3. Visible Saints by this shall not be the same spiritually politic body, visible, being of divers congregations: contrary to Scripture, expounded by Mr. H. and Mr. Cotton, we being many ⟨p. 393⟩are one body visible, and visible of twenty congregations, partaking 1of one bread and body of Christ. Now by this, as a finger cut off Paul, is not a finger cut off John, for John hath all his ten fingers entire, and Paul hath his nine fingers only: So also if Thomas disobedient he cast out of only his own congregation, he is never cast out of Church-right to Christ, and ordinances in the rest of the congregations; for excommunication by consequence, is only a declaring by witnesses (as Mr. H. saith pag. 242.) that the man is cast out of his own congregation. Now the declaring that Paul's finger is cut off, is not a cutting off of his finger, that is impossible. Far less is it possible, that the declaring that Paul's finger is cut off, can be either a declaring that Peters finger is cut off, or that that declaring is a cutting off of Paul's finger, or a cutting off of Peters finger. Therefore Peters being cast one of his own Church-right, and Church only, is no casting of him out of other Churches, or real removing of his Church-right to ordinances in other Churches. For that which was never really removed, and Peter once had, it must remain with Peter yet: now Peter was never a member of any congregation but of one; then membership to another congregation cannot be taken from him.
3. Visible Saints by this shall not be the same spiritually politick body, visible, being of divers congregations: contrary to Scripture, expounded by Mr. H. and Mr. Cotton, we being many ⟨p. 393⟩are one body visible, and visible of twenty congregations, partaking 1of one bread and body of Christ. Now by this, as a finger cut off Paul, is not a finger cut off Iohn, for Iohn hath all his ten fingers entire, and Paul hath his nine fingers only: So also if Thomas disobedient he cast out of only his own congregation, he is never cast out of Church-right to Christ, and ordinances in the rest of the congregations; for excommunication by consequence, is only a declaring by witnesses (as Mr. H. saith pag. 242.) that the man is cast out of his own congregation. Now the declaring that Paul's finger is cut off, is not a cutting off of his finger, that is impossible. Far less is it possible, that the declaring that Paul's finger is cut off, can be either a declaring that Peters finger is cut off, or that that declaring is a cutting off of Paul's finger, or a cutting off of Peters finger. Therefore Peters being cast one of his own Church-right, and Church only, is no casting of him out of other Churches, or real removing of his Church-right to ordinances in other Churches. For that which was never really removed, and Peter once had, it must remain with Peter yet: now Peter was never a member of any congregation but of one; then membership to another congregation cannot be taken from him.
- 11 Cor. 10. 17. [Greek or Hebrew]. Excommunication by consequence is no excommunication at all.1 Cor. 10. 17. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Excommunication by consequence is no excommunication at all.