A67926:12277
Acts and monuments of matters most special and memorable, happening in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an universal history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitive age to these latter times of ours, with the bloody times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions against the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperors, as now lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realm of England and Scotland. Newly revised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time again published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the help of Christ our Lord) John Fox, which desireth thee good reader to help him with thy prayer.Actes and monuments of matters most speciall and memorable, happenyng in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an vniuersall history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitiue age to these latter tymes of ours, with the bloudy times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions agaynst the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperours, as nowe lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realme of England and Scotland. Newly reuised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time agayne published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the helpe of Christ our Lord) Iohn Foxe, which desireth thee good reader to helpe him with thy prayer.
London: printed by John Daye, 1583London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Pendleton. Master Bradford, I do not know wherefore you are condemned.
Pendleton. Maister Bradford, I doe not know wherefore you are condemned.
Bradford. Transubstantiation is the cause wherefore I am condemned, and because I deny that wicked men receive Christs body: wherein I would desire you to show me what reasons, which before you knew not, did move your conscience now to alter. For once (as I said) you were as I am in Religion.
Bradford. Transubstantiation is the cause wherfore I am condemned, and because I denye that wicked men receyue Christes body: wherein I woulde desire you to shewe me what reasons, which before you knew not, did moue your conscience now to alter. For once (as I sayd) you were as I am in Religion.
Here master Pendleton half amazed, began to excuse himself if it would have been, as though he had not denied fully transubstantiation in deed, although I said (quoth he) that the word was not in Scripture,1 and so he made an endless tale of the thing that moved him to alter: but (said he) I will gather to you the places which moved me, and send you them. And here he desired Bradford that he might have a copy of that which he had sent to Master Weston: the which Bradford did promise him.
Here mayster Pendleton halfe amazed, began to excuse himselfe if it would haue bene, as though he had not denied fully transubstantiation in deede, although I sayde (quoth he) that the word was not in Scripture,1 and so hee made an endlesse tale of the thing that moued hym to alter: but (sayd he) I wil gather to you the places which moued me, and send you them. And here he desired Bradforde that hee might haue a copye of that whiche he had sent to Mayster Weston: the which Bradford did promise him.
Some reasoning also they had, whether evil men did receive Christs body, Bradford denying and Pendleton affirming. Bradford said that they received not the spirit. Ergo, not the body: for it is no […] carcass. Hereto Bradford brought also S. Augustine, how Judas received Panem Domini, and not Panem Dominum, & how that he must be in Christs body, which must receive the body of Christ. But Pendleton went about to put it away with idem, and not ad idem, and how that in Corpore Christi was to be understand of all that be in the visible Church with Gods elect. Bradford denied this to be Saint Augustine's meaning, and said also that the allegation of idem ▪ and not ad idem, could not make for that purpose. They talked more of Transubstantiation, Pendleton bringing forth Cyprian:1 Panis natura mutatur. &c. And Bradford said that in that place natura did not signify substance. As the nature of an herb is not the substance of it: so the bread changed in nature is not to be taken for changed in substance: For now it is ordained not for the food of the body simply, but rather for the soul. Here also Bradford alleged the sentence of Gelasius. Pendleton said, that he was a Pope. Yea said Bradford, but his faith is my faith in the Sacrament, if ye would receive it.
Syme reasoning also they had, whether euill men dyd receiue Christes body, Bradford denying and Pendleton affirming. Bradford sayd that they receiued not the spirit. Ergo, not the body: for it is no 〈…〉 carkas. Hereto Bradford brought also S. Augustine, how Iudas receiued Panem Domini, and not Panem Dominum, & how that he muste be in Christs body, which must receiue the body of Christ. But Pendleton went about to put it away with idem, and not ad idem, and how that in Corpore Christi was to be vnderstand of all that be in the visible Church with Gods elect. Bradforde denyed this to be Saynt Augustines meaning, and sayd also that the allegation of idem ▪ and not ad idem, could not make for that purpose. They talked more of Transubstantiation, Pendleton bringing forth Cyprian:
They reasoned also whether accidentia were res or no. If they be properly res, said Bradford, then are they substances: and if they be substances they are earthly,1 & then are there earthly substances in the Sacrament as Irenaeus saith, which must needs be bread. But Pendleton said that the colour was the earthly thing, and called it an accidental substance.
They reasoned also whether accidentia were res or no. If they be properly res, sayde Bradford, then are they substaunces: and if they be substances they are earthly,1 & then are there earthly substaunces in the Sacramen as Irenaeus sayth, which must needes be bread. But Pendleton sayde that the colour was the earthly thing, and called it an accidentall substaunce.
