A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
[9], 521 [i.e. 519] p. · 190k words · Wing R2395 · ESTC R19199
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. H. To call what members of the Synod he pleaseth to consult about the good of the Church belongeth to the Prince, and their homage requireth this, otherwise he could not maintain the peace of the subject in godliness, for providence doth not require the end, but allows also the means.
1. The godly and sound Prince may call godly and learned Divines where the Churches are rightly constitute; but when the Churches make no free election of these Divines, it is neither a free Synod, not are the Divines messengers of the Churches, nor sent by the Churches, as
the Magistrate for the maintaining of the peace of the subjects in godliness, use what means he pleaseth for that end, but only means prescribed of God, except Mr. H. can prove that Christ hath annexed to the royal Office, a gift of choosing members of Assemblies, more excellent then is in the Churches, which we read not. And if 2. this belong to the Magistrate as the Magistrate, then all Magistrates, Heathen, Arian, Socinian, Popish (for sure they are Magistrates) must have this power, and this power only, if it be given to godly and sound Magistrates, as such, Mr. H. his instance of Herod comes far short of this power. Read then the Council of Antioch holden by the Arians under Constantius. Then must Maximus Bishop of Jerusalem, and Julius Bishop of Rome, who refused to come
⟨p. 501⟩
to that Council, be Rebels by Mr. H. his reason, and deny homage to the Emperor. For the Magdeburgenses, Sozomen, Socrates,
tell us these godly men justly feared the Princes siding with Arians, and the design of casting out of Athanasius, at the Assembly at Antiochia, Anno 344. and the altering of the Nicene faith, as fell out: and its known that Constantius rigorously and unjustly commanded those of the Council of Sirmium, Anno 356. to recall the two Confessions of Faith, one in Latin, another in Greek, in which though abstaining from the word [Greek or Hebrew], (which should not have been) they gave great glory to the Son of God; yet that they too much inclined to obey his wicked design, in that he also banished many worthy Bishops, Liberius Bishop of Rome, Paulinus Bishop
of Trier, Dionysius Bishop of Alba, Osius Bishop of Corduba, and others, because they refused to ratify in the Council at Milan, the deposition of Athanasius, and to alter the Nicene Faith. See Theodoret, Socrates, Sozo•en, Ruffin. Much more
of the flexibleness of Constantius in opposing the Council of Ariminum, and in arming with power Ursatius and Valens to publish the sum of the Arian Faith, and to eject sundry Bishops, who refused to subscribe thereunto:
1. The godly and sound Prince may call godly and learned Divines where the Churches are rightly constitute; but when the Churches make no free election of these Divines, it is neither a free Synod, not are the Divines messengers of the Churches, nor sent by the Churches, as Act. 15. 1, 2, 3. nor may 1the Magistrate for the maintaining of the peace of the subjects in godliness, use what means he pleaseth for that end, but only means prescribed of God, except Mr. H. can prove that Christ hath annexed to the royal Office, a gift of chusing members of Assemblies, more excellent then is in the Churches, which we read not. And if 2. this belong to the Magistrate as the Magistrate, then all Magistrates, Heathen, Arrian, Socinian, Popish (for sure they are Magistrates) must have this power, and this power only, if it be given to godly and sound Magistrates, as such, Mr. H. his instance of Herod comes far short of this power. Read then the Councel of Antioch holden by the Arrians under Constantius. Then must Maximus Bishop of Ierusalem, and Iulius Bishop of Rome, who refused to come ⟨p. 501⟩to that Councel, be Rebells by Mr. H. his reason, and deny homage to the Emperour. For the Magdeburgenses, Sozomen, Socrates, 2tell us these godly men justly feared the Princes siding with Arrians, and the design of casting out of Athanasius, at the Assembly at Antiochia, Anno 344. and the altering of the Nicene faith, as fell out: and its known that Constantius rigorously and unjustly commanded those of the Councel of Sirmium, Anno 356. to recall the two Confessions of Faith, one in Latine, another in Greek, in which though abstaining from the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, (which should not have been) they gave great glory to the Son of God; yet that they too much inclined to obey his wicked design, in that he also banished many worthy Bishops, Liberius Bishop of Rome, Paulinus Bishop 3of Triere, Dionyfius Bishop of Alba, Osius Bishop of Corduba, and others, because they refused to ratifie in the Councel at Millan, the deposition of Athanasius, and to alter the Nicene Faith. See Theodoret, Socrates, Sozo•en, Ruffin. Much more 4of the flexibleness of Constantius in opposing the Councel of Ariminum, and in arming with power Ursatius and Valens to publish the summe of the Arrian Faith, and to eject sundry Bishops, who refused to subscribe thereunto:
1The Magistrate may not use what means he pleaseth, and domineer over Assemblies to choose members, and convocate them as a Magistrate, to preserve godliness. Histor. Magdeburgen. Cent. 4. c. 9.The Magistrate may not use what means he pleaseth, and domineer over Assemblies to chuse members, and convocate them as a Magistrate, to preserve godliness. Histor. Magdeburgen. Cent. 4. c. 9.
