A57981:2036
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ans. I shall not invite Anabaptists to triumph in pulling this 1Argument for Infant-baptism from our Divines; for if the words must be expounded of actual love to God, and actual obedience in Infants; so that, if Infants be not capable of actual love and obedience to God, the covenant-mercy must be broken off in all Infants who die before they can come to years to actually to love the Lord, and keep his commandments; And if the flux of covenant-mercy be suspended, while Infants come to be capable to actually love God and obey him; where then shall be covenant right in the males of the Jews to be circumcised, and in the Infants born of covenanted parents under the New Testament to be baptized? For the Argument, if any be, must be thus:
- 1Mr. H. denies covenant right to baptism to Infants, as Anabaptists do, because they do not actually love & obey God.
To such as cannot actually love God and keep his commandments ⟨p. 452⟩for want of age, there be no covenant-right to Baptism 1conveyed. But this want of age and capacity to love God and actually obey him, is in all Infants in Old or New Testament; except Mr. H. mean, that nearest parents can supply the want of capacity, and infuse actual understanding to Infants, that they may actually love God, and keep his commandments, which remote parents cannot do, which is a mystery I am yet to learn. But to the Reader it is clear, that Infants have no right to Baptism until they come to years to actually love God; Ergo, they should not be baptized until they be converted. But again, no Anabaptist teacheth, that any are to be baptized by covenant-right from parents near or remote, except they personally believe and profess actually: and the very like Mr. H. saith.
- 1Yea, Infants of Turks come to age, if they actually love & actually obey God, and by faith lay hold on his covenant the Lord extends mercy to them, I• 56. 4, 5, 6, 7 thin infants have nothing by nearest or remote parents, but what they have without them. Survey, par. 3. […]. 2. p. 15, 16.Yea, Infants of Turks come to age, if they actually love & actually obey God, and by faith lay hold on his covenāt the Lord extends mercy to them, I• 56. 4, 5, 6, 7 thin infants have nothing by nearest or remote parents, but what they have without them. Survey, par. 3. 〈…〉. 2. p. 15, 16.
Mr. H. Where shall we stand if a thousand generations have interest in Baptism? Then the children of Turks cannot be excluded, for some of them are found between us and Adam.
Ans. Is not this to cavil at the Lords words, not at us? so they set this Conjecture down as a part of their Discipline; Its not above 66 generations from Noah to Christ,—and if Gods mercy to a thousand generations may fetch in the children of excommunicated 1persons, the same promise may fetch in all Turks and Infidels at this day. But I pray you are Turks such as love God and keep his commandments? are not Turks avowed enemies to Christ and the Gospel-covenant? and so for many generations have deserted the covenant and visible Church, so that they are no visible Church, the Lord having removed the Candlestick: Can this be said of children born in the visible Church, either of the Jews or of Christians professors, because their nearest parents are extreme wicked or excommunicated, since they are yet born in the visible Church where the Candlestick is? shall the children be cut off from circumcision, since the Lord for Abraham, for Davids sake, for the holy Roots sake (not the nearest, who were most unholy, and cast out, Rom. 11. 7.) gives circumcision and Church-room to the branches, Rom. 11. 16? And if the child of nearest parents excommunicated be born in 2a believers house, or resigned to a believer, to be brought up as his own, he is to be baptized, say our Brethren; but the being so born, hinders not the child's cutting off from the covenant. ⟨p. 453⟩Where then is his covenant-right to baptism? Its either from his remote parents, which we say; I will be thy God, and the God of thy seed: or from his nearest excommunicate parents. This latter Mr. H. denies: or from the Believer, in whose house he was born. If so, we shall not contend, then the covenant right is not broken and removed, because the nearest parents are excommunicate. Some parental covenant-right is conveyed to this Infant, which is not conveyable to the Infant of a Turk.
