A57981:1744
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Yea, This special power of the Keys is but a part, or a certain kind and species of the power of the Keys in some rare and extraordinary things that belong to the Catholic Church. But we are now disputing of the first seat and subject of the power of the Keys in general, in the latitude of binding and loosing, opening and shutting the gates of heaven by preaching and censures. And I deny expressly that an Oecumenick Council is the first subject of the power of the Keys in this general. And so Mr. H. fights with a shadow. Non concludit negatum. So my Simile is never touched by Mr. H. as pag. 305. The light is first in the whole body of the Sun, as the first and prime subject of light; yet supposing now the received opinion of Astronomers, that the Sun doth exceed the quantity of the Earth 167, it doth not follow, that this or that part of the Sun hath no light in it intrinsical, but that which is derived from the whole body of the Sun, for then this or that part of the Sun should have light derived to it (extrinsically) from some other.
Yea, This special power of the Keyes is but a part, or a certain kind and species of the power of the Keyes in some rare and extraordinary things that belong to the Catholick Church. But we are now disputing of the first seat and subject of the power of the Keyes in general, in the latitude of binding and loosing, opening and shutting the gates of heaven by preaching and censures. And I deny expresly that an Oecumenick Councel is the first subject of the power of the Keyes in this general. And so Mr. H. fights with a shadow. Non concludit negatum. So my Simile is never touched by Mr. H. as pag. 305. The light is first in the whole body of the Sun, as the first and prime subject of light; yet supposing now the received opinion of Astronomers, that the Sun doth exceed the quantity of the Earth 167, it doth not follow, that this or that part of the Sun hath no light in it intrinsecal, but that which is derived from the whole body of the Sun, for then this or that part of the Sun should have light derived to it (extrinsecally) from some other.
Now the power of the Keys is in the whole Catholic Body of Apostles, Pastors, Doctors, Elders, all the world over, as they act respectively in Congregations, Presbyteries and Synods of all sorts, so that one part of the Catholic integral body of the Catholic Church, for example, hath not that power of the Keys due to them, derived from the Presbytery to the congregational Eldership, or from the Synod derived to the Presbytery, and so forth, by either ascending or descending: But when Christ gave the whole power of the Keys to the body of the Apostles, Mat. 28. 19. & 16. 19. Joh. 20. 21, 22, 23 Mar. 16. 15. they were the Body Representative (I never call them an Oecumenick Council) and did immediately represent any Apostles to be chosen, Matthias, Paul, Evangelists, Pastors, Doctors, Elders, that were to be, even to the second coming of Christ, and he promiseth his Ministerial Spiritual presence to them all immediately, Mat. 28. 20 Go teach and baptize—lo, I am with you always, (administering Word, Seals, Censures, according to the Rule) even to the end of the world. Now the Apostles were not to live preaching and baptizing to the end of the world, therefore the promise must be made to them all, though not yet born. Now we read not of deriving of any ⟨p. 383⟩power to Synods, Presbyteries, Congregations, by mediation of Churches, for Christ instituted Synods, Mat. 28. 16. Act. 1. 12, 13, 14, &c. & 6. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. & 13. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. & 15. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, &c. and that immediately he instituted Presbyterial Churches, Act. 2. & 4. 9. & 5. 21, 42. and Churches congregational to meet in one place, 1 Cor. 11. 17. And as one part of the Element of water (suppose we make 24 parts of all) hath not natural moistness and cold from the other 20 parts, but hath it as intrinsically, without the intervening influence of the other twenty three parts, as they have: So the Presbyterial and Congregational Eldership have as primarily, intrinsically, immediately in their sphere and orb the Keys due to them, according to the proportion of the associated body, as the whole integral-Catholic Presbytery and Church hath, whether in an Oecumenick Council, or out of it.
