A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
[9], 521 [i.e. 519] p. · 190k words · Wing R2395 · ESTC R19199
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. Pastors do either as pastors called of God preach to Church-members, to convert them?
2. Or then as pastors called of God, they do not preach to Church-members, to convert them. This contradiction is inevitable.
1. Pastors doe either as pastors called of God preach to Church-members, to convert them?
2. Or then as pastors called of God, they doe not preach to Church-members, to convert them. This contradiction is inevitable.
Then must pastors as pastors called of God preach to Church-members, as some other officers, either as ruling Elders, which confoundeth the preaching Elder, and the not preaching Elder, contrary to the
. or they preach to them, as private Christians, and unofficed persons, upon an intention to convert Church-members: for if only they preach as pastors to confirm them, not to convert them, they do not fulfil their Ministry which they have received of the Lord, in all points, as they should,
. nor do they as pastors, preach in season and out of season, by reproving, rebuking, exhorting. (2) Then must all pastoral feeding formally be in confirming only, not in feeding, nor begetting to Christ, nor in restoring the lost, nor in bringing again the driven away, nor in all these five points,
from the Lion and the wild beasts. Now this distinctions should be proved from the word of truth. 2. Then Pastors as watchmen give not warning of the sword, and of dying in sin, as Ezech. 3. 16, 17, 18, 19 20. Ezech. 33. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, &c. but as unofficed men, and private Christians. But that, way all the citizens of the city shall be made watchmen, which the Prophet Ezekiel and Jeremiah condemn, Jerem. 23. Ezech. 33. But it may be said, if Pastors as Pastors must instruct gain-sayers of the truth, as 2 Tim. 2. 25. then may gain-sayers of the truth be Church-members; but the latter is absurd.
Then must pastors as pastors called of God preach to Church-members, as some other officers, either as ruling Elders, which confoundeth the preaching Elder, and the not preaching Elder, contrary to the 1 Cor. 12. 28. 1 Tim. 5. 17. or (2) as Doctors, which again confoundeth the teaching, and the exhorting Elder; contrary to Rom. 12. 7, 8. Ephes. 4. 11. or (3) as Deacons, which is popish: for deacons serve tables, but attend not to word and prayer, Act. 6. 2, 3, 4. or they preach to them, as private Christians, and unofficed persons, upon an intention to convert Church-members: for if only they preach as pastors to confirme them, not to convert them, they doe not fulfill their Ministery which they have received of the Lord, in all poi•ts, as they should, Colos. 4 17. then they use not the word as pastors, for all uses, for reproofe, for correction, for instruction, for righteousnesse, 2 Tim. 3. 16. nor doe they as pastors, preach in season and out of season, by reproving, rebuking, exhorting. (2) Then must all pastorall feeding formally be in confirming only, not in feeding, nor begetting to Christ, nor in restoring the lost, nor in bringing againe the driven away, nor in all these five points, Ezek. 35. 4. which are ascribed to Christ, who feedeth in his sent pastors, ver. 15. 16. Micah 5. ver. 4. nor in delivering the sheep ⟨p. 37⟩from the Lion and the wild beasts. Now this distinctions should be proved from the word of truth. 2. Then Pastors as watchmen give not warning of the sword, and of dying in sin, as Ezech. 3. 16, 17, 18, 19 20. Ezech. 33. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, &c. but as unofficed men, and private Christians. But that, way all the citizens of the city shall be made watchmen, which the Prophet Ezechiel and Ieremiah condemn, Ierem. 23. Ezech. 33. But it may be said, if Pastors as Pastors must instruct gain-sayers of the truth, as 2 Tim. 2. 25. then may gain-sayers of the truth be Church-members; but the latter is absurd.
Answ. It followeth not, this only followeth, Pastors may instruct gain-sayers and unconverted men, and intend their conversion in a Church-way, by preaching and otherwayes, viz. as pastors, but if these gain-sayers were Pagans and visible opposing Jews, they are not Church-members, nor can they be admitted while they remain such.
Answ. It followeth not, this onely followeth, Pastors may instruct gain-sayers and unconverted men, and intend their conversion in a Church-way, by preaching and otherwayes, viz. as pastors, but if these gain-sayers were Pagans and visible opposing Jews, they are not Church-members, nor can they be admitted while they remain such.
Answ. It is too loosely spoken, without further explanation. All heresies that are works of the flesh, as Socinianisms, &c. are called mistakes in judgment; and this may infer toleration of all Religions, and that men corrupt in their judgment may be truly godly; whereas soundness in the faith is a special part of godliness, nor can a good conscience and a sound faith be separated; see Mr Gillespie, Miscellany quest. chap. 12. pag. 142, 143. and consider whether then most of the Sectaries of our time may not be members of visible Churches at least; such a weighty point in one word, should not have been determined, nor can it be a sound inference.
