A57981:1263
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
LIB. III. CHAP. I.
Of the first subject of Ecclesiastic Power: Of the delegated Power of the Church.
Of the first subject of Ecclesiastick Power: Of the delegated Power of the Church.
There is a double Authority, one Supreme and Monarchical 1only in Christ, and another Subordinate and Delegate; which […] a Right given by Commission from Christ to fit person•, to act i• his House according to his order. By Right, is meant jus, or [Greek or Hebrew], which according to God, certain persons possess in their external administrations issuing from such special relations, unto which they are called by Christ. 2. Its given to […] persons who are capable to receive this power, not to women, children, •admen, &c. Therefore let the Reader take notice of that, as not worthy to be considered. If power be in the Church of believers, then women and children may exercise it, […] Mr. Ball, Mr. R. for they are not fit persons appointed by Christ to manage this power. Lastly, ⟨p. 274⟩they must act according to Gods order. The whole Church is an Army terrible with Banners, but the parts do fight in their own order: The power is in the whole firstly, but each part knows his rank; the officers in their part, order and manner, the members in theirs. The whole acts some things immediately, some things mediately.
THere is a double Authority, one Supreme and Monarchical 1onely in Christ, and another Subordinate and Delegate; which 〈…〉 a Right given by Commission from Christ to fit person•, to act i• his House according to his order. By Right, is meant jus, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which according to God, certain persons possess in their external administrations issuing from such special relations, unto which they are called by Christ. 2. Its given to 〈…〉 persons who are capable to receive this power, not to women, children, •admen, &c. Therefore let the Reader take notice of that, as not worthy to be considered. If power be in the Church of believers, then women and children may exercise it, 〈…〉 Mr. Ball, Mr. R. for they are not fit persons appointed by Christ to manage this power. Lastly, ⟨p. 274⟩they must act according to Gods order. The whole Church is an Army terrible with Banners, but the parts do fight in their own order: The power is in the whole firstly, but each part knows his rank; the officers in their part, order and manner, the members in theirs. The whole acts some things immediately, some things mediately.
- 1Mr. Hookers. Survey; par. […]. cap. 11. p. 185, 186.Mr. Hookers. Survey; par. 〈…〉. cap. 11. p. 185, 186.
Ans. A Monarchical power in Christ we know, and authority delegate of Jurisdiction in the Ambassadors and Officers, 1who are called [Greek or Hebrew], 1 Tim. 5. 17. [Greek or Hebrew], 1 Thess. 5. 12. [Greek or Hebrew], Heb. 13. 17. Rulers we know: but that the people or Church of believers especially separated from officers, are called Rulers, or endued with any delegate power over we know not whom, we read not in Scripture.
Ans. A Mona•chical power in Christ we know, and authority delegate of Jurisdiction in the Ambassadors and Officers, 1who are called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, 1 Tim. 5. 17. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, 1 Thess. 5. 12. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Heb. 13. 17. Rulers we know: but that the people or Church of believers especially separated from officers, are called Rulers, or indued with any delegate power over we know not whom, we reade not in Scripture.
- 1Mr. H. his fit persons the first subject of the Keys, examined, is found lightMr. H. his fit persons the first subject of the Keyes, ••amined, is found light
2. By the Keys he must mean both the Keys of Knowledge and of Jurisdiction: But what Scripture gives the pastoral Key to unofficed Brethren? I do not know a right given to fit persons, without any mentioning of the first subject, the Church of confederate Saints, as Mr. H. which includes women, 1children of age, servants, (for these are fit persons to be members of the Church built on the Rock) and of the Church of Believers) Ergo, they are fit persons, and as fit, some of them, to wit, children of years of discretion, and believing servants, as the Brethren; for neither Sex, nor want of understanding, nor distemper of judgement, the three causes of unfitness owned by Mr. H. can render them more uncapable than the brethren: yea, the brethren being often unlettered Tradesmen, 2and many of them dull and rude, though believers, are most unfit persons to judge of sound and unsound Doctrine, and of controverted points, whether the Pastors teach perverse things, Acts 20. 29. hold the doctrine of Balaam, Rev. 2. 13. or not; and yet by Mr. H. they are the only, and none but they are to judge and try the learning, ability of Pastors, unsoundness in Socinian, Antinomian, Popish, Arminian, &c. Tenets, though they know no more the Tongues, Arts nor Sciences, than some Priests who can scarce read the Mass-book in Latin, nor understand the Language thereof; and they only have power to depose them all for Ignorance and Heresy.
