A64001:128
London: printed by E.G. for John Rothwell, 1641London: printed by E.G. for Iohn Rothwell, 1641
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. It is drawn from the number of six days allowed for work, which number cannot consist, unless it be terminated in rest, and in cessation on the seventh. To this Rivetus answereth, that the six days of labour are in reference to the seventh of rest; the determination of which seventh day being now taken away a man may work on any day, so long as some day be chosen (whether by Divine constitution or humane, and reasonable disposition) for Divine Service, which may be in such sort, that fewer days shall be left for work. But consider.
2. It is drawn from the number of six dayes allowed for worke, which number cannot consist, unlesse it be terminated in rest, and in cessation on the seventh. To this Rivetus answereth, that the six dayes of labour are in reference to the seventh of rest; the determination of which seventh day being now taken away a man may worke on any day, so long as some day be chosen (whether by Divine constitution or humane, and reasonable disposition) for Divine Service, which may be in such sort, that fewer dayes shall be left for worke. But consider.
What more reasonable disposition humane, then that 1which is conformable to constitution Divine? now it is apparent that God required of the Jews one day in seven; neither was it ever known to be abrogated; the particularity of the day is abrogated, not the proportion of time; ground we have for the one by the ceremoniality of it, no colour of ground for the other; nor did ever I think any man set his wits on work to devise a ceremonialitie of one day in seven.
What more reasonable disposition humane, then that 1which is conformable to constitution Divine? now it is apparent that God required of the Jewes one day in seven; neither was it ever knowen to bee abrogated; the particularity of the day is abrogated, not the proportion of time; ground we have for the one by the ceremoniality of it, no colour of ground for the other; nor did ever I thinke any man set his wits on worke to devise a ceremonialitie of one day in seven.
2. But what? shall the morality of rest granted to servants, be altered also under the Gospel? did Calvin any where teach this? may not masters exact as many days work of their servants under the Gospel as under the Law? hath not ⟨p. 72⟩Christ deserved at the hands of servants to be as serviceable to their masters as ever? Lastly are those days of the World such as wherein a labouring man may maintain himself, by the labour of five days in a week as well as by the labour of six? A long time I have found it observed by traffickers in the World, that nothing is more cheap then mens labours; a notable evidence how unprofitable servants we have been unto God, and therefore he makes the labour of our hands and sweat of our brows to afford very unprofitable service unto us. Can these Divines make the World more favourable to crafts-men, and bring their commodities in better request then they are; if they could, let them then change the morality of servants rest, and for one in seven allow them one in three, or four, or five; their masters will be the more easily brought to entreat their consciences to condescend. Or if Kings had power to make the commodities of their own Country more worth, and the commodities of other Countries less worth (which upon due consideration will be found as needful equally) then place might be made for this. Till then let us be content with Calvins morality of the fourth Commandment in reference to servants rest, namely one day after six; and therewithal consider whether our Christian Sabbath must not be confined to that day as the only day of rest for servants; and I hope we shall not think it fit to allow one Sabbath for the masters, and another for the servants.
2. But what? shall the morality of rest granted to servants, be altered also under the Gospell? did Calvin any where teach this? may not masters exact as many dayes worke of their servants under the Gospell as under the Law? hath not ⟨p. 72⟩Christ deserved at the hands of servants to be as serviceable to their masters as ever? Lastly are those dayes of the World such as wherein a labouring man may maintaine himselfe, by the labour of five dayes in a weeke as well as by the labour of six? A long time I have found it observed by traffiquers in the World, that nothing is more cheape then mens labours; a notable evidence how unprofitable servants wee have beene unto God, and therefore hee makes the labour of our hands and sweate of our browes to afford very unprofitable service unto us. Can these Divines make the World more favourable to crafts-men, and bring their commodities in better request then they are; if they could, let them then change the morality of fervants rest, and for one in seven allow them one in three, or foure, or five; their masters will bee the more easily brought to entreat their consciences to condescend. Or if Kings had power to make the commodities of their owne Country more worth, and the commodities of other Countries lesse worth (which upon due consideration will bee found as needfull equally) then place might bee made for this. Till then let us bee content with Calvines morality of the fourth Commandement in reference to servants rest, namely one day after six; and therewithall consider whether our Christian Sabbath must not bee confined to that day as the onely day of rest for servants; and I hope wee shall not thinke it fit to allow one Sabbath for the masters, and another for the servents.
