A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
[9], 521 [i.e. 519] p. · 190k words · Wing R2395 · ESTC R19199
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. Whether the count that Watchmen, who must stand and feed, and not sleep, nor let the flock perish, Ezek. 3. Chap. 34. Isaiah 56. Zech. 11. lie upon unofficed brethren?
. and yet they are the only feeders, rulers, Judges of all to the highest censure of Excommunication. But all the qualifications that Mr. H. gives to the male unofficed Judges are saving grace of anointing,
. except women, aged children, servants, be excluded out of the number of the sheep of Christ, this is a turning of the Gospel upside down, to Popishly confine all the Privileges of Saints, the anointing the spiritual discerning
what key will open the heart, to some few male-believers: 1. Aged; 2. Incorporate, so and so. But I retort it thus: To whom Christ hath given the only qualifications spiritual of Rulers endued with power of judging, those hath he called according to the rule of the Gospel to be such Rulers, and they must dig their Lords talents in the earth, if they improve them not for that end. But the Lord hath given to all Believers as Believers of the same or of another flock, whether in Churches this way, or not, to women, as to males, in some measure, the anointing grace to know Christs voice. Ergo.
5. Whether the crime of usurping be theirs, and not the Prophets, Ierem. 23. and yet they are the onely feeders, rulers, Judges of all to the highest censure of Excommunication. But all the qualifications that Mr. H. gives to the male unofficed Judges are saving grace of anointing, 1 Ioh. 2. 20. 27. which women, who have Christ for their Advocate as well as men, 1 Ioh. 2. 1, 2. the discerning of the voice of Christ, and following him, which all the sheep and Elect of God have, Ioh. 10. 27, 28. except women, aged children, servants, be excluded out of the number of the sheep of Christ, this is a turning of the Gospel upside down, to Popishly confine all the Priviledges of Saints, the anointing the spiritual disce•ning 1what key will open the heart, to some few male-believers: 1. Aged; 2. Incorporate, so and so. But I retort it thus: To whom Christ hath given the onely qualifications spiritual of Rulers endued with power of judging, those hath he called according to the rule of the Gospel to be such Rulers, and they must dig their Lords talents in the earth, if they improve them not for that end. But the Lord hath given to all Beleevers as Beleevers of the same or of another flock, whether in Churches this way, or not, to women, as to males, in some measure, the anointing grace to know Christs voice. Ergo.
1The spiritual qualifications for calling of Ministers, as Mr. H. describeth them, as being able to relish the savour of spiritual administrations, to discern & know the voice of Christ & follow him, &c. are given to women and to all.
2. Let it be observed, that the tongue of the learned, Isaiah 50. of which Mr. R. spoke, to absolve and open heaven to a man swallowed up with grief, and a gift of a son of thunder, to shut the gates of heaven against the obstinate, and such as are to be delivered to Satan, are not required in the exercise of the keys of the Kingdom, but only such gifts as are in women; is this a good frame of Church discipline?
2. Let it be observed, that the tongue of the learned, Esay 50. of which Mr. R. spoke, to absolve and open heaven to a man swallowed up with griefe, and a gift of a son of thunder, to shut the gates of heaven against the obstinate, and such as are to be delivered to Sathan, are not required in the exercise of the keys of the Kingdome, but onely such gifts as are in women; is this a good frame of Church discipline?
Mr. H. God gives to men no calling to a place, but he gives 1rules how they are to order and direct themselves in it. But the Word hath no Canons how the people should order the Keys.
Mr. H. God gives to men no calling to a place, but he gives 1rules how they are to order and direct themselves in it. But the Word hath no Canons how the people should order the Keyes.
Answ. Matth. 18. 15. If thy brother, &c. The Lord points his finger to the Fescu•, and says, Build up one another in the most holy faith, 1 Thess. 5. 11, 12, 13. 2 Thess. 3. 14. Heb 13. 17. Rom. 16. 17. Observe those that cause dissentions among you, &c.
Ans. My Argument is mistaken. If there be Rules in the 1Word how Officers should acquit themselves, 1 Tim. 3. 1, 2, &c. how Judges, Kings, &c. so ought there to be Rules how unofficed brethren, the only Judges, (for Church-officers do but order and regulate judging, as our Brethren say) should behave themselves. But this is not by our Brethren's way.
Ans. My Argument is mistaken. If there be Rules in the 1Word how Officers should acquit themselves, 1 Tim. 3. 1, 2, &c. how Judges, Kings, &c. so ought there to be Rules how unofficed brethren, the onely Judges, (for Church-officers do but order and regulate judging, as our Brethren say) should behave themselves. But this is not by our Brethrens way.
