A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
[9], 521 [i.e. 519] p. · 190k words · Wing R2395 · ESTC R19199
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. My argument is this, The Church covenant is tither one and the same, or a branch of the covenant of grace, as it offers ⟨p. 153⟩grace externally to all, to Peter and Magus, or then it is a different covenant. That it is different Mr. H. denies, for then it 1should not be warranted in the Gospel, if it be a part of the Gospel-covenant, how can they debar men of approved godliness, and visibly within the covenant of grace from ordinances? for such are implicitly in this covenant.
1The covenant of grace solemnly entered in baptism, ties us to all Church-duties in all Congregations, without any special covenant-engagement, making me a special Church-brother to these of this Congregation only, and that by divine command of a new covenant, different from the Gospel-covenant.The covenant of grace solemnly entred in baptism, ties us to all Church-duties in all Congregations, without any special covenant-engagement, making me a special Church-brother to these of this Congregation only, and that by divine command of a new covenant, different from the Gospel-covenant.
3. Some are (saith M. H.) in the covenant of Grace, that are not Church-members, and contrary: true; but not if they be externally and professedly as Israel was, for so to be Gods visible people in covenant, is to be Gods visible Church, Acts 2. 39. Gen. 17. 7. Rev. 11. 15. Isa. 19. 25. now we dispute whether the Church-covenant be not a branch of the covenant of the Gospel externally proposed. Mr. H. yields it is, only he saith, the Church-covenant is not the covenant of grace according to the benefits of saving grace given in it: true; nor is the covenant of grace externally preached, according to which Magus and Judas, and all such Church-members are in the covenant of grace: the covenant of grace according to the benefit of saving grace given it, to wi, a new heart, and remission, &c. Then this cannot hinder, but when one vows to duties in baptism, he also vows he shall acquit himself in all duties of warning, rebuking, gaining to Christ persons in all Congregations he shall come unto: for sure to be buried with Christ in Baptism, and to rise again to newness of life,
. And therefore it must be will-worship and unwarrantable, to teach that a visible professor is not called, nor can lawfully gain a trespassing brother, as
. until he be inchurched a member to that one Congregation, and that he is not to gain to God, and to bring into fellow Church-duties the inhabitants of another City, nor in covenant way to exhort one
⟨p. 154⟩
another while it is to day, nor to strengthen one another in Church duties of love, while first we be all inchurched, by particular agreement, and covenant to this only Congregation. Yea, it is the nature (saith Mr. H.) of all Corporations, that one cannot be a Member, or free Citizen, without the consent of that Corporation.
3. Some are (saith M. H.) in the covenant of Grace, that are not Church-members, and contrary: true; but not if they be externally and professedly as Israel was, for so to be Gods visible people in covenant, is to be Gods visible Church, Acts 2. 39. Gen. 17. 7. Rev. 11. 15. Isa. 19. 25. now we dispute whether the Church-covenant be not a branch of the covenant of the Gospel externally proposed. Mr. H. yeelds it is, only he saith, the Church-covenant is not the covenant of grace according to the benefits of saving grace given in it: true; nor is the covenant of grace externally preached, according to which Magus and Iudas, and all such Church-members are in the covenant of grace: the covenant of grace according to the benefit of saving grace given it, to wi•, a new heart, and remission, &c. Then this cannot hinder, but when one vowes to duties in baptism, he also vowes he shall acquit himself in all duties of warning, rebuking, gaining to Christ persons in all Congregations he shall come unto: for sure to be buried with Christ in Baptism, and to rise again to newness of life, Rom. 6. 3, 4. Col. 2. 11, 12. Gal. 3. 27. 1 Pet. 3. 21. 1 Cor. 12 13. engages a man, when converted, to strengthen his brethren, to gain others, Ps. 51. 12, 13. Luk. 22. 23. 1 Cor. 7. 16. and undeniably to gain a trespassing brother, Mat. 18. and it must be commanded in the covenant of grace; and to exhort another while it is to day, Isa. 2. 3. Isa. 19. 23, 24, 25. Zach. 8. 21, 22. Ier. 50 4, 5. And therefore it must be will-worship and unwarrantable, to teach that a visible professor is not called, nor can lawfully gain a trespassing brother, as Mat. 18. until he be inchurched a member to that one Congregation, and that he is not to gain to God, and to bring into fellow Church-duties the inhabitants of another City, nor in covenant way to exhort one ⟨p. 154⟩another while it is to day, nor to strengthen one another in Church duties of love, while first we be all inchurched, by particular agreement, and covenant to this only Congregation. Yea, it is the nature (saith Mr. H.) of all Corporations, that one cannot be a Member, or free Citizen, without the consent of that Corporation.
