A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
[9], 521 [i.e. 519] p. · 190k words · Wing R2395 · ESTC R19199
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. The argument supposeth that we approve a towering up of appeals, even to a General Council, as a liberty of every member, whatever unjust prejudice be in it: and that every such appeal may stop the actings of Christs visible Kingdom and called Pastors. Christ hath given no power to sin.
3. The argument supposeth that we approve a towering up of appeals, even to a General Councel, as a liberty of every member, whatever unjust prejudice be in it: and that every such appeal may stop the actings of Christs visible Kingdom and called Pastors. Christ hath given no power to sin.
Mr. H. Its a wonder, that because Churches may rebuke, yea, Christians may rebuke Heathens, though not in a Church way, that therefore the Synod hath a power of jurisdiction—Paul rebuked the Athenians, Acts 17. A […] these acts of Church communion?
Mr. H. Its a wonder, that because Churches may rebuke, yea, Christians may rebuke Heathens, though not in a Church way, that therefore the Synod hath a power of jurisdiction—Paul rebuked the Athenians, Acts 17. A 〈…〉 these acts of Church communion?
Ans. My argument is not à genere ad speciem, sed specie ad genus. These convened in the name of Christ by the Holy 1Ghost, who [Greek or Hebrew], with one consent, by way of suffrage and judgement. [Greek or Hebrew],
. and these who in a Church-way determine against perverters of souls have juridical power: if therefore these men had done the contrary, and had refused to hear the Church, or Churches convened, and should teach these decrees came not from the holy Ghost, were they not to us as Publicans and Heathens? Yea, and wh•• more could the Church of Pergamus, and that of Thyatira Independent […], say our Brethren, do in making acts against such as h•ld the Doctrine of Balaam, of the Nicholas against Jezebel,
. If they should after practice and practice such impure doctrine, but declare them perverters of souls, and charge others to keep no fellowship with them? and shall all be but a rebuke, & such a counsel as one private man giveth to heathen? and sure Pauls rebuke of these at Athens,
. though it made not up the rebuke of a Church, yet Paul rebuked them not as a private man, or as a godly woman may rebuke Idolaters,
⟨p. 466⟩
but formally as a Pastor. And Paul and Barnabas as Pastors removed the Candlestick, and turned to the Gentiles, Act. 13. and unchurched the Jews, which no private men could do. So the prophesies of Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, against Babylon, Persians, Tyre, &c. as they made not the people to be Churches, so they came not from private men, but from the immediately inspired Prophets; and such Prophets of Divine authority these are proved to be from these Prophesies: So the juridical Church-authority of the Synod, by Whitaker, Calvin, Beza, and hosts of learned Divines, is concluded from Act. 15.
Ans. My argument is not à genere ad speciem, sed specie ad genus. These convened in the name of Christ by the Holy 1Ghost, who 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, with one consent, by way of suffrage and judgement. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Act. 15. 9. & 21. 25. rebuke perverters of souls, Act. 24. 28. and lay on burdens and commands, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to observe, Act. 21. 25. and keep such things, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to abstain from such things, Act. 15. 29. and give Decrees, by which the Churches were established in peace and truth, Act. 16. 4, 5. these have power to excommunicate the refusers of such acts, according to Matth. 18. for Paul and Barnabas were scandalized, and complained to the Church of Antioch. Act. 1. who sent them to complain to a Synod at Ierusalem, Act. 15. 2, 3, 6. and these who in a Church-way determine against perverters of souls have juridical power: if therefore these men had done the contrary, and had refused to hear the Church, or Churches convened, and should teach these decrees came not from the holy Ghost, were they not to us as Publicans and Heathens? Yea, and wh•• more could the Church of Pergamus, and that of Thyatira Independent 〈…〉, say our Brethren, do in making acts against such as h•ld the Doctrine of Balaam, of the Nichola• against Iezabel, Rev. 2. 14, 15. 20. If they should after prctice and practice such impure doctrine, but declare them perverters of souls, and charge others to keep no fellowship with them? and shall all be but a rebuke, & such a counsel as one private man giveth to heathen? and sure Pauls rebuke of these at Athens, Act. 17. though it made not up the rebuke of a Church, yet Paul rebuked them not as a private man, or as a godly woman may rebuke Idolaters, ⟨p. 466⟩but formally as a Pastor. And Paul and Barnabas as Pastors removed the Caadlestick, and turned to the Gentiles, Act. 13. and unchurched the Jews, which no private men could do. So the prophesies of Isaiah, Ieremiah, Ezekiel, against Babylon, Persians, Tyrus, &c. as they made not the people to be Churches, so they came not from private men, but from the immediatly inspired Prophets; and such Prophets of Divine authority these are proved to be from these Prophesies: So the juridical Church-authority of the Synod, by Whitaker, Calvin, Beza, and hosts of learned Divines, is concluded from Act. 15.