2Sozom. l. 3. c. 5: Socrat. l. […]. c. 8: The Emperors had not that power over assemblies, which Mr. H. says. Socrat. l. 2. c. 29 30.Sozom. l. 3. c. 5: Socrat. l. 〈…〉. c. 8: The Emperors had not that power over assemblies, which Mr. H. sayes. Socrat. l. 2. c. 29 30.
3Bulling, de Concil.
4Theod. l. 1. c. 15. Socrat. l. 2. c. 36 Sozom. l. 4. c. 9. Ruffin. l. 1. c. 20.
and in gathering a Council in Nica a town in Thracia, which ratified the Arian Faith, and called it falsely the Nic••• Faith; as if the world knew not then and now, the difference between Nica in Thracia, and Nice in Bithynia. See Socrates and Sozomen. 1Who shall read the Histories shall find, 1. That the Emperors were not Masters of true and false Religion, as Mr. H. saith. 2. That they had not power of choosing members of the Council. as Mr. H. 3. That godly Bishops refusing to come to corrupt Councils at the command of the Emperor, were not counted rebellious, as Mr. H. saith.
and in gathering a Councel in Nica a town in Thracia, which ratified the Arrian Faith, and called it falsely the Nic••• Faith; as if the world knew not then and now, the difference between Nica in Thracia, and Nice in Bithynia. See Socrates and Sozomen. 1Who shall read the Histories shall find, 1. That the Emperors were not Masters of true and false Religion, as Mr. H. saith. 2. That they had not power of chusing members of the Councel. as Mr. H. 3. That godly Bishops refusing to come to corrupt Councels at the command of the Emperor, were not counted rebellious, as Mr. H. saith.
1Socrat. l. […]. c. 37 Sozom. l. 4. c. 17Socrat. l. 〈…〉. c. 37 Sozom. l. 4. c. 17
To the fifth Argument, The Churches need the protection of the Prince in Assemblies, and are to give an account to any of their 1faith and doings, 1 Pet. 3. 18. and far more to the Christian Prince: but it follows not, that they have no intrin•l power ⟨p. 502⟩from Christ to meet themselves, if the Prince refuse to convocate them, as Asa, Hezekiah, Josiah did, for the Magistrate ought to protect the Independent congregation, and every single Professor: but it follows not, therefore the single congregation hath no power intrinsical to meet for Word and Seals, except the Prince who is a persecutor, give him leave: nor follows it yet, therefore no single member can profess Christ before men and the Ruler (who often persecutes confession of Christ) except the Ruler give him leave to profess Christ, and to meet in a Synod: For Christ hath given to his Church, and members thereof, power to worship him in private, in public, in Church-Assemblies, and hath laid above their heads no lawful privative power of Rulers to hinder his people to worship the Lord God, Exodus 3• and the Argument retorted concludes against Mr. Hooker. The Prince hath no power under pretence of keeping civil peace to Caesar, to hinder actings of rendering honour to God, contrary to truth, and destructive to the Gospel.
