A57981:977
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas…
A survey of the Survey of that sum of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A survey of the Survey of that summe of church-discipline penned by Mr. Thomas Hooker ... wherein the way of the churches of N. England is now re-examined ... / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by J.G. for Andr. Crook, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ans. This is neither my Argument, nor my words: my words are, Par. 1 pag. 332. Now if we distinguish ONEROUSNESS, CARE and LABOUR by way of jurisdiction, the former is as GREAT IN FORO DEI, in the Court of conscience, as the latter. These words are left out by Mr. H. qua fide; let the ⟨p. 219⟩Reader judge; for the toil, care, onerousness and labour in point of conscience in the kind, and sphere; I urge in both, by necessity of a divine command: but the like care, onerousness and labour in quantity, in the use of more means, in constant preaching, personal comforting, to all the Christians on earth, as to the single congregation, I utterly deny. But can Mr. H. deny but the Apostles and Brethren, Act. 15. did owe as much care, onerousness, and labour in a binding conscientious way in laying on synodical burdens, which bind not only (saith Mr. Cotton) materially for the weight of the matter imposed by divine 1precept, but also formally from the authority of the Synod, upon the Churches of Jerusalem, Antioch, Syria, Cilicia, as any pastor owes to his single flock; and that because these Churches are all one consociated body? and yet Elders of the Synod were never to see the faces of all these members of the Churches.
Ans. This is neither my Argument, nor my words: my words are, Par. 1 pag. 332. Now if we distinguish ONEROUSNESS, CARE and LABOUR by way of jurisdiction, the former is as GREAT IN FORO DEI, in the Court of conscience, as the latter. These words are left out by Mr. H. qua fide; let the ⟨p. 219⟩Reader judge; for the toil, care, onerousness and labour in point of conscience in the kind, and sphere; I urge in both, by necessity of a divine command: but the like care, onerousness and labour in quantity, in the use of more means, in constant preaching, personal comforting, to all the Christians on earth, as to the single congregation, I utterly deny. But can Mr. H. deny but the Apostles and Brethren, Act. 15. did ow as much care, onerousness, and labour in a binding conscientious way in laying on synodical burdens, which bind not onely (saith Mr. Cotton) materially for the weight of the matter imposed by divine 1precept, but also formally from the authority of the Synod, upon the Churches of Ierusalem, Antioch, Syria, Cilicia, as any pastor ows to his single flock; and that because these Churches are all one consociated body? and yet Elders of the Synod were never to see the faces of all these members of the Churches.
- 1Mr. Cotton Keys of the Kingdom, c. 6. pag. 25.
And I put this query to the Brethren, what warrant of Christ is there that a member of an Independent Church owe Church-care to watch, teach, admonish, rebuke, comfort, as Col. 3. 16. Heb. 3. 13. 1 Thes. 5 14. to a fellow member of the same congregation only, and owe no Church-care to another brother, dwelling in the same house with him, having with him the same faith, the same baptism, the same Lord, the same covenant of Grace, the same Saviour, only because he is a member of another Independent Church?
And I put this quere to the Brethren, what warrant of Christ is there that a member of an Independent Church ow Church-care to watch, teach, admonish, rebuke, comfort, as Col. 3. 16. Heb. 3. 13. 1 Thes. 5 14. to a fellow member of the same congregation only, and ow no Church-care to another brother, dwelling in the same house with him, having with him the same faith, the same baptism, the same Lord, the same covenant of Grace, the same Saviour, only because he is a member of another Independent Church?
Mr. H. Arg. 5. If they be Pastors over all the Congregations 1of the circuit, then they were new chosen by the Congregations, or not, &c.
- 1Pag. 117.
Ans. This is a repeated blast of an old horn; there is this required, that Churches about, by their silence approve him as Pastor to one single Congregation; but that all Congregations make a special election of him to be their fixed Pastor, is no more required, then that the Churches of Antioch and Jerusalem chose the Apostles and Elders, who yet Act. 15. exercise pastoral and official acts over them by the grant of Mr. Cotton and our Brethren.
Ans. This is a repeated blast of an old horn; there is this required, that Churches about, by their silence approve him as Pastor to one single Congregation; but that all Congregations make a special election of him to be their fixed Pastor, is no more required, then that the Churches of Antioch and Ierusalem chose the Apostles and Elders, who yet Act. 15. exercise pastoral and official acts over them by the grant of Mr. Cotton and our Brethren.
They are Elders of Ephesus, i. e. of every Congregation of the 1combination, as all the Kings, if they were met in one royal Court to govern the Nations, in things of common concernment to all, yet ⟨p. 220⟩are called the Kings of the Nations. These are words (saith Mr. H. to darken:) the Elders met here, have a new power distinct from the power over their several Congregations, a Commission, i. e. a new Creature. The Kings if so convened, have a joint power of confederate Princes, to act in things of common concernment, and if that power were distinct from the particular power that they have over their own territories, the comparison were parallel.