Ans. If entering the covenant of grace and professed faith in Baptism put me not in a state of brotherhood to any, but to 1the five thousand men, and multitudes beside of the same Congregation, Acts 4. 4. and also Acts 5. 14. Acts 6. 7. (whose faces I never saw, nor can see, to enter this new covenant with them.) Then
Ans. If entring the covenant of grace and professed faith in Baptism put me not in a state of brotherhood to any, but to 1the five thousand men, and multitudes beside of the same Congregation, Acts 4. 4. and also Acts 5. 14. Acts 6. 7. (whose faces I never saw, nor can see, to enter this new covenant with them.) Then
1It is vain doctrine that none can be my Church-brother, whom I am to gain, but one under the same only Congregational covenant with me.
3. To Christs second coming, none can be made my Church-Brother, though visibly and professedly he have with me one hope of Calling, one Lord, one Faith, one Baptism, one God, one Father of all, Eph. 4. 4, 5, 6. but one of the same Congregation, and that by this new covenant.
3. To Christs s•cond coming, none can be made my Church-Brother, though visibly and professedly he have with me one hope of Calling, one Lord, one Faith, one Baptism, one God, one Father of all, Eph. 4. 4, 5, 6. but one of the same Congregation, and that by this new covenant.
6. Nor can he eat of one bread with me, contrary to Scripture, 1 Cor. 10. 17. 1 Cor. 12. 13. and our brethren's way, being not my brother, nor a member of that household of Faith, Eph. 2. which to Mr. H. is only a Congregational household.
6. Nor can he eat of one bread with me, contrary to Scripture, 1 Cor. 10. 17. 1 Cor. 12. 13. and our brethrens way, being not my brother, nor a member of that houshold of Faith, Eph. 2. which to Mr. H. is only a Congregational houshold.
7. Nor should I love him as a visible brother to me, contrary to 1 Joh. 3. 14, 15. nor give him alms, as such, contrary to 1 Joh. 3. 17, 18. 3 Joh. 5. Jam 2. 14, 15.
7. Nor should I love him as a visible brother to me, contrary to 1 Ioh. 3. 14, 15. nor give him alms, as such, contrary to 1 Ioh. 3. 17, 18. 3 Ioh. 5. Iam 2. 14, 15.
M. H. The word (saith Mr. R.) teacheth that I should confess Christ, walk before God, &c. but that I am under a divine law to swear this covenant which is different from the covenant of grace, in relation to this duty, is no divine law.
Ans. But to say there is no divine law to necessitate a man to enter into another covenant for marriage, beside the covenant of ⟨p. 155⟩grace is strange. So a man may take the place, and do the duties of a husband to a woman, and tell her, I have been these many years in the covenant of grace, and there is no necessity to make a marriage covenant beside. A Nimrod might say, the Gospel teacheth to pay tribute to Princes, and the Prince to exact it, and there needs no other covenant between Prince and people.
Ans. But to say there is no divine law to necessitate a man to enter into another covenant for marriage, beside the covenant of ⟨p. 155⟩grace is strange. So a man may take the place, and do the duties of a husband to a woman, and tell her, I have been these many years in the covenant of grace, and there is no necessity to make a mariagecovenant beside. A Nimrod might say, the Gospel teacheth to pay tribute to Princes, and the Prince to exact it, and there needs no other covenant between Prince and people.
Ans. The reason is altogether impertinent, for a Pastor is no 1married Husband, no Monarch to rule over one single Congregation only. So when he dispenseth Bread and Wine in the Lords Supper to forty of another Congregation, which he may lawfully do, 1 Cor. 10 17. 1 Cor. 12. 13. As our brethren teach: the Pastor saith, I am no married Husband, nor Church-covenanting Pastor to you forty foreign members of another Congregation, but yet I do the duty of your own sworn, and only Husband and Pastor to you, in dispensing to you this Seal of the Covenant, and there is no need of a marriage covenant between you and me.