Answ. It is too loosely spoken, without further explanation. All heresies that are works of the flesh, as Socinianisms, &c. are called mistakes in judgment; and this may infer toleration of all Religions, and that men corrupt in their judgment may be truly godly; wheras soundness in the faith is a special part of godliness, nor can a good conscience and a sound faith be separated; see Mr Gillespie, Miscellanie quest. chap. 12. pag. 142, 143. and consider whether then most of the Sectaries of our time may not be members of visible Churches at least; such a weighty point in one word, should not have been determined, nor can it be a sound inference.
The holding of the visible Churches in England to be true Churches (suppose it were an error, as it is not) doth not hinder men 1from being fit matter for a visible Church.
The holding of the visible Churches in England to be true Churches (suppose it were an errour, as it is not) doth not hinder men 1from being fit matter for a visible Church.
1See Answer to 32 questions. answer to sect. 9. q. 10. q. 1. q. 2 See M Baylie vindicat. of dissuasive an. 1655. pag. 1. c. 16. pag. 38. 39. Answer to 32. Quest. sect. 1. pag. 7. 8. 9. pag. 25. 26. 27. ans. to q. 10. p. 29.See Answer to 32 questions. answer to sect. 9. q. 10. q. 1. q. 2 See M Baylie vindicat. of disswasive an. 1655. pag. 1. c. 16. pag. 38. 39. Answer to 32. Quest. sect. 1. pag. 7. 8. 9. pag. 25. 26. 27. ans. to q. 10. p. 29.
Answ. If it be no error, to say that the Churches of England are true Churches, then is it true; and why is it then unlawful to enter in Church-fellowship with them; the contrary of which Mr H. proveth par. 1. ch. 12. pag. 32, 33. 2. Why doth Mr H. teach that the seals ought not to be given to Church-members of old England of approved piety, except they be inchurched their way: this saith that Mr H. holdeth that all that are not inchurched their way are no Church-members.
Answ. If it be no errour, to say that the Churches of England are true Churches, then is it true; and why is it then unlawful to enter in Church-fellowship with them; the contrary of which Mr H. proveth par. 1. ch. 12. pag. 32, 33. 2. Why doth Mr H. teach that the seals ought not to be gven to Church-members of old England of approved piety, except they be inchurched their way: this saith that Mr H. holdeth that all that are not inchurched their way are no Church-members.
Whether Mr Rutherfurd doth unjustly impute to Separatists that they hold that only such as are effectually called, justified and sanctified, to be the only matter of a rightly constituted Church.
Whether Mr Rutherfurd doth unjustly •mpute to Separatists that they hold that onely such as are effectually called, justified and sanctified, to be the onely matter of a rightly constituted Church.
Mr Hooker par. 1. ch. 2. pag. 20, 21, 22, &c. complaineth of Mr Rutherfurd that he dealeth not fairly and candidly with the brethren of the separation and others, and saith that they teach that only internally justified ones are the matter of the true visible Church; and he allegeth passages out of Mr Ainsworth and Mr Robinson, who though they speak in too narrow expressions, yet mind no such thing; for then they should be all chosen and elected that are members of the visible Church; which in words they openly deny.
Mr Hooker par. 1. ch. 2. pag. 20, 21, 22, &c. complaineth of Mr Rutherfurd that he dealeth not fairly and candidly with the brethren of the separation and others, and saith that they teach that onely internally justified ones are the matter of the true visible Church; and he alledgeth passages out of Mr Ainsworth and Mr Robinson, who though they speak in too narrow expressions, yet mind no such thing; for then they should be all chosen and elected that are members of the visible Church; which in words they openly deny.
Answ. I am conscious to my self of nothing, but a fair and Christian dealing with these godly men against whom I writ, and all that Mr H. bringeth, citations from Mr Ainsworth and Mr Robinson, I acknowledge in words saith the contrary of what I allege, and I know it to be so; but is it any thing against pious moderation, that I prove that their arguments contradict their conclusion? and that one place of M. Robinson contradicteth another; is it against pious moderation that Chamier, Pareus, Junius, Amesius, object to Bellarmine and to Papists (though I judge there be some difference in the matter) contradictions, that they writ things contrary to their ⟨p. 39⟩own grounds, and to things which they in open words peremptorily 1deny, as Mr Hooker speaketh, pag. 21, I confess if I make these contradictions not to appear, I wrong them either wilfully, which were in me wickedness; or if of ignorance, it is much weakness and more.