They are Elders of Ephesus, i. e. of enery Congregation of the 1combination, as all the Kings, if they were met in one royal Court to govern the Nations, in things of common concernment to all, yet ⟨p. 220⟩are called the Kings of the Nations. These are words (saith Mr. H. to darken:) the Elders met here, have a new power distinct from the power over their several Congregations, a Commission, i. e. a new Creature. The Kings if so convened, have a joynt power of confederate Princes, to act in things of common concernment, and if that power were distinct from the particular power that they have over their own territories, the comparison were parallel.
- 1Pag. 117. 118.
Ans. We may suppose such a convention of Kings, the Commissioners 1or Messengers of the Churches have no new office, but only are met to determine of such a thing as disturbs the Churches, Act. 15 5. they differ as Elders, and such Elders sent and nominate by the Church, and act as Elders by the same official power common to Elders that are not sent, and are called by the Church Apostles and Elders, Act. 15. 23. & 16. 4. & 21. 18, 25. then sending and commissionating is a condition of order appointed by the God of order, no devise of men: and the Churches submit to them as to no new office.
Ans. We may suppose such a convention of Kings, the Commissioners 1or M•ssengers of the Churches have no new office, but only are met to determin of such a thing as disturbs the Churches, Act. 15 5. they differ as Elders, and such Elders sent and nominate by the Church, and act as Elders by the same official power common to Elders that are not sent, and are called by the Church Apostles and Elders, Act. 15. 23. & 16. 4. & 21. 18, 25. then sending and commissionating is a condition of order appointed by the God of order, no devise of men: and the Churches submit to them as to no new office.
- 1A commission in a Presbytery is no new office, but apower of order appointed by the God of order.
But 1. as to the messengers of the Church, and gracious and sound Elders.
2. If they speak according to the Law and the testimony, not otherwise, and the answer is as much against Act. 15. and against Mr. Cotton and all that are for Synods, either juridical or consultative, as against Mr. R. for they go to Synods, who so go by a new power of order, not by a new office.
Mr. H. This course nullifies the power of Elders, and propl••f a 1Congregation, and their proceeding in a righteous way; for the Classis may judge a member to be excommunicated, whom the Congregation judgeth. and that truly not worthy of that censure; here 2the power of Elders and people which act in a way of Christ is wholly hindered.
Mr. H. This course nullifies the power of Elders, and propl••f a 1Congregation, and their proceeding in a righteous way; for the Classis may judge a member to be excommunicated, whom the Congregation judgeth. and that truely not worthy of that censure; here 2the power of Elders and people which act in a way of Christ is wholly hindered.
- 1Pag. 119, 120.
- 2Due right of Presbytery. The votes of associated Churches added to the votes of the Elders of a congregation strengtheneth, but hindereth not right proceeding, except by accident.
Ans. This weak Argument is fully answered by me before; That Government, which of its own nature hinders and nullifies the righteous proceeding of the Congregation is not a power from Christ. True; but now the assumption is false: for the presbyterial power added to the just power of a Congregation does strengthen, and not nullify the power of the Congregation That Government, which by accident, and abuse of their power in over voting two Elders, who proceed according to the rule of Christ, hinders ⟨p. 221⟩and nullifies right proceeding in on• single act, is not from Christ, is most false: For because an abused power, and abused government is not from Christ, it follows not that the power and government it self is not from God. I added an answer 1to this in my Book which Mr. H. passeth over in silence. Suppose the Congregation and Synod agree in the truth, as they do Act. 15. Will you say that Peter, Paul and James, their power is nullified, and their three votes are swallowed up in that greater convention; because to their power is added in this dogmatical determination, the power and voices of the rest of the Apostles and Elders; yea, and some say of the whole Church, Act. 15. 2, 6, 25. & 16. 4. & 21. 18, 25. So say that the Congregation of Thyatira (suppose it so to be) by assuming to themselves a huge number of Elders and visible Saints shall by over-voting the former Congregation, conclude that Jezebel shall still teach and seduce. Mr. H. cannot say, that the added power of the Elders and Members of it self is not of Christ, but rather their abusing of their power in that wicked act, is not from Christ; for the adding to the Church two thousand to three thousand, to make five thousand is lawful, Act. 5.
