Ans. To begin with what Amesius saith, its utterly impertinent: 1The title of that Chapter is of the Mystical Church, the members of which can never fall away, but must be until the end of the world, as the title of the next Chapter is of the instituted Church; yea, Am•sius saith, this place Matth. 16. is a special promise made to those built on a Rock, to the Militant Catholic Church, and to real believers only, not to hypocrites. Mr. H. by this teacheth the Patrons of the Apostasy of the Saints, a distinction useful for their Error. So cinus saith, The places which saith, They are saved who are written in the Book of Life before the world was, do not speak of some particular man th•• or that, (as Mr. H. this or that single Church may fall off the Rock) but some kind of men, and therefore Mr. H. renders this a comfortless doctrine, which Christ makes a singular bulwark of Faith and Consolation to single persons, Peter, Mary, who believe, and are built upon the Rock, that such shall never fall away; but this or that congregation of some few persons, though true and real believers, may and do fall away. This is the down-right Apostasy of believers.
Ans. To begin with what Amesius saith, its utterly impertinent: 1The title of that Chapter is of the Mystical Church, the members of which can never fall away, but must be until the end of the world, as the title of the next Chapter is of the instituted Church; yea, Am•sius saith, this place Matth. 16. is a special promise made to those built on a Rock, to the Militant Catholick Church, and to real believers onely, not to hypocrites. Mr. H. by this teacheth the Patrons of the Apostasie of the Saints, a distinction useful for their Errour. So cinus saith, The places which saith, They are saved who are written in the Book of Life before the world was, do not speak of some particular man th•• or that, (as Mr. H. this or that single Church may fall off the Rock) but some kinde of men, and therefore Mr. H. renders this a comfortless doctrine, which Christ makes a singular bulwark of Faith and Consolation to single persons, Peter, Mary, who believe, and are built upon the Rock, that such shall never fall away; but this or that congregation of some few persons, though true and real believers, may and do fall away. This is the down-right Apostasie of believers.
- 1Ames. Medul. lib. 1. c. 31. De Ecclesia mysticè considerata. Cap. 32. De Ecclesia instituta. Mr. H. his Exposition of Matth. 16. 18. infers the apostasy of real believers. Ames. Coronis art. 5. de perserver. arg▪ 2: pag. 413, 414. Si damnatio sola fidelium per has portas intelligatur, tum consistere potest haec promissio cum totali defectu Ecclesi• militantis, nihil enim sponderet militantibus (Ecclesiae Catholicae membris, ut ex seri• discurfus) sed solis desunctis. Socinus in praelect. Theolog. c. 13. p. 71. Si tamen placeat eos qui in praedictis locis in lib. vitae à constitution mundi scripti esse dicuntur, satis est ostendisse ibi non de•certis quibusdam hominibus agi, sed de hominum quodam genere. Pag. 72. Verum nomen alicujus scriptum esse […] libro vitae, non significat eum nullâ ratione prorsus interire posse.Ames. Medul. lib. 1. c. 31. De Ecclesia mysticè considerata. Cap. 32. De Ecclesia instituta. Mr. H. his Exposition of Matth. 16. 18. infers the apostasie of real believers. Ames. Coronis art. 5. de perserver. arg▪ 2: pag. 413, 414. Si damnatio sola fidelium per has portas intelligatur, tum consistere potest haec promissio cum totali defectu Ecclesi• militantis, nihil enim sponderet militantibus (Ecclesiae Catholicae membris, ut ex seri• discurfus) sed solis desunctis. Socinus in praelect. Theolog. c. 13. p. 71. Si tamen placeat eos qui in praedictis locis in lib. vitae à constitutione mundi scripti esse dicuntur, satis est ostendisse ibi non de•certis quibusdam hominibus agi, sed de hominum quodam genere. Pag. 72. Verum nomen alicujus scriptum esse 〈…〉 libro vitae, non significat eum nullâ ratione prorsus interire posse.