Ans. The reason is altogether impertinent, for a Pastor is no 1married Husband, no Monarch to rule over one single Congregation only. So when he dispenceth Bread and Wine in the Lords Supper to fourty of another Congregation, which he may lawfully do, 1 Cor. 10 17. 1 Cor. 12. 13. As our brethren teach: the Pastor saith, I am no married Husband, nor Church-covenanting Pastor to you fourty forraign members of another Congregation, but yet I do the duty of your own sworn, and only Husband and Pastor to you, in dispensing to you this Seal of the Covenant, and there is no need of a marriage covenant between you and me.
1Way of the Churches, c. 6. sect. 6. pag. 103 sect. 7. Cotton of the Keys. c. 4. pag. 17. Mr. Hooker Survey. A Pastor is not as a husband to his own Congregation only, for he may perform pastoral duties to other members and Congregations. See Mr. Robinson Justific. of Separate. 317, 318. in the the same mistake with Mr. H. but disputing more nervously then Mr. Hooker: Epaphras though at Rome is a Minister at Coloss. Answ. A fixed Minister labouring among them, in that part of the Vineyard: true; but he was actu primo, habitu all the world over a Minister, wheresoever he opened his mouth and tendered the seals.Way of the Churches, c. 6. sect. 6. pag. 103 sect. 7. Cotton of the Keys. c. 4. pag. 17. Mr. Hooker Survey. A Pastor is not as a husband to his own Congregation only, for he may perform pastoral duties to other members and Congregations. See Mr. Robinson Iustific. of Separat. 317, 318. in the the same mistake with Mr. H. but disputing more nervously then Mr. Hooker: Epaphras though at Rome is a Minister at Coloss. Answ. A fixed Minist•r labouring among them, in that part of the Vineyard: true; but he was actu primo, habitu all the world over a Minister, wheresoever he opened his mouth and tendered the seals.
Is not this by Mr. H. his own doctrine, to quit the argument, when it undoes his own cause, and to say the comparison of husband & wife is blasphemous? And the like is said of that of Prince and people; for he is no Prince nor Magistrate to a people which never promised, nor covenanted with him for subjection and obedience: and a covenant is necessary in both these, but a Pastor may and doth discharge pastoral acts to these with whom he never entered a marriage-covenant, all our brethren grant.
Is not this by Mr. H. his own doctrine, to quit the argument, when it undoes his own cause, and to say the comparison of husband & wife is blasphemous? And the like is said of that of Prince and people; for he is no Prince nor Magistrate to a people which never promised, nor covenanted with him for subjection and obedience: and a covenant is necessary in both these, but a Pastor may and doth discharge pastoral acts to these with whom he never entred a marriage-covenant, all our brethren grant.
2. Mr. R. denies not, but there may be a Covenant between a fixed and a proper Pastor (to make him fixed and proper, not to make him a Pastor) and this Congregation, but that agreement makes neither Husband nor Prince; but my argument is, that the covenant of grace gives marriage membership to the man who entereth it, to all Congregations on earth, and warrants the sound professor to gain a trespassing brother in all Congregations, without the new fancied marriage, or covenant ⟨p. 156⟩between him and them. And the covenant of grace entered did this.
2. Mr. R. denies not, but there may be a Covenant between a fixed and a proper Pastor (to make him fixed and proper, not to make him a Pastor) and this Congregation, but that agreement makes neither Husband nor Prince; but my argument is, that the covenant of grace gives marriage membership to the man who entereth it, to all Congregations on earth, and warrants the sound professor to gaine a trespassing brother in all Congregations, without the new fansied marriage, or covenant ⟨p. 156⟩between him and them. And the covenant of grace entred did this.
See and answer my Arguments, and prove not to me a marriage-membership with this only Congregation, by an asserted comparison, wickedly said. But Mr. H. speaks dishonourably of partaking Church-ordinances, and seals in another Congregation, and from another Pastor, when he will have these acts to be adulterous, and traitorous, performed by no Husband, but by a strange man, and a foreign usurper and tyrant.
See and answer my Arguments, and prove not to me a marriage-membership with this only Congregation, by an asserted comparison, wickedly said. But Mr. H. speaks dishonourably of partaking Church-ordinances, and seals in another Congregation, and from another Pastor, when he will have these acts to be adulterous, and traiterous, performed by no Husband, but by a strange man, and a forraign usurper and tyrant.