3. The third is drawn from the examples of the Apostles and the apostolical Church, who in place of the (Jews) Sabbath, observed the first day of the week without variation: therefore by force of the precept, one day in seven is to be observed still. Never any hath been found to change this; therefore that which hath been kept from the beginning of the World, and shall continue to the end, is to be taken for such as by the Analogy of Gods Commandment binds all men.
3. The third is drawne from the examples of the Apostles and the apostolicall Church, who in place of the (Iewes) Sabbath, observed the first day of the weeke without variation: therefore by force of the precept, one day in seven is to be observed still. Never any hath beene found to change this; therefore that which hath beene kept from the beginning of the VVorld, and shall continue to the end, is to bee taken for such as by the Analogy of Gods Commandement binds all men.
To this Rivetus answereth, that the consequence is not ⟨p. 73⟩firm; for as much as Christians observed the Lords Day not of necessity by reason of any binding precept, but of free choice. Yet was it wisely done of them, lest by a greater change they might offend the Jews. And that it might be a free monument of their maintaining the weekly remembrance of Christs Resurrection.
To this Rivetus answereth, that the consequence is not ⟨p. 73⟩firme; for as much as Christians observed the Lords Day not of necessity by reason of any binding praecept, but of free choise. Yet was it wisely done of them, lest by a greater change they might offend the Iewes. And that it might be a free monument of their maintaining the weekly remembrance of Christs Resurrection.
He sayeth they did it freely; but of things freely 1done without any conscience of duty obliging, it was never known that so universal a concurrence was found as the observation of the Lords Day. Nay Philosophers observe that things freely done as often come to pass to the contrary. Again then it was free for them to observe one day in fourteen as well as one in seven, as Breatius professeth, and consequently as well one in twenty, which Rivetus denies. Nay it stood them upon to change the observation, lest men by universal and perpetual practise might be confirmed in an opinion of the necessity of that which is not necessary. It is apparent that as the Lords Day under the Law was one day in seven; So the Lords Day in the Gospel was and still is one Day in seven. And both himself and Gomarus are driven to profess, that we may not allow a less proportion then one in seven to Divine worship. And I appeal to every conscience, to judge by the very light of nature; whether the Lord requiring of the Jews one day in seven to be consecrated unto him, it doth not manifestly follow that we Christians can allow no less then one in seven; and whether it be not fit that the Lords Day should be our holy Day; and as for the allowance of more in a week then one, let them persuade their own Churches thereunto first, and then it will be time enough for us to hearken unto them. And what should move them to illustrate the memory of Christs Resurrection weekly? whereas they contented themselves with a yearly memorial (if at all they observed any such) of his Nativity, Passion and Ascension, and sending down of the Holy Ghost. Why doth he not consider that the day of the week only whereon Christ rose is called the ⟨p. 74⟩Lords Day in Scripture, whereon John the beloved Disciple received from his loving Lord, and master, that Divine revelation of his concerning things to come.
Hee sayeth they did it freely; but of things freely 1done without any conscience of duty obliging, it was never knowne that so universall a concurrence was found as the observation of the Lords Day. Nay Philosophers observe that things freely done as often come to passe to the contrary. Againe then it was free for them to observe one day in fourteene as well as one in seven, as Breatius professeth, and consequently as well one in twenty, which Rivetus denies. Nay it stood them upon to change the observation, lest men by universall and perpetuall practise might bee confirmed in an opinion of the necessity of that which is not necessary. It is apparent that as the Lords Day under the Law was one day in seven; So the Lords Day in the Gospell was and still is one Day in seven. And both himselfe and Gomarus are driven to professe, that we may not allow a lesse proportion then one in seven to Divine worship. And I appeale to every conscience, to judge by the very light of nature; whether the Lord requiring of the Jewes one day in seven to bee consecrated unto him, it doth not manifestly follow that wee Christians can allow no lesse then one in seven; and whether it bee not fit that the Lords Day should bee our holy Day; and as for the allowance of more in a weeke then one, let them persuade their owne Churches thereunto first, and then it will bee time enough for us to hearken unto them. And what should move them to illustrate the memory of Christs Resurrection weekly? whereas they contented themselves with a yearely memoriall (if at all they observed any such) of his Nativity, Passion and Ascension, and sending downe of the Holy Ghost. Why doth hee not consider that the day of the weeke onely whereon Christ rose is called the
4. If the number of seven, (that is, the observation of one day in seven) in this Commandment be changeable; then as ceremonial, or as political: not as ceremonial; for then the Church ought not to observe it. Nor as political; for in the moral Law precepts political are not given. And to this Rivetus answereth, that the observation of the seventh day is ceremonial: and that the Primitive Church kept it not, neither did the Primitive Church keep it, nor do we keep it as ceremonial; but another seventh day, for Ecclesiastical policy sake, not civill.