Ans. Is not this to cavil at the Lords words, not at us? so they set this Conjecture down as a part of their Discipline; Its not above 66 generations from Noah to Christ,—and if Gods mercy to a thousand generations may fetch in the children of excommunicated 1persons, the same promise may fetch in all Turks and Infidels at this day. But I pray you are Turks such as love God and keep his commandments? are not Turks avowed enemies to Christ and the Gospel-covenant? and so for many generations have deserted the covenant and visible Church, so that they are no visible Church, the Lord having removed the Candlestick: Can this be said of children born in the visible Church, either of the Jews or of Christians professors, because their nearest parents are extreme wicked or excommunicated, since they are yet born in the visible Church where the Candlestick is? shall the children be cut off from circumcision, since the Lord for Abraham, for Davids sake, for the holy Roots sake (not the nearest, who were most unholy, and cast out, Rom. 11. 7.) gives circumcision and Church-room to the branches, Rom. 11. 16? And if the child of nearest parents excommunicated be born in 2a believers house, or resigned to a believer, to be brought up as his own, he is to be baptized, say our Brethren; but the being so born, hinders not the childs cutting off from the covenant. ⟨p. 453⟩Where then is his covenant-right to baptism? Its either from his remote parents, which we say; I will be thy God, and the God of thy seed: or from his nearest excommunicate parents. This latter Mr. H. denies: or from the Beleever, in whose house he was born. If so, we shall not contend, then the covenantright is not broken and removed, because the nearest parents are excommunicate. Some parental covenant-right is conveyed to this Infant, which is not conveyable to the Infant of a Turk.
- 1Way of the Churches of N. E. c. 4. sec. 6. p. 87.
- 2Way of the Churches, ib. c. 4. sect. 6. p. •8.
2. Mr. H. hath the words of the second Command for his party: for, i• the nearest parents excommunication deprive the children of all covenant-mercy and right to the seals, the words should be false, and the Lord should be less in showing mercy, in extending it to one generation only, to the nearest children only, for their nearest parents loving of God, and keeping of his Commandments, and more abundant in severity of justice, in visiting the sins of the Fathers upon the Children, unto the third 1and fourth Generation of them that hate him. But this turns the promise and the threatening of the Command upside down, for mercy is so extended to Fathers nearest & nearest Children, and punishing justice to four, and the command extends mercy unto thousands, & justice to only four Generations. Now two Generations, as they are fewer then four, so are they far more fewer then a thousand Generations: as also, if mercy extended to a thousand Generations, only be upon condition, they imitate their godly parents (saith Mr. H.) by loving (actually) and obeying (actually) his Commandments, especially that of the truth of his worship, then is mercy not extended to the nearest one generation of Infants; for it is certain the nearest one generation of Infants cannot be yet capable (saith Mr. H. with the same 2breath) being not come to years to put forth such acts of actual love and obedience in worshipping the true God, as he hath commanded in his word: and if mercy be not extended to one generation, nor Covenant-seals to Ishmael, for Abraham's, nor to Esau for Isaacs sake, contrary to all Scripture: the Lord shows not mercy to thousands of generations, because not to one generation. And so again, the promise of mercy is destroyed, for the condition of actual love, and of actual obedience ⟨p. 454⟩is physically impossible to all sorts of Infants, both of Parents loving or hating God.
2. Mr. H. hath the words of the second Command for his party: for, i• the nearest parents excommunication deprive the children of all covenant-mercy and right to the seals, the words should be false, and the Lord should be less in shewing mercy, in extending it to one generation only, to the nearest children only, for their nearest parents loving of God, and keeping of his Commandments, and more abundant in severity of justice, in visiting the sins of the Fathers upon the Children, unto the third 1and fourth Generation of them that hate him. But this turns the promise and the threatning of the Command upside down, for mercy is so extended to Fathers nearest & nearest Children, and punishing justice to four, and the command extends mercy unto thousands, & justice to only four Generations. Now two Generations, as they are fewer then four, so are they far more fewer then a thousand Generations: as also, if mercy extended to a thousand Generations, only be upon condition, they imitate their godly parents (saith Mr. H.) by loving (actually) and obeying (actually) his Commandments, especially that of the truth of his worship, then is mercy not extended to the nearest one generation of Infants; for it is certain the nearest one generation of Infants cannot be yet capable (saith Mr. H. with the same 2breath) being not come to years to put forth such acts of actual love and obedience in worshipping the true God, as he hath commanded in his word: and if mercy be not extended to one generation, nor Covenant-seals to Ishmael, for Abrahams, nor to Esau for Isaacs sake, contrary to all Scripture: the Lord shews not mercy to thousands of generations, because not to one generation. And so again, the promise of mercy is destroyed, for the condition of actual love, and of actual obedience ⟨p. 454⟩is physically impossible to all sorts of Infants, both of Parents loving or hating God.
