A66107:15
Ne suitor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrativeNe sutor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrative
Ne suitor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrative wherein the notorious mistakes and falsehoods [sic] by them published are detected / by Samuel Willard, teacher of a church in Boston in New England.Ne sutor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrative wherein the notorious mistakes and falshoods [sic] by them published are detected / by Samuel Willard, teacher of a church in Boston in New England.
printed by S. Green upon assignment of S. Sewall, 1681
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. That the place may sometimes make a great alteration, as to indulgence to be expected. It is evident, that that Toleration is in one place, not only lawful, but a necessary duty, which in another place would be destructive; and the expectation of it irrational. That which is needful to ballast a great ship, will sink a small boat. If a considerable number of Antipaedobaptists should (as our Fathers here did) obtain Liberty from the State, to transport themselves and families, into a wast American wilderness, that so they might be a peculiar People by themselves; practising all, and only the institutions of Christ: if now Pado-Baptists should come after them, and intrude themselves upon them, and when they cast men out of their society for moral Scandals, entertain them: Surely they would desire such persons; either to walk orderly with them, or to return to the place from whence they came. And if they would do neither, they would think that such Pado-Baptists were blame-worthy: let them th•n do as they would be done by; and deal by us, as they would have us to deal by them; were they in our case, and we in theirs.
2. Let them please to consider, that those of their persuasion in this place, have acted with so much irregularity and profaneness, that should men of any other persuasion whatsoever, have done the like, the same severity would have been used towards them. I truly profess unto them, that if any men, either of the Presbyterian, or Congregational (or never so much of my) persuasion in matters referring to Church-Discipline, should behave themselves as the Anabaptists in Boston, in New-England, have done, I think they would have deserved far greater punishment than any thing that to this day, hath been inflicted upon them. Whether the sentence passed on them by the Churches, proceeding in the Name of the Lord Jesus, were only the abuse of an holy Ordinance; or a righteous process according to Scripture Rule: the following Animadversions, will discover unto those that are willing to weigh matters impartially, in the balance of the Sanctuary. How vain is it for men, after they have received such Excommunicates into their communion, and then perceive that the World cries shame on them for it; and some of their own persuasion reprove them: in stead of abhorring themselves before God and the World; and purging out the old leaven, to think they shall come off with saying, It was a defect! and who in this world are without their failings? and then by retaining such in their communion to persist in their scandal to this very day? To parallel the case of the Anabaptists in New-England, with that of the Nonconformists in England, seems most unreasonable. Do the conforming Congregations there, cast men out of their fellowship for moral, scandalous evils? I doubt the godly Discipline which their Liturgy confesseth was in the Primitive Church, and should be in theirs, is not found amongst them: or, if they should, I believe the Nonconformists would be loth to receive any such into their Communion; which the New-England Anabaptists have done, and have persisted therein, from year to year, and that after conviction. And although in their deluding Narrative, they seek to palliate this offence, by a fallacious Representation of things; their iniquity is marked before the Lord, Nitre and much Soap will never wash them clan. If then Dr.