Now the power of the Keys is in the whole Catholick Body of Apostles, Pastors, Doctors, Elders, all the world over, as they act respectively in Congregations, Presbyteries and Synods of all sorts, so that one part of the Catholick integral body of the Catholick Church, for example, hath not that power of the Keys due to them, derived from the Presbytery to the congregational Eldership, or from the Synod derived to the Presbytery, and so forth, by either ascending or descending: But when Christ gave the whole power of the Keys to the body of the Apostles, Mat. 28. 19. & 16. 19. Ioh. 20. 21, 22, 23 Mar. 16. 15. they were the Body Representative (I never call them an Oecumenick Councel) and did immediately represent any Apostles to be chosen, Matthias, Paul, Evangelists, Pastors, Doctors, Elders, that were to be, even to the second coming of Christ, and he promiseth his Ministerial Spiritual presence to them all immediately, Mat. 28. 20 Go teach and baptize—lo, I am with you always, (administring Word, Seals, Censures, according to the Rule) even to the end of the world. Now the Apostles were not to live preaching and baptizing to the end of the world, therefore the promise must be made to them all, though not yet born. Now we reade not of deriving of any ⟨p. 383⟩power to Synods, Presbyteries, Congregations, by mediation of Churches, for Christ instituted Synods, Mat. 28. 16. Act. 1. 12, 13, 14, &c. & 6. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. & 13. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. & 15. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, &c. and that immediately he instituted Presbyterial Churches, Act. 2. & 4. 9. & 5. 21, 42. and Churches congregational to meet in one place, 1 Cor. 11. 17. And as one part of the Element of water (suppose we make 24 parts of all) hath not natural moistness and cold from the other 20 parts, but hath it as intrinsecally, without the intervening influence of the other twenty three parts, as they have: So the Presbyterial and Congregational Eldership have as primarily, intrinsecally, immediately in their sphere and orb the Keys due to them, according to the proportion of the associated body, as the whole integral-Catholick Presbytery and Church hath, whether in an Oecumenick Councel, or out of it.
It is then a wide mistake in Mr. H. to tell us, If an Ecumenical Council be the first subject of the Keys, (as it is not) that there can be no act of power in ordaining of Ministers, in excommunicating of delinquents, but by virtue of an Ecumenical Council giving their influence first to that work. For if the meaning be (as it must be) that a General Council must prove an act, and put forth some actual Mandate, commanding such a man to be ordained an officer, such a delinquent to be excommunicate, else the Churches cannot proceed: for to take Mr H. his own comparison, Richard or Joshua cannot be a man, or apt to laugh, except the abstract nature of man give in his influence to the work. And since Mr. H. and his Brethren make the male-congregation 1abstracted from this or that congregation, the first formal subject of the whole power of the Keys, what influence (I ask) doth the so abstract congregation give to the work of Ordination and Excommunication in a particular congregation? Abstracted natures do not send abroad mandates to all the congregations all the world over, before they can ordain, censure, or excommunicate. If it be said, this agrees to the nature of a congregation in general to ordain and excommunicate, but there needs no other actual influence of a command to come from the congregation in general to this individual congregation for their using of the Keys. True, there needs not, by the like, ⟨p. 384⟩that any mandate pass from the Oecumenick Council in general, to this or that individual Oecumenick Council in the exercise of its Synodical acts.
It is then a wide mistake in Mr. H. to tell us, If an Oecumenical Councel be the first subject of the Keys, (as it is not) that there can be no act of power in ordaining of Ministers, in excommunicating of delinquents, but by vertue of an Oecumenical Councel giving their influence first to that work. For if the meaning be (as it must be) that a General Councel must prove an act, and put forth some actual Mandate, commanding such a man to be ordained an officer, such a delinquent to be excommunicate, else the Churches cannot proceed: for to take Mr H. his own comparison, Richard or Ioshua cannot be a man, or apt to laugh, except the abstract nature of man give in his influence to the work. And since Mr. H. and his Brethren make the male-congregation 1abstracted from this or that congregation, the first formal subject of the whole power of the Keys, what influence (I ask) doth the so abstract congregation give to the work of Ordination and Excommunication in a particular congregation? Abstracted natures do not send abroad mandates to all the congregations all the world over, before they can ordain, censure, or excommunicate. If it be said, this agrees to the nature of a congregation in general to ordain and excommunicate, but there needs no other actual influence of a command to come from the congregation in general to this individual congregation for their using of the Keys. True, there needs not, by the like, ⟨p. 384⟩that any mandate pass from the Oecumenick Councel in general, to this or that individual Oecumenick Councel in the exercise of its Synodical acts.
- 1M. H. Survey, par. 1. c. 11. p. 186. Way of the Churches, c. 1. sect. 1. pro. 3. M. Cotton keys. c. 7. p. 31.
But (saith Mr. H.) if the Oecumenick Council be the first formal subject of the power of the Keys, then inferior Courts cannot ordain nor excommunicate without a warrant, and actual command from them.
But (saith Mr. H.) if the Oecumenick Councel be the first formal subject of the power of the Keys, then inferiour Courts cannot ordain nor excommunicate without a warrant, and actual command from them.
Ans. This is feeble: for beside that the Oecumenick Council 1is not at all any such formal first subject, as is said, its a naughty consequence; for though power of life and death be in King and Parliament as in the first subject, it follows not that an inferior Judge or free City cannot put to death notorious Traitors and Murderers all England over, without the influence of some actual Mandate from King and Parliament to the putting to death of every Traitor. So when Christ gave power of Word, Seals and Censures to the Apostles, as representing all officers, (say we) or as representing all believers (saith Mr. H.) it follows, that officers and the male-Church cannot administer Word, Seals, Censures, without the influence of a new actual command from the Apostles, who did represent all such to whom Jesus Christ gave the Keys, by this arguing of Mr. H.