- 1Mr. H. his exposition of the second Command, overturns the gracious intent and sense of the Lord in both threatening and promise.Mr. H. his exposition of the second Command, overturns the gracious intent and sense of the Lord in both threatning and promise.
- 2Surv. par. 3. c. 2 page 16.
And 3. the sweet and merciful proportion is destroyed, for God punisheth Infants Children of Ahab, of the Amalekites, of Jeroboam in the cradle, though these Infants be as uncapable to bow the knee to Idol gods, or to imitate the Idolatry and actual abominations of their Fathers, as the Infants of godly parents are to imitate the actual love and obedience of their parents: and yet the Scripture and experience teach, that justice proceedeth to four generations against the one: And Mr. H. denies that mercy goes along to the thousand generations with the other, because poor Infants on the breast cannot bow their knee and pray in faith to God, and do the like acts of true worship, as their godly parents do: and yet Mr. H. fathers his meaning upon Calvin, Zanchius, Junius, Perkins.
And 3. the sweet and merciful proportion is destroyed, for God punisheth Infants Children of Achab, of the Am•lakites, of Ieroboam in the cradle, though these Infants be as uncapable to bow the knee to Idol gods, or to imitate the Idolatry and actual abominations of their Fathers, as the Infants of godly parents are to imitate the actual love and obedience of their parents: and yet the Scripture and experience teach, that justice proceedeth to four generations against the one: And Mr. H. denies that mercy goes along to the thousand generations with the other, because poor Infants on the breast cannot bow their knee and pray in faith to God, and do the like acts of true worship, as their godly parents do: and yet Mr. H. fathers his meaning upon Calvin, Zanchius, Iunius, Perkins.
Mr. H. The next parents being excommunicate, cannot give to the child the right which they have not themselves.1
- 1Par. 3 pag. 18.
Ans. I grant, because they are not the sole and adequate cause of conveying covenant-right to the children. But where then (saith Mr. H.) shall we stand, how shall it be conveyed to remote parents? The answer is easy, so long as the nearest children 1of excommunicate parents are born in the visible house, where the King yet dwells, and the golden candlestick is not removed, the children are heirs to the remote parents, the children are followed with covenant-mercy, passing by the nearest parents: (saith the Lord) for my servant Davids sake, 1 King. 11. 32, 34, 36. he would not destroy Judah for his servant Davids sake, 2 King. 8. 19, 2 King. 19. 34. 2 King, 20 6. for the promise is not laid down in the hand of the nearest parents only, but in their hands with whom first God signally covenants, as with Abraham, David, with the three thousand baptized, Act. 2. 39. and their children, and all that are afar off, and as many as the Lord shall call with the seed, with Samaria and theirs, Act. 8. so long as a calling Gospel is there: This shall not fetch in the Turks. How will Mr H. with so short a good night of Christ break off the longanimity of God to the seed for their nearest parents, if they break a new congregational covenant? Yea, if by persecution, and through no sin of the nearest parents, ⟨p. 455⟩they be broken out of congregation-state, presently the Candlestick is removed from the seed, and a bill of Divorce sent to the whole race, and they banished out of the house, and declared Pagans. O Scriptureless cruelty, to make God to break the covenant first, the parents continuing in covenant-obedience and suffering for Christ!