1The argument of Mr. R. that there be no rules in the Word how the male-Church should rule & judge, Ergo, there is no such judging Church, stands unanswered. Mr. H. his way overturns the Ministry.
2. The Reader may observe all along, that Mr. H. and his way lays the Axe to the root of the Ministry; for he ascribeth the Church acts of office, of opening and shutting heaven, of the learned Tongue, of Excommunicating, &c. to unofficed men; or then he denies that there is any necessity of such in judging, and ascribes such acts and qualifications as are in women, to their judging Church; the very way of Anabaptists and rigid Separatists.
2. The Reader may observe all along, that Mr. H. and his way lays the Ax to the root of the Ministery; for he ascribeth the Church acts of office, of opening and shutting heaven, of the learned Tongue, of Excommunicating, &c. to unofficed men; or then he denies that there is any necessity of such in judging, and ascribes such acts and qualifications as are in women, to their judging Church; the very way of Anabaptists and rigid Separatists.
3. Mat. 18. 15. shall make every Church-member, brother 1or sister, who are to gain by admonishing one another, a Church-Judge, to exercise the Keys one over another. I thought the power had been given, not uni sed unitati, to brethren in the Judicature, not to stones scattered.
3. Mat. 18. 15. shall make every Church-member, brother 1or sister, who are to gain by admonishing one another, a Church-Judge, to exercise the Keyes one over another. I thought the power had been given, not uni sed unitati, to brethren in the Judicature, not to stones scattered.
1See Mr. John Collins his vindic. Minist. Evangel. an. 1651. the question accurately and clearly discussed. The Pulpit guarded with 20 Arg. an. 1652. A Plea for the use of Gospel-Ordinances, by Hen: Laurence against Mr. Dell, 1652. p. 44, 45. Vindication of Presbyt. Governm. and Ministry, by the Ministers of the Province of London, an. 1649. M Gillespy Miscel. q. 1. p. 1, 2, 3. &c. Vindic. Minist. Evang. by the Ministers of London. The Jus Divinum of Presbyt. c. 11. p. 180.See Mr. Iohn Collins his vindic. Minist. Evangel. an. 1651. the question accurately and clearly discussed. The Pulpit guarded with 20 Arg. an. 1652. A Plea for the use of Gospel-Ordinances, by Hen: Laurence against Mr. Dell, 1652. p. 44, 45. Vindication of Presbyt. Governm. and Ministry, by the Ministers of the Province of London, an. 1649. M Gillespy Miscel. q. 1. p. 1, 2, 3. &c. Vindic. Minist. Evang. by the Ministers of London. The Ius Divinum of Presbyt. c. 11. p. 180.
The edifying one of another, and comforting one another, and withdrawing from dividers, are acts of love required of men, women, and of Christians of all ranks, and by no word tied to those of the same single congregation, but to all the Catholic Church; should not women withdraw from dividers? and therefore these places, 1 Thess. 5. 11. 2 Thess. 3. Rom. 16. are abused.
The edifying one of another, and comforting one another, and withdrawing from dividers, are acts of love required of men, women, and of Christians of all ranks, and by no word tied to those of the same single congregation, but to all the Catholick Church; should not women withdraw from dividers? and therefore these places, 1 Thess. 5. 11. 2 Thess. 3. Rom. 16. are abused.
4. Ambrose, Theophylact, Oecumenius, Paraphrastes, Beza, Calvin, Marlorat, nor any Interpreter dreamed the place Heb. 13. 17. was meant of unofficed brethren, who watch and must 1give an account for souls: yea, Mr. H. expounds it of officers, and yet he cites Heb. 13. 17. Obey them that are over you in the Lord, i. e. Brethren of the male-Church obey brethren.
1Ch. 11. p. 191. M. H. his way destroys the ministry of the N. Testament.
Mr. H The power of the Keys is larger then the power of office, and therefore the Lord requires not so much abilities in the brethren as in the Officers.
Mr. H The prwer of the Keys is larger then the power of office, and therefore the Lord requires not so much abilities in the brethren as in the Officers.
2. If God require the highest abilities in officers to the laying 1on of hands, 1 Tim. 5. 22. to the highest censurer, 1 Tim. 19. 20, 21. compared with 1 Tim. 3. 1, 2, &c. 1 Tim. 3. 6. 7, &c. then he must require these same far more in brethren, the first and proper subject of all power, or then the Lord calls them to highest actings, and promises to them no gift to, or for these highest actings, such as delivering to Satan, cutting off of members.
1Mr. H. denies that the highest abilities that are required in the Epistles to Timothy & Titus, are required to be in such as open and shut Heaven by the Keys. Page 206.