Answ. I am conscious to my self of nothing, but a fair and Christian dealing with these godly men against whom I writ, and all that Mr H. bringeth, citations from Mr Ainsworth and Mr Robinson, I acknowledge in words saith the contrary of what I alledge, and I know it to be so; but is it any thing against pious moderation, that I prove that their arguments contradict their conclusion? and that one place of M. Robinson contradicteth another; is it against pious moderation that Chamier, Pareus, Iunius, Amesius, object to Bellarmine and to Papists (though I judge there be some difference in the matter) contradictions, that they writ things contrary to their ⟨p. 39⟩own grounds, and to things which they in open words peremp•orily 1deny, as Mr Hooker speaketh, pag. 21, I confess if I make these contradictions not to appear, I wrong them either wilfully, which were in me wickedness; or if of ignorance, it is much weaknesse and more.
1Both Mr Hoo••r and M Robinson and the Sepaparatists teach that there can be none members of the visible Church but only real converts, and such as are chosen to life; and so contradict themselves, and this is no calumny which M. H. chargeth on them.Both Mr Hoo••r and M Robinson and the Sepaparatists teach that there can be none members of the visible Church but onely real converts, and such as are chosen to life; and so contradict themselves, and this is no calumny which M. H. chargeth on them.
But 1. as Mr Hooker bringeth citations from Mr Answorth, Mr Robinson, why doth he not from his own writings bring the 1like? for I allege the same against his own way; for the way of the Churches of New England Sect. 3. ch. 3. pag. 56, 57. faith more then the brethren of the separation eve• did say. The Lord Jesus is the head of the Church even the visible Church, and the visible Church is the body of Christ Jesus, 1 Cor. 12. 12. the habitation of God by the Spirit; Ephes. 2. 22. the members of the visible. Church are said to be the temples of the holy Ghost, 1 Cor. 3. 16. espoused to Christ, as a chaste virgin, 2 Cor. 11. 2. Sons and daughters of the Lord God almighty, 2 Cor. 6. 18. how can they be members of the body, or the spouse of Christ, &c. ex cept they in charitable disor•tion be ([…] indeed the holy Ghost describeth them to be) Saints by calling? 1 Cor. 1. 2. and faithful brethren, Gal. 1. 2. and that not by external profession, for these are too high styles for hypocrites, but in some measure of sincerity and truth.
But 1. as Mr Hooker bringeth citations from Mr Answorth, Mr Robinson, why doth he not from his own writings bring the 1like? for I alledge the same against his own way; for the way of the Churches of New England S•ct. 3. ch. 3. pag. 56, 57. faith more then the brethren of the separation eve• did say. The Lord Iesus is the head of the Church ev•n the visible Church, and the visible Church is the body of Christ Iesus, 1 Cor. 12. 12. the habitation of God by the Spirit; Ephes. 2. 22. the members of the visible. Church are said to be the temples of the holy Ghost, 1 Cor. 3. 16. espoused to Christ, as a chast virgin, 2 Cor. 11. 2. Sons and daughters of the Lord God almighty, 2 Cor. 6. 18. how can they be members of the body, or the spouse of Christ, &c. ex cept they in charitable disor•tion be (〈…〉 indeed the holy Ghost describeth them to be) Saints by calling? 1 Cor. 1. 2. and faithful brethren, Gal. 1. 2. and that not by external profession, for these are too high styles for hypocrites, but in some measure of sincerity and truth.
1So M. Robinson whom M. H. desends, justification of separation against Mr. R. Rernard, propos. 3. pag. 112. So hath every true visible Church of Christ direct and immediate interest in Christ, and title to Christ himself, and the whole N•w Testament. See pag. 113, 114, 115. Ans. Why saith he not the true visible Church hath direct and immediate interest in Christ, &c. in the judgment of charity; which is sometime Mr Hookers addition, and so he knows that Magus, Judas and such, have neither direct nor indirect, mediate nor immediate interest in Christ, but are Jeprous members. See pag. 95. The Scriptures never ascribe holiness to a people for some few sake, if the rest be unholy and profane. Answ. The man hath not read of Israel holy to the Lord, of Sardis with whom Christ was, where there were a remnant, and some few names only saved. See Robinson, pag. 96, 97, 98, 253, 258. mistaking the matter the same way.So M. Robinson whom M. H. desends, justification of separation against Mr. R. Rernard, propos. 3. pag. 112. So hath every true visible Church of Christ direct and immediate interest in Christ, and title to Christ himself, and the whole N•w Testament. See pag. 113, 114, 115. Ans. Why saith he not the true visible Church hath direct and immediate interest in Christ, &c. in the judgment of charity; which is sometime Mr Hookers addition, and so he knows that Magus, Iudas and such, have neither direct nor indirect, mediate nor immediate interest in Christ, but are Ieprous members. See pag. 95. The Scriptures never ascribe holiness to a people for some fews sake, if the rest be unholy and profane. Answ. The man hath not read of Israel holy to the Lord, of Sardis with whom Christ was, where there were a remnant, and some few names onely saved. See Robinson, pag. 96, 97, 98, 253, 258. mistaking the matter the same way.