A66107:34
Ne suitor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrativeNe sutor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrative
Ne suitor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrative wherein the notorious mistakes and falsehoods [sic] by them published are detected / by Samuel Willard, teacher of a church in Boston in New England.Ne sutor ultra crepidam, or, Brief animadversions upon the New-England Anabaptists late fallacious narrative wherein the notorious mistakes and falshoods [sic] by them published are detected / by Samuel Willard, teacher of a church in Boston in New England.
printed by S. Green upon assignment of S. Sewall, 1681
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
6. It is a matter which hath been, and (if we believe them) is still sub judice: controverted, and that between learned and judicious, holy and good men] why then should they be so stiff for it, or we against it? it is very weak for men to be so rigid on all hands about a nice controversy, and indeterminable question, which learned and good men have not these 1600 years known how to determine. But (upon search) I find it hath been both professed and defended in all ages by the Churches of Christ: though this truth (as many others) hath not escaped the opposition of men left by God to a spirit of error: but it hath fared as well, as almost any great Gospel Truth; God having ever raised up worthy Patrons for the defence of it. If fundamental Truths must be the more charily or dubiously ⟨p. 6⟩asserted because men infatuated with Error and holding perverse, principles, yet pretending holiness (and what Heretic ever did other) impugn it, it would be a plausible way to subvert all.
6. It is a matter which hath been, and (if we believe them) is still sub judice: controverted, and that between learned and judicious, holy and good men] why then should they be so stiffe for it, or we against it? it is very weak for men to be so rigid on all hands about a nice controversie, and indeterminable question, which learned and good men have not these 1600 years known how to determine. But (upon search) I finde it hath been both professed and defended in all ages by the Churches of Christ: though this truth (as many others) hath not escaped the opposition of men left by God to a spirit of error: but it hath fared as well, as almost any great Gospel Truth; God having ever raised up worthy Patrons for the defence of it. If fundamental Truths must be the more charily or dubiously ⟨p. 6⟩asserted because men enfatuated with Error and holding perverse, principles, yet pretending holiness (and what Heretick ever did other) impugne it, it would be a plausible way to subvert all.
With these Arguments they fortify their conclusion, viz. that for one Protestant Congregation (on such occasions) to persecute another (where there is no pretence to infallibility in deciding controversies) seems much more unreasonable then all the cruelties of the Romish Church &c.] Before I saw that Narrative, one told me it was a moderate piece, and showed a Christian spirit. If they intend us not in these words they are vain mn; if they do, they render themselves the Persecutors, pursuing us with bitter words who have this to say that in all our dealings with them, we have (allowing humane infirmities) walked by the golden Rule they urge upon us (if rightly understood) doing as we would be done by.