Ans. No man (I do not say its done consultò) more darkens. ⟨p. 459⟩I brought three members to clear the matter. Mr. H. leaves 1out the third, and darkens all: for acts of Synods lay on bands neither as formal Scripture, for they come not from the immediately inspiring Spirit, nor yet only as clear and infallible deductions from Scripture, for so the counsel of a woman Abigail, infallibly deduced from the sixth Command, laid a burden upon the conscience of David. And this is all the tie that Mr. H. gives to Synods, they tie as godly counsels of women and servants. But Mr. R. and so Mr. Cotton, gives a third member, they lay burdens on the consciences of the Churches, not for the matter only, as the godly advice of women, but formally, as from the Ministerial Authority of the Commissioners. And this power Mr. Tho. Goodwin and Mr. Ph. Nigh give to all Ministers 2over their congregations: So as these three shall be Judges of Mr. H. his great mistake in this distinction. Hence two contradictions are here: Mr. H. gives no power to Synods, but power of advising, such as women over men. Mr. Cotton offends at that, and says, that Synods have a Ministerial power over the Churches. In the former Mr. H. leaves his Brethren, and sides with Socinians and Arminians. And Mr. H. shall 3confess the weakness of this distinction, if applied to doctrines delivered by Pastors to the flock; for they neither bind as women's godly counsels deduced from Scripture only, not do they bind as immediately inspired formal Scripture.
Ans. No man (I do not say its done consultò) more darkens. ⟨p. 459⟩I brought three members to clear the matter. Mr. H. leaves 1out the third, and darkens all: for acts of Synods lay on bands neither as formal Scripture, for they come not from the immediately inspiring Spirit, nor yet onely as clear and infallible deductions from Scripture, for so the counsel of a woman Abigail, infallibly deduced from the sixth Command, laid a burthen upon the conscience of David. And this is all the tie that Mr. H. gives to Synods, they tie as godly counsels of women and servants. But Mr. R. and so Mr. Cotton, gives a third member, they lay burthens on the consciences of the Churches, not for the matter onely, as the godly advice of women, but formally, as from the Ministerial Authority of the Commissioners. And this power Mr. Tho. Goodwyn and Mr. Ph. Nye give to all Ministers 2over their congregations: So as these three shall be Judges of Mr. H. his great mistake in this distinction. Hence two contradictions are here: Mr. H. gives no power to Synods, but power of advising, such as women over men. Mr. Cotton offends at that, and sayes, that Synods have a Ministerial power over the Churches. In the former Mr. H. leaves his Brethren, and sides with Socinians and Arminians. And Mr. H. shall 3confess the weakness of this distinction, if applied to doctrines delivered by Pastors to the flock; for they neither binde as womens godly counsels deduced from Scripture onely, not do they binde as immediately inspired formal Scripture.
- 1Mr. H. his mistake as touching the burdens of the acts of Synods, which is, that they tie the conscience only as the godly counsels of women tie men. M Cotton of the keys, c. 6. p. 25.Mr. H. his mistake as touching the burthens of the acts of Synods, which is, that they tie the conscience only as the godly counsels of women tie men. M Cotton of the keys, c. 6. p. 25.
- 2Preface to the Treatise of the Keys.
- 3Socin. contra Gabr. Ementropium, c. 1. p. 7. Socin. Res. 11. ad Resp. Andr. Volam. Nullis deinceps hominibus, &c. Smalcius Ref. lib. de Error. Aria. 1 c. 1. p. 6. Qui vult sensum Scripturae ab illis peti, qui post Apostolos vixerunt, dum hoc facit, tacitè deserit Scripta Apostolica, &c. Epist. ad 3. th. 8 disp. 26. th 10. disp. 32. th. 1. Remonst. Apol. c. 25. fol. •94. fol. 282, 283. Armin. disp. 58. n. 3.