To the fifth Argument, The Churches need the protection of the Prince in Assemblies, and are to give an account to any of their 1faith and doings, 1 Pet. 3. 18. and far more to the Christian Prince: but it follows not, that they have no intrin•l power ⟨p. 502⟩from Christ to meet themselves, if the Prince refuse to convocate them, as Asa, Hezekiah, Iosiah did, for the Magistrate ought to protect the Independent congregation, and every single Professor: but it follows not, therefore the single congregation hath no power intrinsecal to meet for Word and Seals, except the Prince who is a persecutor, give him leave: nor follows it yet, therefore no single member can profess Christ before men and the Ruler (who often persecutes confession of Christ) except the Ruler give him leave to profess Christ, and to meet in a Synod: For Christ hath given to his Church, and members thereof, power to worship him in private, in publick, in Church-Assemblies, and hath laid above their heads no lawful privative power of Rulers to hinder his people to worship the Lord God, Exodus 3• and the Argument retorted concludes against Mr. Hooker. The Prince hath no power under pretence of keeping civil peace to Casar, to hinder actings of rendring honour to God, contrary to truth, and destructive to the Gospel.
1The Church is to give an account of their sinned […] acting […] the Prince, but this proves not, that the Prince hath over the Church any such headship as Mr. Hooker ascribeth to him.The Church is to give an account of their syned 〈…〉 act•ng 〈…〉 the Prince, but this proves not, that the Prince hath over the Church any such headship as Mr. Hooker ascribeth to him.
The external Society of the Church (say the Magdeburgenses 1is at all times mixed of good and bad. Our Brethren say of all visibly good, even visible converts. The Magdeburgenses teach, That after Paul hath commended the faith and obedience, love, sanctification, growth of grace of the visible Church of Rome, Rom. 1. 6, 7. Corinth, 1 Cor. 1. 2. Galatia, Gal. 1. 2, 3, 4. Thessalonic•, 2 Thess. 1. 2, 3, 4. Philippi, cap. 1. ver. 5, 6. and the seven Churches, Rev c. 2. & 3. which are commended highly by Christ; yet in the same very Epistle, the mixture of visible hypocrites was to be seen among them.
THe external Society of the Church (say the Magdeburgenses 1is at all times mixed of good and bad. Our Brethren say of all visibly good, even visible converts. The Magdeburgenses teach, That after Paul hath commended the faith and obedience, love, sanctification, growth of grace of the visible Church of Rome, Rom. 1. 6, 7. Corinth, 1 Cor. 1. 2. Galatia, Gal. 1. 2, 3, 4. Thessalonic•, 2 Thess. 1. 2, 3, 4. Philippi, cap. 1. ver. 5, 6. and the seven Churches, Rev c. 2. & 3. which are commended highly by Christ; yet in the same very Epistle, the mixture of visible hypocrites was to be seen among them.
1Magdeb. cent. 1. l. 11 c. 4. p. 288. Ecclesiae ve: o•tum externum ex bonis & ex malie omnibus temporibus esse mixtum Apostoli tradunt, pag. 289. Paulus in Ecclesia Romana etiam malos (visibiliter) mixtos ostendit, Rom. 16. & in Ecclesiâ Corinthiacā plurima desiderat, sunt enim intereos contentiones—idololatrae, convitiatores, ebriosi, rapaces, 1 Cor. 5. incestuosus—litigant sub infidelibus, & damno afficiunt fratres: Scortatores, avari, 1 Cor. 6. vescuntur Idolothytis, 1 Cor. 8. & 10, &c. Galatae à doctrina Evangelii defecerant—fermentum inter eos alii alios devorant, &c. sio in•er Thessalonicenses, 2 Thess. 3. & Philippenses, 2. omnes quae sua sunt quaerunt, 2 Tim. 1. Asiani omnes aversati sunt me, &c.Magdeb. cent. 1. l. 11 c. 4. p. 288. Ecclesiae ve: o•tum externum ex bonis & ex malie omnibus temporibus esse mixtum Apostoli tradunt, pag. 289. Paulus in Ecclesia Romana etiam malos (visibiliter) mixtos ostendit, Rom. 16. & in Ecclesiâ Corinthiacā plurima desiderat, sunt enim intereos contentiones—idololatrae, convitiatores, ebriosi, rapaces, 1 Cor. 5. incestuosus—litigant sub infidelibus, & damno afficiunt fratres: Scortatores, avari, 1 Cor. 6. vescuntur Idolothytis, 1 Cor. 8. & 10, &c. Galatae à doctrina Evangelii defecerant—fermentum inter eos alii alios devorant, &c. sio in•er Thessalonicenses, 2 Thess. 3. & Philippenses, 2. omnes quae sua sunt quaerunt, 2 Tim. 1. Asiani omnes aversati sunt me, &c.