Ans. This is feeble: for beside that the Oecumenick Councel 1is not at all any such formal first subject, as is said, its a naughty consequence; for though power of life and death be in King and Parliament as in the first subject, it follows not that an inferiour Judge or free City cannot put to death notorious Traitors and Murtherers all England over, without the influence of some actual Mandate from King and Parliament to the putting to death of every Traitor. So when Christ gave power of Word, Seals and Censures to the Apostles, as representing all officers, (say we) or as representing all believers (saith Mr. H.) it follows, that officers and the male-Church cannot administer Word, Seals, Censures, without the influence of a new actual command from the Apostles, who did represent all such to whom Jesus Christ gave the Keyes, by this arguing of Mr. H.
- 1Inferior courts may use the keys without any influence of a command from a general Councel.
Nor does Mr. H. his first deduction follow, that if a General Council be such a subject (as it is not) that therefore the existing 1of such a Council is as necessary as the well-being of the Church. For a Parliamentary power is necessary for England, yet suppose by war, and other invincible impediments, a Parliament could not meet for divers years, yet neither power nor exercise of Justice do cease. So here Synodical power may be, and by the care of the Lord of his House, is continued in lesser Assemblies, though such Councils exist not. But 2. the Antecedent being true, the Consequence is null.
Nor does Mr. H. his first deduction follow, that if a General Councel be such a subject (as it is not) that therefore the existing 1of such a Councel is as necessary as the well-being of the Church. For a Parliamentary power is necessary for England, yet suppose by war, and other invincible impediments, a Parliament could not meet for divers years, yet neither power nor exercise of Justice do cease. So here Synodical power may be, and by the care of the Lord of his House, is continued in lesser Assemblies, though such Councels exist not. But 2. the Antecedent being true, the Consequence is null.
- 1Though a general Councel exist not, yet •he use of the keys ceaseth not in inferior courts.Though a general Councel •xist not, yet •he use of the keys ceaseth not in inferior courts.
Nor is the power of the Keys in its latitude, as is said, either firstly or only, and so not perfectly in this Council, but firstly and intrinsically in the whole integral Presbytery all the earth over.
Nor is the power of the Keyes in its latitude, as is said, either firstly or onely, and so not perfectly in this Councel, but firstly and intrinsecally in the whole integral Presbytery all the earth over.
Nor is it necessary that this General Council, though it were the first subject of the Keys, always attain all its end in the use of ⟨p. 385⟩the Keys. For the male-Church void of Pastors cannot attain all its end, to wit, the pastoral preaching, the dogmatic and official sentencing of delinquents, the right tendering of the seals, yet is the male-Church the only formal subject of this power to Mr. H.
Nor is it necessary that this General Councel, though it were the first subject of the Keys, always attain all its end in the use of ⟨p. 385⟩the Keyes. For the male-Church void of Pastors cannot attain all its end, to wit, the pastoral preaching, the dogmatick and official sentencing of delinquents, the right tendring of the seals, yet is the male-Church the onely formal subject of this power to Mr. H.
Mr. R. said well, that a General Council can hardly excommunicate 1a whole National Church: for it could hardly be known to them, but many are not obstinate in the National Heresy and Scandal, who through weakness and fear of persecution dare not confess. And its enough that a National Church may be declared to be no Church: as Moses removed the Tabernacle, and pitched it without the camp, Exod. 33. 7. and Paul turned away from the blaspheming Jews Acts. 13. 45, 46. and yet neither the one nor the other is the excommunicating of a National Church, for the word of the Covenant remained in the Nation of the Jews, after Paul and Barnabas turned from them, and preached to the Gentiles, Jam. 1. 1. Heb. 1. 1. & 3. 6. & 10. 25. 1 Pet. 1 1. 1 Joh. 1. 1. & 2. 1, 2. Nor is our Brethren's new censure 2of non communion of Churches so warrantable. For,
Mr. R. said well, that a General Councel can hardly excommunicate 1a whole National Church: for it could hardly be known to them, but many are not obstinate in the National Heresie and Scandal, who through weakness and fear of persecution dare not confess. And its enough that a National Church may be declared to be no Church: as Moses removed the Tabernacle, and pitched it without the camp, Exod. 33. 7. and Paul turned away from the blaspheming Jews Acts. 13. 45, 46. and yet neither the one nor the other is the excommunicating of a National Church, for the word of the Covenant remained in the Nation of the Jews, after Paul and Barnabas turned from them, and preached to the Gentiles, Iam. 1. 1. Heb. 1. 1. & 3. 6. & 10. 25. 1 Pet. 1 1. 1 Ioh. 1. 1. & 2. 1, 2. Nor is our Brethrens new censure 2of non communion of Churches so warrantable. For,
- 1Hardly can a general Councel excommunicate a National Church.