4. If the number of seven, (that is, the observation of one day in seven) in this Commandement be changeable; then as ceremoniall, or as politicall: not as ceremoniall; for then the Church ought not to observe it. Nor as politicall; for in the morall Law precepts politicall are not given. And to this Rivetus answereth, that the observation of the seventh day is ceremoniall: and that the Primitive Church kept it not, neither did the Primitive Church keepe it, nor doe we keepe it as ceremoniall; but another seventh day, for Ecclesiasticall policy sake, not civill.
When he saith we keep another seventh day; he implieth 1that by the seventh formerly mentioned he meant that particular day of the week which the Jews kept; and that we indeed acknowledge to be ceremonial; but in this interpretation of Wallaeus, he manifestly corrupts his adversaries argument, which is plainly directed against the ceremoniality of one day in seven indefinitely considered, and not against the ceremoniality of the Jews seventh. Yet when he saith the Primitive Church did, and we do keep a seventh, but not as ceremonial; he speaks to the point; but his words following have no coherence herewith: so that he may seem to shuffle miserably in this, affecting to decline that which he is not able to answer. But take we him at the best, he must say that the observation of one day in seven was ceremonial, if he speaks to the purpose. Now let him show us if he can, the ceremoniality of one day in seven, and how Christ was the body of it; nothing more common then to affirm that the Jews Sabbath was ceremonial hand over head, without any distinction of the sanctification of the day, and the rest; much less distinguishing between the rest of one day in seven, and the rest of the seventh. At length I found a fair way opened for the explication of the ceremoniality found in the rest on the seventh day. But as for any ceremoniality in the rest of one day in seven; never (I think) any man set his wits on work to devise that. Lastly, ⟨p. 75⟩after such a ceremoniality is devised, we will confer whether in reason such a thing ought to be still observed as was ceremonial unto the Jews; and why may we not as well observe circumcision with the Ethiopians, who observe it only in conformity to Christ, who was circumcised?
When hee saith we keepe another seventh day; he implieth 1that by the seventh formerly mentioned hee meant that particular day of the weeke which the Iewes kept; and that wee indeed acknowledge to bee ceremoniall; but in this interpretation of Wallaeus, hee manifestly corrupts his adversaries argument, which is plainly directed against the ceremoniality of one day in seven indefinitly considered, and not against the ceremoniality of the Iewes seventh. Yet when he saith the Primitive Church did, and we doe keepe a seventh, but not as ceremoniall; hee speaks to the point; but his words following have no coherence herewith: so that hee may seeme to shuffle miserably in this, affecting to decline that which he is not able to answer. But take wee him at the best, he must say that the observation of one day in seven was ceremoniall, if hee speakes to the purpose. Now let him shew us if he can, the ceremoniality of one day in seven, and how Christ was the body of it; nothing more common then to affirme that the Iewes Sabbath was ceremoniall hand over head, without any distinction of the sanctification of the day, and the rest; much lesse distinguishing betweene the rest of one day in seven, and the rest of the seventh. At length I found a faire way opened for the explication of the ceremoniality found in the rest on the seventh day. But as for any ceremoniality in the rest of one day in seven; never (I thinke) any man set his wits on worke to devise that. Lastly,
Now because Rivetus brings arguments also to the contrary, to prove that the observation of one day in seven, under the Gospel is not necessary, but free: it is fit we should consider them also to prove what force is in them.