I omit the talk they had of my Lord of Canterbury of Peter Martyrs book, of Pendleton's Letter laid to Bradford's charge when he was condemned, with other talk more of the Church: whether Dic Ecclesiae was spoken of the universal Church, or of a particular (which Pendleton at the length granted to be spoken of a particular Church) also of vain glory, which he willed Bradford to beware of, and such like talk: A little before his departing Bradford said thus: Master Doctor,1 as I said to M. Weston the last day, so say I unto you again, that I am the same man in Religion against Transubstantiation still, which I was when I came into prison: for hitherto I have seen nothing in any point to infirm me. At which words Pendleton was something moved, and said that it was no Catholic doctrine. Yes, quoth Bradford, and that will I prove even by the testimony of the Catholic fathers until Concilium Lateranense, or thereabout. Thus Pendleton went his way, saying that he would come oftener to Bradford. God our father be with us all, and give us the spirit of his truth for ever. Amen.
I omitte the talke they had of my Lord of Canterbury of Peter Martyrs booke, of Pendletons Letter layde to Bradfordes charge when he was condemned, with other talke more of the Church: whether Dic Ecclesiae was spokē of the vniuersall Church, or of a particular (which Pēdleton at the length graunted to bee spoken of a particulare Church) also of vayne glory, which he willed Bradford to beware of, and such like talke: A litle before his departing Bradford sayd thus: Maister Doctor,1 as I said to M. Weston the last day, so saye I vnto you agayne, that I am the same man in Religion agaynst Transubstantiation styll, which I was whē I came into prison: for hitherto I haue sene nothing in any poynt to infirme me. At which words Pendleton was something moued, and said that it was no Catholicke doctrine. Yes, quoth Bradford, and that wil I proue euen by the testimony of the Catholicke fathers vntill Concilium Lateranense, or thereabout. Thus Pendleton wēt his way, saying that he would come oftener to Bradford. God our father be with vs all, and geue vs the spirite of his truth for euer. Amen.
The same day in the afternoon, about five of the clock, came Master Weston to Bradford: and after gentle salutations, he desired the company every man to depart, & so they two sat down. And after that he had thanked Bradford for his writing unto him, he pulled out of his bosom the same writing, which Bradford had sent him. The writing is this that followeth.
The same day in the afternoone, about fiue of the clock, came Mayster Weston to Bradford: and after gentle salutations, he desired the company euery man to depart, & so they two sat downe. And after that he had thanked Bradford for his writing vnto him, he pulled out of his bosome the same writing, which Bradford had sent him. The writing is this that foloweth.
1. That which is former (saith Tertullian) is true: that which is latter is false. 1But the doctrine of transubstantiation is a late doctrine: for it was not defined generally afore the Council of Lateran, about 1215. years after Christs coming, under Pope Innocentius the third of that name. For before that time it was free for all men to believe it or not believe it: as the Bishop of Duresme doth witness in his book of the presence of Christ in his Supper lately put forth: Ergo the Doctrine of Transubstantiation is false.
1. THat which is former (sayth Tertullian) is true: that whiche is latter is false. 1But the doctrine of transubstantiation is a late doctrine: for it was not defined generally afore the Councel of Laterane, about 1215. yeares after Christes comming, vnder Pope Innocentius the thyrd of that name. For before that time it was free for all men to beleue it or not beleue it: as the Bishop of Duresme doth witnesse in his booke of the presence of Christ in his Supper lately put forth: Ergo the Doctrine of Transubstantiation is false.
2. That the words of Christs supper be figurative, the circumstances of the scripture, the Analogy or proportion of the sacraments, 1& the sentences of all the holy fathers, which were & did write for the space 1000. years after Christs Ascension, do teach: whereupon it followeth, that there is no transubstantiation.
2. That the words of Christes supper be figuratiue, the circūstā ces of the scripture, the Analogy or proportiō of the sacramētes, 1& the sentēces of all the holy fathers, which were & did write for the space 1000. yeares after Christes Ascension, do teach: wherevpon it foloweth, that there is no transubstantiation.
3. That the Lord gave to his Disciples bread and called it his body, the very Scriptures do witness. For he gave that & called it his body which he took in his hands, whereon he gave thanks, which also he brake, & gave to his Disciples, that is to say, bread, as the fathers, 1Iraeneus, Tertullian, Origene, Cyprian, Epiphanius, Augustine, and all the residue which are of antiquity, do affirm: but in as much as the substance of bread and wine is an other thing then the substance of the body & blood of Christ, it plainly appeareth that there is no transubstantiation.
3. That the Lord gaue to his Disciples bread and called it his body, the very Scriptures do witnesse. For he gaue that & called it his body which he tooke in his handes, wheron he gaue thankes, which also he brake, & gaue to his Disciples, that is to say, bread, as the fathers, 1Iraeneus, Tertullian, Origene, Cyprian, Epiphanius, Augustine, and all the residue which are of antiquity, doe affirme: but in as much as the substaunce of breade and wine is an other thing then the substance of the body & bloud of Christ, it plainely appeareth that there is no transubstantiation.