2. By the Keyes he must mean both the Keyes of Knowledge and of Jurisdiction: But what Scripture gives the pastoral Key to unofficed Brethren? I do not know a right given to fit persons, without any mentioning of the first subject, the Church of confederate Saints, as Mr. H. which includes women, 1children of age, servants, (for these are fit persons to be members of the Church built on the Rock) and of the Church of Believers) Ergo, they are fit persons, and as fit, some of them, to wit, children of years of discretion, and believing servants, as the Brethren; for neither Sex, nor want of understanding, nor distemper of judgement, the three causes of unfitness owned by Mr. H. can render them more uncapable than the brethren: yea, the brethren being often unlettered Tradesmen, 2and many of them dull and rude, though believers, are most unfit persons to judge of sound and unsound Doctrine, and of controverted points, whether the Pastors teach perverse things, Acts 20. 29. hold the doctrine of Balaam, Rev. 2. 13. or not; and yet by Mr. H. they are the onely, and none but they are to judge and try the learning, ability of Pastors, unsoundness in Socinian, Antinomian, Popish, Arminian, &c. Tenets, though they know no more the Tongues, Arts nor Sciences, than some Priests who can scarce reade the Mass-book in Latine, nor understand the Languge thereof; and they onely have power to depose them all for Ignorance and Heresie.
- 1Sect. 2. p. 192.
- 2Unlettered brethren are not fit persons to judge of sound and of heretical doctrine, as M. H.
2. As for women, they are redeemed, built on the Rock, and ⟨p. 275⟩have a voice tacit, or no, let Mr. Hooker say.
1. To choose or refuse Officers, 1. They are of the sheep that can discern the voice of Christ in sent Pastors, Joh. 9 and this is Mr. H. his argument to prove that the people should call their own pastors, as hereafter he saith.
1. To choose or refuse Officers, 1. They are of the sheep that can discern the voice of Christ in sent Pastors, Joh. 9 and this is Mr. H. his argument to prove that the people should call their own pastors, as hereafttr he saith.
2. Women must have a vote in admission of members, which Mr. H. calls potestatem judicii, a power of judging; for they 1are not to own as Church members, and to rebuke, and tell the Church, and to gain brethren and sisters blindly; they, by the judgement of discretion, if not by more, according to Mr. H. must have some hand in this. Women are to try, by the judgement of discretion, the spirits of Teachers, whether Antichristian or not, whether they be of God, or no, and to hold what is good, as men, 1 Joh. 4. 1. 1 Thess. 5. 21. Ergo, they must try both men and doctrines; and must, as was said, withdraw from the unsound and scandalous: therefore what Mr. Ball and Mr. R. say touching them, must be considered, If the power be in the whole Church firstly, then must the power of the Keys be in all the members firstly also, if Logic have place; and if it be in all, then its in women: How came it to women? show the Scripture. And whereas Mr. H. saith, The whole Church is terrible as an Army with Banners, it saith, the Church ruling and conquering by the Keys both of Knowledge and Jurisdiction, is made up of ruled commanders, and ruled soldiers, not of a number of only brethren; and soldiery acts of ruling (for of the Church that beareth the Keys Mr. H. must now speak) in women Mr. R. would know: for that terribleness is in acts of Discipline, not a little: if all be terrible, then also women. Your homogeneous Church, which only, and none but they, by Mr. H. his doctrine, may lift a Banner against all the officers, and depose and excommunicate them every man: But Mr. Cotton saith to this, What haste brother Mr. H?
2. Women must have a vote in admission of members, which Mr. H. calls potestatem judicii, a power of judging; for they 1are not to own as Church members, and to rehuke, and tell the Church, and to gain brethren and sisters blindly; they, by the judgement of discretion, if not by more, according to Mr. H. must have some hand in this. Women are to try, by the judgement of discretion, the spirits of Teachers, whether Antichristian or not, whether they be of God, or no, and to hold what is good, as men, 1 Ioh. 4. 1. 1 Thess. 5. 21. Ergo, they must try both men and doctrines; and must, as was said, withdraw from the unsound and scandalous: therefore what Mr. Ball and Mr. R. say touching them, must be considered, If the power be in the whole Church firstly, then must the power of the Keyes be in all the members firstly also, if Logick have place; and if it be in all, then its in women: How came it to women? shew the Scripture. And whereas Mr. H. saith, The whole Church is terrible as an Army with Banners, it saith, the Church ruling and conquering by the Keyes both of Knowledge and Iurisdiction, is made up of ruled commanders, and ruled souldiers, not of a number of onely brethren; and souldiery acts of ruling (for of the Church that beareth the Keyes Mr. H. must now speak) in women Mr. R. would know: for that terribleness is in acts of Discipline, not a little: if all be terrible, then also women. Your homogeneous Church, which onely, and none but they, by Mr. H. his doctrine, may lift a Banner against all the officers, and depose and excommunicate them every man: But Mr. Cotton saith to this, What haste brother Mr. H?
- 1Survey, pa• 1. c. 11. propos. 4. p. 203.
Mr. H. This power is either a power of many when combined, and this is either a power—
Of judging, judicii; or of donation:
Or its power in one a power of Office:
The power of judgement the whole hath, and doth use in admissions and excommunication: the same pow•r that takes in must cast out.
Ans. The distinction of power of Office or Order in one 1who is a Pastor, and of Jurisdiction in many in a Presbytery, is warranted by Scripture.
- 1Consent is in the people, but no judicial authority, as antiquity and our Divines prove.
But for the power of judging, and of giving of power, potest as donationis, to others to preach and administer the seals, in the people who have no power themselves, it hath neither the countenance of Scripture nor Reason, and is but a device of Merellius holden by Mr. H.