Now because Rivetus brings arguments also to the contrary, to prove that the observation of one day in seven, under the Gospell is not necessary, but free: it is fit we should consider them also to prove what force is in them.
1If by force of the Commandment a seventh day is to be kept, then that day is to be kept which the Commandment hath defined, which is the Sabbath of the Jews.
1If by force of the Commandement a seventh day is to be kept, then that day is to be kept which the Commandement hath defined, which is the Sabbath of the Iewes.
To this I answer by denying the consequence, and not contenting 1my self with a bare denial, I prove it to be inconsequent. For whereas God in commanding the seventh hath therewithal commanded one in seven, and withal specified which of the seven shall be rested on and sanctified unto his service: If it may be made appear that the particularity of rest on the seventh day be abrogated; and no colour can be brought for the abrogation of the proportion of time; to wit, of keeping one day in seven; it will evidently appear herewithall, that this consequence of Doctor Rivetus is unsound. Now this we prove to be most true; forasmuch as the Jews rest on the seventh day was ceremonial prefiguring Christs rest on that day in his grave; as both the fathers of old and modern Divines both Papists, and Protestants, both Lutherans, and Calvinists have acknowledged; but never any man was found to devise a ceremoniality of resting one day in seven; they may as well give themselves to devise a ceremonality in the setting apart of some time in general for Gods holy worship and service.
To this I answer by denying the consequence, and not contenting 1my selfe with a bare deniall, I prove it to bee inconsequent. For whereas God in commanding the seventh hath therewithall commanded one in seven, and withall specified which of the seven shall bee rested on and sanctified unto his service: If it may bee made appeare that the particularity of rest on the seventh day be abrogated; and no colour can be brought for the abrogation of the proportion of time; to wit, of keeping one day in seven; it will evidently appeare herewithall, that this consequence of Doctor Rivetus is unsound. Now this wee prove to bee most true; forasmuch as the Jewes rest on the seventh day was ceremoniall profiguring Christs rest on that day in his grave; as both the fathers of old and moderne Divines both Papists, and Protestants, both Lutheranes, and Calvinists have acknowledged; but never any man was found to devise a ceremoniality of resting one day in seven; they may as well give themselves to devise a ceremonality in the setting apart of some time in generall for Gods holy worship and service.
2. Now this puts me in mind of another way clearly to demonstrate the inconsequence of Rivetus his argument thus. If it will follow that in case we are bound to such a proportion of time by virtue of this Commandment, therefore we are bound also to keep the seventh day: Then it will follow as well, that because we are bound to set apart some time for the service of God by virtue of this Commandment ⟨p. 76⟩(as all confess) therefore we are bound also to keep such a proportion of time as is here specified, and the seventh day also which is here particulated; For like as God doth not command such a proportion of time in special, but by commanding the observation of the seventh day; in like sort neither doth God Command a time in general to be set apart for his service, but by commanding of such a proportion of time in special, and such a Day in particular.
2. Now this puts me in minde of another way clearely to demonstrate the inconsequence of Rivetus his argument thus. If it will follow that in case wee are bound to such a proportion of time by vertue of this Commandement, therefore wee are bound also to keepe the seventh day: Then it will follow as well, that because wee are bound to set apart some time for the service of God by vertue of this Commandement ⟨p. 76⟩(as all confesse) therefore we are bound also to keepe such a proportion of time as is here specified, and the seventh day also which is here particulated; For like as God doth not command such a proportion of time in speciall, but by commanding the observation of the seventh day; in like sort neither doth God Command a time in generall to bee set apart for his service, but by commanding of such a proportion of time in speciall, and such a Day in particular.
12. His second argument runs thus: if the observation of every seventh day be moral it must be known by light of nature, but so it is not. Therefore it is not moral; and seeing it is not political, it must be ceremonial; and therefore doth nor oblige by force of Law moral. To this I answer first.
12. His second argument runnes thus: if the observation of every seventh day bee morall it must bee knowne by light of nature, but so it is not. Therefore it is not morall; and seeing it is not politicall, it must bee ceremoniall; and therefore doth nor oblige by force of Law morall. To this I answer first.