Ans. This weak Argument is fully answered by me before; That Government, which of its own nature hinders and nullifies the righteous proceeding of the Congregation is not a power from Christ. True; but now the assumption is false: for the presbyterial power added to the just power of a Congregation does strengthen, and not nullifie the power of the Congregation That Government, which by accid•nt, and abuse of their power in over voting two Elders, who proceed according to the rule of Christ, hinders ⟨p. 221⟩and nullifies right proceeding in on• single act, is not from Christ, is most false: For because an abused power, and abused government is not from Christ, it follows not that the power and government it self is not from God. I added an answer 1to this in my Book which Mr. H. passeth over in silence. Suppose the Congregation and Synod agree in the truth, as they do Act. 15. Will you say that Peter, Paul and Iames, their power is nullified, and their three votes are swallowed up in that greater convention; because to their power is added in this dogmatical determination, the power and voices of the rest of the Apostles and Elders; yea, and some say of the whole Church, Act. 15. 2, 6, 25. & 16. 4. & 21. 18, 25. So say that the Congregation of Thyatira (suppose it so to be) by assuming to themselves a huge number of Elders and visible Saints shall by over-voting the former Congregation, conclude that Iesabel shall still teach and seduce. Mr. H. cannot say, that the added power of the Elders and Members of it self is not of Christ, but rather their abusing of their power in that wicked act, is not from Christ; for the adding to the Church two thousand to three thousand, to make five thousand is lawful, Act. 5.
- 1Due Right. p. 335.
Mr. H. To this Mr. R. answers, de jure, the power of the greater 1in this case ought to be swallowed up of the two voices of the Elders of the Congregation. But saith Mr. H. so the weaker should overbear the stronger, the part the whole.
- 1Pag. 120.
2. This opens a gap to endless dissension, the fewer say we have the truth, the other, we have the truth, and who shall be the Judge?
2. This opens a gap to endless dissention, the fewer say we have the truth, the other, we have the truth, and who shall be the Iudge?
Aus. Mr. A. citeth my words (as frequently elsewhere) so here imperfectly, and mutilates the sense, if their power and voices be against the truth; it is fit that many voices be swallowed up by two, Jure in fore Dei: for Christ gave no power to thirty to err, and to excommunicate an innocent person, he hath given no power, but to edification, 2 Cor. 10. 8. 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5. But I said not that Jure Ecclesiastico, the fewer, and the part, should overbear the many, and the whole. And what will Mr. H. say, the fewer names in Sardis judge that a Jezebel should be excommunicated; the whole saith no. The fewer say we have truth, the whole say, we have truth; by the brethren's ⟨p. 222⟩way no remedy, but be the matter heresy, or scandals, incest and parricide, the larger part of every single Congregation in the midst of 24. sound Churches hath a power independent, and from which there is no appeal on earth, to excommunicate the few names that are in Sardis and keep their garments clean. If ye say, so is it in a National, in an Oecumenick Council by the 1Presbyterian way:
Aus. Mr. A. citeth my words (as frequently elsewhere) so here imperfectly, and mutilates the sense, if their power and voices be against the truth; it is fit that many voices be swallowed up by two, Iure in fore Dei: for Christ gave no power to thirty to erre, and to excommunicate an innocent person, he hath given no power, but to edifica•ion, 2 Cor. 10. 8. 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5. But I said not that Iure Ecclesiastico, the fewer, and the part, should overbear the many, and the whole. And what will Mr. H. say, the fewer names in Sardis judge that a Iezabel should be excommunicated; the whole saith no. The fewer say we have truth, the whole say, we have truth; by the brethrens ⟨p. 222⟩way no remedy, but be the matter heresie, or scandals, incest and parricide, the larger part of every single Congregation in the midst of 24. sound Churches hath a power independent, and from which there is no appeal on earth, to excommunicate the few names that are in Sardis and keep their garments clean. If ye say, so is it in a National, in an Oecumenick Councel by the 1Presbyterian way:
- 1The sounder part of the Church is the Church.
I answer in either the one or the other; if there be a manifest departing from the faith, and the man of sin sit in the Temple of God, and the fornications of Babel be multiplied, the fewer and weaker being Saviour pars Ecclesiae, the sounder part are (as Mr. H. saith, Jure in the Court of Heaven) the Church.
I answer in either the one or the other; if there be a manifest departing from the faith, and the man of sin sit in the Temple of God, and the fornications of Babel be multiplyed, the fewer and weaker being Sa•ior pars Ecclesiae, the sounder part are (as Mr. H. saith, Iure in the Court of Heaven) the Church.
Mr. H. Arg. 7. This course cannot attain its end appointed by 1our Saviour, whose wisdom fails not, nor can be frustrate in its preparation. But the Classis excommunicating, when the Elders and Congregation refuse to submit, would be of no force.
Mr. H. Arg. 7. This course cannot attain its end appointed by 1our Saviour, whose wisedom fails not, nor can be frustrate in its preparation. But the Classis excommunicating, when the Elders and Congregation refuse to submit, would be of no force.
- 1Pag. 121.
Ans. Let the larger part of the Congregation by three votes 1excommunicate a godly sound man, and discern an Arch-heretic to preach, as a Godly Socinian; Where is the end of Christ attained by you?
Ans. Let the larger part of the Congregation by three votes 1excommunicate a godly sound man, and descern an Arch-heretick to preach, as a Godly Socinian; Where is the end of Christ attained by you?
- 1How the ordinances are not contrary to the Wisdom of Christ though they attain not always finem operis.How the ordinances are not conttary to the Wisedome of Christ though they attain not always finem operis.