saints agrees; and therefore our brethren must either quit the principles they follow, or then a multitude of believers of visible Saints must be larger than the actual binding and loosing Church, Mat. 18. and against their will this, Tell the Church, must be understood of, Tell some believers onely, (if they will) The Officers; but, Tell not women, nor sons, nor servants, for they are no part of the binding and loosing Church; and, If he hear not the Church; that is, as the Hebraism there, If he obey not the Church, if he obey not some believers Men, and Heads of Families, not women, servants, •ons, Let him be to thee as a publican, &c.
2. So woman are either not capable of believing and visible 1Saintship, which none can say; or they are not capable of a power of binding and loosing: and so a power capable of binding and loosing is not given to the multitude of believers, as the Church, Mat. 18.
1Women are as essential parts of the believing Church as men, and wom•n must no more blindly believe what the Church believes, than men; nor must their faith in discerning the voice of Christ in this pastor, not in this, be blindly included in the males discerning and so women must be a part of the binding and loosing Church, Mat. 18.
1. Their tacit voices and consents are not excluded, because they must try the spirits, & not upon trust, & fide implicitâ believe every teacher more than men, or believe as the Church believes, more than their husbands, nor must they take Doctrines as truth: upon their husbands word; not are women so excluded from speaking in the Church, as they may upon no occasion confess their faith.
5. We seek a warrant why the votes of women in choosing their Pastors, must more be included in the votes of the male, than their being essential parts of the redeemed Church is included in the males, or their confessing publicly, that Jesus is the Christ, as many women Martyrs, and sons and servants have gloriously done; and yet their confession of Christ to the death must be personal, and not included in the confession of husband or parents, as Mat. 10. 32.
5. We seek a warrant why the votes of women in choosing their Pastors, must more be included in the votes of the male, than their being essential parts of the redeemed Church is included in the males, or their confessing publickly, that Jesus is the Christ, as many women Martyrs, and sons and servants have gloriously done; and yet their confession of Christ to the death must be personal, and not included in the confession of husband or parents, as Mat. 10. 32.
Mr. H. Arg. 5. of Mr. R. Those to whom the essence and definition 1of a Ministerial Church, having power to excommunicate, doth belong; those and those only are understood under the Name of the Church, Mat. 18. But the essence and definition of a Ministerial Church, having power to excommunicate, doth not necessarily belong to a great company of believers assembled Churchwise.
Mr. H. Arg. 5. of Mr. R. Those to whom the essence and definition 1of a Ministerial Church, having power to excommunicate, doth belong; those and those onely are understood under the Name of the Church, Mat. 18. But the essence and definition of a Ministerial Church, having power to excommunicate, doth not necessarily belong to a great company of believers assembled Churchwise.
Ans. Both propositions may be denied. Neither a Church without officers, nor as having them, is here only understood; but the second sense is here firstly attended. For both people and Elders have their power, parts and places in a right order and manner; when its said, a Ministerial Church is here understood, Ministerial notes either Ministers without the body exclusively, and that is false, or Ministers with the body inclusively. Now a Ministerial Church in the fairest sense aims at both. In the first sense, ⟨p. 257⟩the proposition is false; in the second it doth not conclude to whom the essence and definition of a Ministerial, i. e. of a Church of Ministers, without the body, having power to excommunicate, doth necessarily belong: These and these only are here understood. This Mr. R. l. 1. p. 226. refu•eth.1
Ans. Both propositions may be denied. Neither a Church without officers, nor as having them, is here onely understood; but the second sense is here firstly attended. For both people and Elders have their power, parts and places in a right order and manner; when its said, a Ministerial Church is here understood, Ministerial notes either Ministers without the body exclusively, and that is false, or Ministers with the body inclusively. Now a Ministerial Church in the fairest sense aims at both. In the first sense, ⟨p. 257⟩the proposition is false; in the second it doth not conclude to whom the essence and definition of a Ministerial, i. e. of a Church of Ministers, without the body, having power to excommunicate, doth necessarily belong: These and these onely are here understood. This Mr. R. l. 1. p. 226. refu•eth.1
1The Church principally meant Mat. 18. must be the binding and loosing brethren which are the Church fi•st•y, the officers are only separable adjuncts thereof, saith M. H. Par. 1. c. 11. p. 198.The Church principally meant Mat. 18. must be the binding and loosing brethren which are the Church fi•st•y, the officers are onely separable adjuncts thereof, saith M. H. Par. 1. c. 11. p. 198.
Ans. Well then Mr. H. denies the conclusion; then both a Ministerial Church, and a Church of Redeemed, meeting to partake of Ordinances, have their part here: Ergo, women have their part here.
2. If a Church in both senses be here understood when all the Officers turn grievous Wolves, Socinians, Papists, Familists, such as say they are Apostles, and do li•; then
2. If a Church in both s•nses be here understood when all the Officers turn grievous Wolves, Socinians, Papists, Familists, such as say they are Apostles, and do li•; then
1. Must the people that are stumbled complain to themselves. This is not just, to make the complaining party (saith M. H.) judge. What if they unjustly complain, and say their officers are Presbyterial and Prelatical, and are Legal Preachers, and preach neither Christ nor Free-grace, then hath Christ ordained them whose lips preserve not knowledge, to be the only judging and first Church, which hath power to excommunicate, to be the 1first and only Judges-of sound Doctrine, and Heresy in officers. And suppose the Church of people and officers be here firstly understood; we cannot complain of the Familist people (of which there were too many in N•E.) to the Elders, for the same reason.
1. Must the people that are stumbled complain to themselves. This is not just, to make the complaining party (saith M. H.) judge. What if they unjustly complain, and say their officers are Presbyterial and Prelatical, and are Legal Preachers, and preach neither Christ nor Free-grace, then hath Christ ordained them whose lips preserve not knowledge, to be the onely judging and first Church, which hath power to excommunicate, to be the 1first and onely Judges-of sound Doctrine, and Heresie in officers. And suppose the Church of people and officers be here firstly understood; we cannot complain of the Familist people (of which there were too many in N•E.) to the Elders, for the same reason.
1When all the officers turn wolves, the people must complain to the people, & when the people turn Familists, Socinians &c. to whom s•a•l the officers complain, according to M. H. mind?When all the office•s turne wolves, the people must complain to the people, & when the people turn Familists, Socinians &c. to whom s•a•l the officers complain, acco•ding to M. H. minde?
2. Nor is it true, that people and Elders (the people must in judging be first, by Mr. H.) have their power, parts and place in this work, for all Elders and people have equally a decisive voice, except women, and children, and servants; and by what reason they want votes, a reason […] yet is not heard of.
2. Nor is it true, that people and Elders (the people must in judging be first, by Mr. H.) have their power, parts and place in this work, for all Elders and people have equally a decisive voice, except women, and children, and se•vants; and by what reason they want votes, a reason 〈…〉 yet is not heard of.