Let but Doctor Rivetus stretch his wits to describe unto 1us what ceremoniality can possibly be devised in the observation of one day in seven; and when he hath devised it, I dare appeal to his own judgement and conscience for the approbation of it. For I do not think it possible for the wit of man with any colour of reason, to devise a ceremoniality to be constituted in the observation of one day in seven, speaking of it indefinitely as we do, the body whereof can be found in Christ; for of such ceremonies we speak, that as shadows are to flee away when the body comes in place.
Let but Doctor Rivetus stretch his wits to describe unto 1us what ceremoniality can possibly bee devised in the obsertion of one day in seven; and when hee hath devised it, I dare appeale to his owne judgement and conscience for the appobation of it. For I doe not thinke it possible for the wit of man with any colour of reason, to devise a ceremoniality to be constituted in the observation of one day in seven, speaking of it indefinitly as wee doe, the body whereof can bee found in Christ; for of such ceremonies wee speake, that as shadowes are to flee away when the body comes in place.
2. Neither doth it follow that because it is not moral nor political, therefore it is ceremonial; for some will say that it is positive as touching the defining of some particular necessarily required to the performance of a moral duty. As for example, not to go further then the matter in hand for instance; it is generally confessed, to be a moral duty by natural instinct, that some time is to be set apart for Gods service; but of our selves we are to seek of the proportion of time; it is fit for none so much as for God himself our Creator, and consequently our great Lord and master to define what proportion of time shall be allowed for his service; now this they call positively moral, as belonging to the execution ⟨p. 77⟩of a moral duty. Yet indeed not so much a circumstance thereof in proper speech as the specification of the general concerning the circumstance of time.
2. Neither doth it follow that because it is not morall nor politicall, therefore it is ceremoniall; for some will say that it is positive as touching the defining of some particular necessarily required to the performance of a morall duty. As for example, not to go further then the matter in hand for instance; it is generally confessed, to be a morall duty by naturall instinct, that some time is to bee set apart for Gods service; but of our selves wee are to seeke of the proportion of time; it is fit for none so much as for God himselfe our Creator, and consequently our great Lord and master to define what proportion of time shall be allowed for his service; now this they call positively morall, as belonging to the execution ⟨p. 77⟩of a morall duty. Yet indeed not so much a circumstance thereof in proper speech as the specification of the generall concerning the circumstance of time.
13. Yet to draw nearer to the morality of it; what? shall nothing be moral that is not known to be so, by light of nature, for what I pray? is not our nature now corrupt? nay hath not Aristotle professed that matter of morality is not capable of demonstration, but only of [Greek or Hebrew] persuasion? Nay how is it known by the light of nature, that some time is to be set apart to the worship of God that made us; but upon presupposition that God is known to be our Creator? and is this known by the light of nature? How came Aristotle then the greatest Philosopher that ever was, and his whole school, how I say came they to be ignorant of it? but upon presupposition of the History of the Creation known unto us, Doctor Field spares not to profess as Master Broad reports him, that by light of nature it is known that one day in seven ought to be consecrated to Divine Service? Yet I am not forward to say so much, but rather with Chrysostom, that now from the Creation God hath manifested that one day in a week is to be apportioned for his service; and with Azorius that it is most agreeable to reason, 2after six days of work, to set apart one to his service. And seeing God did require such a portion of time to be consecrated unto him under the Law. Undoubtedly and by the very light of nature it is clear and evident, that no less proportion of time can we in conscience allow unto him under the Gospel.
13. Yet to draw nearer to the morality of it; what? shall nothing bee morall that is not knowne to bee so, by light of nature, for what I pray? is not our nature now corrupt? nay hath not Aristotle professed that matter of morality is not capable of demonstration, but onely of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 perswasion? Nay how is it knowne by the light of nature, that some time is to bee set apart to the worship of God that made us; but upon presupposition that God is knowne to bee our Creatour? and is this knowne by the light of nature? How came Aristotle then the greatest Philosopher that ever was, and his whole schoole, how I say came they to be ignorant of it? but upon presupposition of the History of the Creation knowne unto us, Doctor Feild spares not to professe as Master Broad reportes him, that by light of nature it is known that one day in seven ought to bee consecrated to Divine Service? Yet I am not forward to say so much, but rather with Chrysostome, that now from the Creation God hath manifested that one day in a weeke is to bee appōrtioned for his service; and with Azorius that it is most agreeable to reason,