Ans. My Argument is not faithfully repeated (of which I often complain) if the Ministerial formal power of ruling, and creating and unmaking of officers (a virtual power of which he of new speaks, I know not, for who hath the formal power ⟨p. 338⟩of calling officers then?) be given to believers, though destitute of Pastors, because believers are in a congregational frame 1built upon the Rock, nothing hindereth but ministerial power, that is the power of the Keys given to believers, which is but a gift given to hypocrites often, should be as firm as though believers were built on a rock. Mr. H denieth the Assumption only, and seems to yield the Proposition. I appeal to the Reader, if these words, I will build my Church (in the frame of a Congregation Independent) upon the Rock Christ, of the confession of Peter, have any such sense; for in all Scripture the building upon the rock hath no such sense, but noteth Christs building of real believers on himself in the most holy faith, which building cannot sail. And whereas Mr. H. saith, The visible Church cannot totally fail, as our Divines say, they mean the Catholic visible Church, and not your Independent congregations, of which they knew nothing who teach this Doctrine. So this Argument of mine stands. Promises of never falling are made in Scripture to things, not to persons, as to the Kingdom, to the Gospel, to the Dominion of Christ, Psal. 72. 8. Isa. 9. 7. Luke 1. 33. Isa. 55. 11. Psal. 110. 2. Mat. 24. 14, &c. but ever in order to persons, especially to that excellentest of persons: But of temptations to offices, and institutions and promises to such, as here, we read not.
Ans. My Argument is not faithfully repeated (of which I often complain) if the Ministerial formal power of ruling, and creating and unmaking of officers (a virtual power of which he of new speaks, I know not, for who hath the formal power ⟨p. 338⟩of calling officers then?) be given to believers, though destitute of Pastors, because believers are in a congregational frame 1built upon the Rock, nothing hindreth but ministerial power, that is the power of the Keys given to believers, which is but a gift given to hypocrites often, should be as firm as though believers were built on a rock. Mr. H denieth the Assumption onely, and seems to yield the Proposition. I appeal to the Reader, if these words, I will build my Church (in the frame of a Congregation Independent) upon the Rock Christ, of the confession of Peter, have any such sense; for in all Scripture the building upon the rock hath no such sense, but noteth Christs building of real believers on himself in the most holy faith, which building cannot sail. And whereas Mr. H. saith, The visible Church cannot totally fail, as our Divines say, they mean the Catholick visible Church, and not your Independent congregations, of which they knew nothing who teach this Doctrine. So this Argument of mine stands. Promises of never falling are made in Scripture to things, not to persons, as to the Kingdome, to the Gospel, to the Dominion of Christ, Psal. 72. 8. Isa. 9. 7. Luke 1. 33. Isa. 55. 11. Psal. 110. 2. Mat. 24. 14, &c. but ever in order to persons, especially to that excellentest of persons: But of temptations to offices, and institutions and promises to such, as here, we reade not.
- 1If to be built upon the Rock be to be built in a congregational Church-frame, then the gates of Hell cannot prevail against the office, against the visible frame of congregations. Some of our Divines make the Church of believers, men and women, the virtual subject of the Keys, and of all Church-power. But Mr. H. maketh them more than a virtual subject, for he must make the formal calling and creating of officers, and excommunicating of them, and so preaching, as was the Apostle Peters case, Act. 1. 15. and the Prophets, Act. 13, 3. who prayed and laid on hands on Saul and Barnabas, and sent them as Apostles to the Gentiles, a formal act of the Church of Redeemed ones, men and women, servants and children, for which we have no Scripture, and as little Reason, for we may so say the Flint formally makes fire. Hist. Magdeb. Vol. 1. Cen. 1. l. 1. c. 4. p. 138.