Ans. 1. This argument may be wholly yielded, but is not my 1argument; I refer the Reader to the place of my book where this is first propounded. The argument is much mistaken, and is not drawn from visible Churches, as they are de facto, and through abuse, though I speak to that also, which I am willing 2to dispute with any who will defend M. H. in his survey. My argument is from visible Churches as they were at first planted and constituted lawfully, and to all that read with any considerable attention, planted according, not to the permissive decree of God, according to which I tell M. Barrow, many hypocrites are de facto in the visible Church lawfully constitute; but according to 3the revealed will of precept. Hence take the argument according to my mind; if the visible kingdom and Church of Christ at both its first planting in fieri, and its after constitution in facto esse, consist not according to the decree, but even according to the revealed and approving and commanding will of God, of good fish and of bad, and filth; and of vessels of honour and of dishonour: then the visible Church consisteth not of such Saints only as must be real converts in the judgement of charity. But the former is true, M. H. might have known that I of purpose closed up this mouse-hole, non semel, not once, but 4twenty times; the proposition is from the scope of the Parable, which, as worthy Calvin sayeth, that nihil novum &c. that our Saviour teacheth no new thing, but by a new similitude, the ⟨p. 64⟩same which he taught in the parable of the tares, only as Mr. Dickson hath judiciously observed. That hence the visible 5Church in the way of gathering members, and manner of constitution thereof is like a draw-net, taking in a I who profess subjection to Christ in his ordinances good and bad. To which as for the purpose, it is also most false, that the Lord tacitly commands such Pastors as cast out the net of the preached Gospel, to fish no souls in a Pastoral Church-way, but these 6who in their judgement of charity, savour of being with Jesus (as sayeth M. H. survey par. 1. c. 2. pag. 14, 15) and so are good fish and real converts. Whereas the Lord commands Pastors not to look whether they be converted or not in their judgement; leave that to God, and call in as many as ye find, Matth. 22. 9. Luk. 14. 17, 18, 23. Call in fools and simple ones, Prov. 9. 4. which indeed to M.
Ans. 1. This argument may be wholely yielded, but is not my 1argument; I referre the Reader to the place of my book where this is first propounded. The argument is much mistaken, and is not drawen from visible Churches, as they are de facto, and through abuse, though I speak to that also, which I am willing 2to dispute with any who will defend M. H. in his survey. My argument is from visible Churches as they were at first planted and constituted lawfully, and to all that read with any considerable attention, planted according, not to the permissive decree of God, according to which I tell M. Barrow, many hypocrites are de facto in the visible Church lawfully constitute; but according to 3the revealed will of precept. Hence take the argument according to my mind; if the visible kingdome and Church of Christ at both its first planting in fieri, and its after constitution in facto esse, consist not according to the decree, but even according to the revealed and approving and commanding will of God, of good fish and of bad, and filth; and of vessels of honour and of dishonour: then the visible Church consisteth not of such Saints only as must be reall converts in the judgement of charity. But the former is true, M. H. might have known that I of purpose closed up this mouse-hole, non semel, not once, but 4twenty times; the proposition is from the scope of the Parable, which, as worthy Calvin sayeth, that nikil novum &c. that our Saviour teacheth no new thing, but by a new similitude, the ⟨p. 64⟩same which he taught in the parable of the tares, only as Mr. Dickson hath judiciously observed. That hence the visible 5Church in the way of gathering members, and manner of constitution thereof is like a draw-net, taking in a I who professe subjection to Christ in his ordinances good and bad. To which as for the purpose, it is also most false, that the Lord tacitly commands such Pastors as cast out the net of the preached Gospell, to fish no souls in a Pastorall Church-way, but these 6who in their judgement of charity, savour of being with Iesus (as sayeth M. H. survey par. 1. c. 2. pag. 14, 15) and so are good fish and reall converts. Whereas the Lord commands Pastors not to look whether they be converted or not in their judgement; leave that to God, and call in as many as ye find,
- 1Pauls Presbytery, c. 9. arg. 2. pag. 101, 102.
- 2M. R. his argument from the draw-net, wronged by M. H. is vindicated.
- 3Barrow disc. of false Church, pag. 20.
- 4Calvin in Evang. Matth. in ••c.
- 5Dicks. Mat. 13
- 6Pareus. Non restrictè, non hoc modo quo vos vultis, immoderato rigore cum laesione tritici; non prohibet quin Magistratus & Ecclesia faciat officium eradicandis suo loco zizaniis.