1The juridical power of Synods is concluded from Acts 15. and their Church-way of rebuking, &c.
Not is it my mind, that the Jews did excommunicate the 1Samaritans so formally as a single delinquent is excommunicate: nor do I defend the superstition by Mr. Jo-Weemes, and Jewish Doctors in the manner of excommunicating them. Its sure, the Jews, the true Church deservedly renounced Church communion with them. Origen, Josephus, Car•lus Sigonius, and others, tell us they were most corrupt in their Religion, 2 King. 17. and though Augustine say the Jews so abhorred them, that they would not drink water out of any vessel of the Samaritans; and Christ refutes that, seeking water to drink from the Woman of Samaria. Yet since Christ saith, Joh. 4. 22. Ye worship ye know not what; we know what we worship, for salvation is of the Jews; he evidently, as Mr. R. said, justifieth the substance of the excommunication, which is all I intend: let their fooleries pass.
Not is it my mind, that the Jews did excommunicate the 1Samaritans so formally as a single delinquent is excommunicate: nor do I defend the superstition by Mr. Io-Weemes, and Jewish Doctors in the manner of excommunicating them. Its sure, the Jewes, the true Church deservedly renounced Churchcommunion with them. Origen, Iosephus, Car•lus Sigonius, and others, tell us they were most corrupt in their Religion, 2 King. 17. and though Augustine say the Jewes so abhorred them, that they would not drink water out of any vessel of the Samaritans; and Christ refutes that, seeking water to drink from the Woman of Samaria. Yet since Christ saith, Ioh. 4. 22. Ye worship ye know not what; we know what we worship, for salvation is of the Iews; he evidently, as Mr. R. said, justifieth the substance of the excommunication, which is all I intend: let their fooleries pass.
1Of the Samaritans, and their religion, See Tostat. Abulen. in 4. Reg. c. 17. qu. 24. Joan. Wolph. Come. in 2. Regn. c 17. v. 24, 25, &c. pag. 346. The Jews deservedly excommunicate the Samaritans. Weemes Christian Synag. par. 7. Diatr•. 147. Origen. To. 4. in Joan. receperunt tantum, scilicer, libros Mosis. Epiphanius haer. 9. Joseph. ant. 11. c. ult. Quando res Judaeorum erant prosperae, se Judaeos, alioqui Assyrios see dicebant: Judaei convitium jactantes, Samaritanum appellabant. Ita Hieronym. Epist. ad Algas. 4. 5. Joseph. l. 13. antiq. c. 14, Religione corruptiss• crant Samaritae. Carol. Sigon. de Rep. Hebr. l. 1. c. 3. Ex Josepho, Ephraimitas praedicarunt se, Judaeis ab Antiocho Epiphane asflictis, Samaritae perterriti, se non Deum (Judaeorum) sed Deos colere asseruerunt, nec se Israelitas, sed S•doniosesse dixerunt, & Templum ipsum Jovi Cretensi se dedicaturos esse professi sunt: atque ita praesentem armati B•gis iracundiam eluserunt. August. in jocum Joan. 4. Omnino vasculis eorum Judaei non utuntur.Of the Samaritans, and their •eligion, See Tostat. Abulen. in 4. Reg. c. 17. qu. 24. Ioan. Wolph. Com. in 2. Regn. c 17. v. 24, 25, &c. pag. 346. The Jewes deservedly excommunicate the Samaritans. Weemes Christian Synag. par. 7. Diatr•. 147. Origen. To. 4. in Ioan. receperunt tantum, scilicer, libros Mosis. Epiphanius haer. 9. Ioseph. ant. 11. c. ult. Quando res Iudaeorum erant prosperae, se Iudaeos, alioqui Assyrios se dicebant: Iudaei convitium jactantes, Samaritanum appellabant. Ita Hieronym. Epist. ad Algas. 4. 5. Ioseph. l. 13. antiq. c. 14, Religione corruptiss• crant Samaritae. Carol. Sigon. de Rep. Hebr. l. 1. c. 3. Ex Iosepho, Ephraimitas praedicarunt se, Iudaeis ab Antiocho Epiphane asflictis, Samaritae perterriti, se non Deum (Iudaeorum) sed Deos colere asseruerunt, nec se Israelitas, sed S•doniosesse dixerunt, & Templum ipsum Iovi Cretensi se dedicaturos esse professi sunt: atque ita praesentem armati B•gis iracundiam eluserunt. August. in iocum Ioan. 4. Omnino vasculis eorum Iudaei non utuntur.