- 2Non-communion of Churches, as our Brethren use it, is not warrantable.
1. The removing of the Candlestick seems to be a judgment inflicted only by Jesus Christ; and they who declare such a society to be no Church, must have the warrant of Christ going before, and really removing the Gospel. For if the Word, the contract of marriage, and seals, remain there in their substance, they can only (the profession thereof not ceasing) declare them an impure and corrupt Church, but not to be no Church.
1. The removing of the Candlestick seems to be a judgment inflicted onely by Jesus Christ; and they who declare such a society to be no Church, must have the warrant of Christ going before, and really removing the Gospel. For if the Word, the contract of marriage, and seals, remain there in their substance, they can only (the profession thereof not ceasing) declare them an impure and corrupt Church, but not to be no Church.
2. The doctrine or practise of a Church may be erroneous, hurtful 1and destructive to holiness, as that of Pergamus and Thyatira, and they defend it; and yet remaining sound in other points, they cease not to be a people in covenant with God, and they cannot be declared no Church, and the Ministerial acts of baptizing invalid, and to be reiterate, as is clear in the Church of the Jews, though Idolatrous, and in the Scribes and Pharisees, corrupt the same way in practise and doctrine, whom Christ commandeth to hear, Mat. 23. 1, 2. far more for a sinful act of Jurisdiction, leave they not off to be a Church.
- 1See the paper of Accommodation at the Synod at Westminster, anno 1644. Sept. 13.
3. How can it be clear to a sister-Church, that there are not there, the Church being above a thousand, or many Churches, ⟨p. 386⟩(for many Churches may be unchurched as well as one) a few names that out of weakness only are silent at the sinful doctrine and practise of the Church.
3. How can it be clear to a sister-Church, that there are not there, the Church being above a thousand, or many Churches, ⟨p. 386⟩(for many Churches may be unchurched as well as one) a few names that out of weakness onely are silent at the sinful doctrine and practise of the Church.
4. Its hard to say the Church of Rome, in which there are the matrimonial Tables, the Old and New Testament, valid Baptism, and Salvation to a covenanted people by the fundamentals preached, is no Church, though communion with such a Whore be unlawful.
Mr. H. If the Churches refuse the sentence of Excommunication 1inflicted by the Court Ecumenical, it can never prevail to attain its end.
Mr. H. If the Churches refuse the sentence of Excommunication 1inflicted by the Court O•cumenical, it can never prevail to attain its end.
- 1Par. 1. c. 13. p. 234, 235.
Ans. Ergo, its unlawful. It follows not, the Churches, the 1person excommunicate refuse to abstain from the society of one excommunicate, and excommunication hardens and humbles not; Ergo, its unlawful: So the Gospel is the savour of death unto death, 2 Cor. 2. 16, a Rock of stumbling, 1 Pet. 2. 8. and prepared vengeance, 2 Cor. 10. 6. to some; Ergo, its not the Word of God. Many such consequences have been drawn, to make Mr. R. his way odious to the godly. But I desire to contend for truth.
- 1Excommunication attaineth not its end alway; Ergo, is not lawful. M. H. so, Nor doth the Gospel ever attain its saving end; Ergo, its not the Gospel.
Mr. H. To the Ministry and Catholic Guides of that visible Church, hath Christ committed the Keys as the first subject, to the which he hath given his Word, Ordinances, Sacraments, Ministry primarily. This is Mr. R. his in terminis determinate conclusion beyond all gainsaying. But to the Oecumenick Council, as the Representative of all Churches, God hath not primarily given his Ministry, Word, Sacraments, Ordinances; then an Oecumenick Representative Church hath not the Keys given to it as to the first subject. The Assumption only needs proof. 1. There was no such Council for 300 years after Christ. 2. Councils consist primarily of Pastors and Elders; then must Ministers be sent to feed Ministers. 3. Word and Seals are not primarily attended in Councils, but scanning of controversies.
Mr. H. To the Ministery and Catholick Guides of that visible Church, hath Christ committed the Keys as the first subject, to the which he hath given his Word, Ordinances, Sacraments, Ministery primarily. This is Mr. R. his in terminis determinate conclusion beyond all gainsaying. But to the Oecumenick Councel, as the Representative of all Churches, God hath not primarily given his Ministery, Word, Sacraments, Ordinances; then an Oecumenick Representive Church hath not the Keys given to it as to the first subject. The Assumption onely needs proof. 1. There was no such Councel for 300 years after Christ. 2. Councels consist primarily of Pastors and Elders; then must Ministers be sent to feed Ministers. 3. Word and Seals are not primarily attended in Councels, but scanning of controversies.