Ans. I grant, because they are not the sole and adequate cause of conveying covenant-right to the children. But where then (saith Mr. H.) shall we stand, how shall it be conveyed to remote parents? The answer is easie, so long as the nearest children 1of excommunicate parents are born in the visible house, where the King yet dwells, and the golden candlestick is not removed, the children are heirs to the remote parents, the children are followed with covenant-mercy, passing by the nearest parents: (saith the Lord) for my servant Davids sake, 1 King. 11. 32, 34, 36. he would not destroy Iudah for his servant Davids sake, 2 King. 8. 19, 2 King. 19. 34. 2 King, 20 6. for the promise is not laid down in the hand of the nearest parents only, but in their hands with whom first God signally covenants, as with Abraham, David, with the three thousand baptized, Act. 2. 39. and their children, and all that are afar off, and as many as the Lord shall call with the seed, with Samaria and theirs, Act. 8. so long as a calling Gospel is there: This shall not fetch in the Turks. How will Mr H. with so short a good night of Christ break off the longanimity of God to the seed for their nearest parents, if they break a new congregational covenant? Yea, if by persecution, and through no sin of the nearest parents, ⟨p. 455⟩they be broken out of congregation-state, presently the Candlestick is removed from the seed, and a bill of Divorce sent to the whole race, and they banished out of the house, and declared Pagans. O Scriptureless cruelty, to make God to break the covenant first, the parents continuing in covenant-obedience and suffering for Christ!
- 1When, and how the posterity are cast off.
Mr. H. Men of approved piety in covenant with God visibly, are to be admitted to the seals (saith Mr. R.) but (saith Mr. H.) gracious men be pertinacious.
Ans. Pertinacy in a scandal mars approved piety; but because they approve not your way, are they therefore pertinacious?
Ans. Pertinacy in a scandal marrs approved piety; but because they approve not your way, are they therefore pertinacious?
Mr. H. To be a member of the visible Church in general, and 1have no particular existence of membership in any particular congregation, is a fancy, as to say there is a part of manhood not existing in John, Thomas, or any Individuals.
Mr. H. To be a member of the visible Church in general, and 1have no particular existence of membership in any particular congregation, is a fansie, as to say there is a part of manhood not existing in John, Thomas, or any Individuals.
- 1Par. 3. pag. 20.
Ans. Mr. H. fancies there is a promise of continuing on the Rock made to the congregation in general, and yet this or that congregation falls off the Rock.
Ans. Mr. H. fansies there is a promise of continuing on the Rock made to the congregation in general, and yet this or that congregation falls off the Rock.
2. Mr. R. his Church-general is no abstract generic nature, but an individual integral Catholic body, existing in all the earth; and one is baptized a member to all congregations jure, and exists and dwells in one only: as a man may have right to all City-privileges, and yet may reside, and actually enjoy only the City privilege of London. Mr. H. imagines that our Catholic integral Church is genus, and the Congregation species: and if so, the Church of Boston should be the whole integral Catholic Church, and the little finger the whole body of John.
2. Mr. R. his Church-general is no abstract generick nature, but an individual integral Catholick body, existing in all the earth; and one is baptized a member to all congregations jure, and exists and dwells in one only: as a man may have right to all City-priviledges, and yet may reside, and actually enjoy only the City priviledge of London. Mr. H. imagines that our Catholick integral Church is genus, and the Congregation species: and if so, the Church of Boston should be the whole integral Catholick Church, and the little finger the whole body of Iohn.
CHAP. IX.
A new device of Mr. H. his two sentences, the official and dogmatical sentence of officers, yet not concional, nor juridical, and another juridical of the male-Church, is examined.
MR. H. It is the office of Rulers dogmatically to discover the mind of God, and the mind of Christ, in convincing by witnesses 1the offenders, and preparing the cause. And the brethren have no more power to oppose the sentence of the Censure thus prepared, and propounded by the Elders, then they have to oppose their Doctrine, for the Elders may preach it as the word of God, by virtue of their office.
MR. H. It is the office of Rulers dogmatically to discover the mind of God, and the mind of Christ, in convincing by witnesses 1the offenders, and preparing the cause. And the brethren have no more power to oppose the sentence of the Censure thus prepared, and propounded by the Elders, then they have to oppose their Doctrine, for the Elders may preach it as the word of God, by vertue of their office.
- 1Par. 3. c. 3. pag. 41.