Mr. H. A man may separate totally from a Church, and from ⟨p. 467⟩an assembly of Turks; but for one man to excommunicate, were a profanation of the Lords Ordinance.
Mr. H. A man may separate totally from a Church, and from ⟨p. 467⟩an assembly of Turks; but for one man to excommunicate, were a pr•fanation of the Lords Ordinance.
Ans. A single person could not separate from the Church of the Jews, though they had not a few corruptions, Mat. 23. 1, 2, 3. Mat. 8. 4. no single person can lawfully be a member of a Turkish Church, how can he then separate from such?
Ans. A single person could not separate from the Church of the Jewes, though they had not a few corruptions, Mat. 23. 1, 2, 3. Mat. 8. 4. no single person can lawfully be a member of a Turkish Church, how can he then separate from such?
3. The Church of the Jews (and salvation was of the Jews, Joh. 4 2•.) was not one man; therefore their excommunicating of the Samaritans is not hence concluded to be null.
3. The Church of the Jewes (and salvation was of the Jews, Ioh. 4 2•.) was not one man; therefore their excommunicating of the Samaritans is not hence concluded to be null.
4. But when the sounder part, though fewer, separateth from the major part, and the major part makes manifest defection from the truth, and professed cause and covenant.
And 4. That major part is again and again warned and […] go on to hold out and cast out, as far as they can, all, not of their sinful way, though in their conscience they in other things judge and profess them to be sound and godly: in that case I judge the fewer part the Church, and their censures valid: for the promise is made to such as meet in the name of Christ, Mat. 18.
And 4. That major part is again and again warned and 〈…〉 go on to hold out and cast out, as far as they can, all, not of their sinful way, though in their conscience they in other things judge and prosess them to be sound and godly: in that case I judge the fewer part the Church, and their censures valid: for the promise is made to such as meet in the name of Christ, Mat. 18.
Mr. H. If all common affairs that concern many congregations (saith Mr. R.) were managed not by one congregation, 1but by the suffrages, [Greek or Hebrew], Act. 15. 25. Apostles, Elders and select Brethren, then Synods and their Church-power most be lawful: but the former is true in the choosing of Matthias, Act. 1. and the treasury of the Churches, and calling of their Deacons, Act. 4. & 6. are disposed by a Synod of Apostles, with consent of the Churches. Paul instructeth a Synod or meeting of […] at Ephesus in their duty of feeding, Act. 20. & Act 11. Peter gives an account of his going in to the Gentiles, to a meeting of Apostles and Bre•, […]. […], 4. Its true, in the choosing of Matthias, something extraordinary there was, that the Apostles could not do as Pastors, but as Apostles: as ⟨p. 468⟩Apostles they appoint two, v. 23. God only could limit the call to two certain men, all the Pastors and Churches on earth could not do that: and as Apostles, v. 24. they pray for the directing of the lo•: and Act. 6. as Apostles by the immediately inspiring authority by which they writ Scripture, they appoint a new office of Deacons, which was not in the Church before: but they do most of the rest by the Churches going along.
Mr. H. If all common affairs that concern many congregations (saith Mr. R.) were managed not by one congregation, 1but by the suffcages, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Act. 15. 25. Apostles, Elders and select Brethren, then Synods and their Church-power most be lawful: but the former is true in the chusing of Matthias, Act. 1. and the treasury of the Churches, and call•ng of their Deacons, Act. 4. & 6. are disposed by a Synod of Apostles, with consent of the Churches. Paul instructeth a Synod or meeting of 〈…〉 at Ephesu• in their duty of feeding, Act. 20. & Act 11. Peter gives an account of his going in to the Gentiles, to a meeting of Apostles and Bre•, 〈…〉. 〈…〉, 4. Its true, in the chusing of Matthias, something extraordinary there was, that the Apostles could not do as Pastors, but as Apostles: as ⟨p. 468⟩Apostles they appoint two, v. 23. God only could limit the call to two certain men, all the Pastors and Churches on earth could not do that: and as Apostles, v. 24. they pray for the directing of the lo•: and Act. 6. as Apostles by the immediately inspiring authority by which they writ Scripture, they appoint a new office of Deacons, which was not in the Church before: but they do most of the rest by the Churches going along.
1The acting of Apostles in things belonging to many Churches, wi•h the Churches concurrence, proveth that a Synod hath Church power.