4. The bread is no more transubstantiate then the wine: but that the wine is not transubstantiate, S. Matthew & S. Mark do teach us: for they witness that Christ said that he would drink no more of the fruit of the vine, which was not blood but wine: and therefore it followeth, that there is no transubstantiation. Chrysostom upon Matthew and S. Cyprian do affirm this reason.
4. The bread is no more transubstantiate then the wine: but that the wine is not trāsubstātiate, S. Mathew & S. Mark do teach vs: for they witnes that Christ sayd that he would drinke no more of the fruit of the vine, which was not bloud but wine: and therfore it foloweth, that there is no transubstantiation. Chrysostome vpō Mathew and S. Cyprian do affirme this reason.
5. As the bread in the Lords Supper is Christs natural body, so is it his mystical body: for the same spirit that spake of it: This is my body, 1did say also: for we many are one bread, one body. &c. but now it is not the mystical body by transubstantiation, and therefore it is not his natural body by transubstantiation.
5. As the bread in the Lordes Supper is Christes naturall bodye, so is it his mysticall body: for the same spirit that spake of it: This is my body, 1did say also: for we many are one bread, one body. &c. but now it is not the mysticall body by transubstantiation, and therfore it is not his naturall body by transubstantiation.
6. The words spoken over the cup in S. Luke and Paul, are not so mighty and effectual as to transubstantiate it: For then it or that which is in it should be transubstantiate into the new Testament: therefore the words spoken over the bread are not so mighty as to make transubstantiation.
6. The wordes spoken ouer the cup in S. Luke and Paule, are not so mighty and effectuall as to transubstantiate it: For then it or that which is in it should be transubstantiate into the new Testament: therfore the wordes spoken ouer the bread are not so mighty as to make transubstantiation.
7. All that doctrine which agreeth with those Churches which be Apostolic, mother Churches or original churches, is to be counted for truth, in that it holdeth that which these Churches received of the Apostles, the Apostles of Christ, Christ of GOD. But it is manifest that the doctrine taught at this present of the church of Rome, concerning transubstantiation, doth not agree with the Apostolic and mother Churches in Greece of Corinthus, 1of Phillppos, Colossia, Thessalonica, Ephesus, which never taught transubstantiation: yea it agreeth not with the doctrine of the Church of Rome taught in times past. For Gelasius the Pope setting forth the doctrine which that sea did then hold, doth manifestly confute the error of transubstantiation, and reproveth them of the sacrilege which divide the mystery, and keep from the Laity the cup: Therefore the doctrine of transubstantiation agreeth not with the truth.
7. All that doctrine which agreeth with those Churches whiche be Apostolicke, mother Churches or originall churches, is to be counted for truth, in that it holdeth that which these Churches receiued of the Apostles, the Apostles of Christ, Christ of GOD. But it is manifest that the doctrine taughte at this present of the church of Rome, concerning transubstantiation, doth not agree with the Apostolicke and mother Churches in Grece of Corinthus, 1of Phillppos, Colossia, Thessalonica, Ephesus, which neuer taught transubstantiation: yea it agreeth not with the doctrine of the Churche of Rome taught in times past. For Gelasius the Pope setting forth the doctrine which that sea did thē hold, doth manifestly confute the error of transubstantiation, and reproueth them of the sacriledge which deuide the mistery, and keepe from the Laity the cup: Therefore the doctrine of transubstantiation agreeth not with the truth.
This was the writing which Weston pulled out of his bosom: & yet before he began to read it, he showed Bradford that he asked of his conversation at Cambridge sithen his last being with him: and (quoth he) Master Bradford, because you are a man not given to the glory of the world, I will speak it before your face: Your life I have learned was such there always, as all men, even the greatest enemies you have, can not but praise it, and therefore I love you much better then ever I did: but now I will read over your arguments, and so we will confer them. Such they are, that a man may well perceive you stand on conscience, & therefore I am the more ready & glad to pity you. So he began to read the first: to the which he said, that though the word transubstantiation began but lately: yet the thing always was, and hath been sithen Christs institution.
This was the writing which Weston pulled out of his bosome: & yet before he began to read it, he shewed Bradford that he asked of his conuersatiō at Cābridge sithen his last being with him: and (quoth he) Mayster Bradford, because you are a man not geuen to the glory of the world, I will speake it before your face: Your life I haue learned was such there alwayes, as all men, euen the greatest enemyes you haue, can not but prayse it, and therefore I loue you much better then euer I did: but now I will reade ouer your argumentes, and so we will conferre them. Such they are, that a man may well perceiue you stand on cōscience, & therfore I am the more redy & glad to pity you. So he began to read the first: to the which he sayd, that though the word transubstantiatiō began but lately: yet the thyng alwayes was, and hath bene sithen Christes institution.