A67926:13041
Acts and monuments of matters most special and memorable, happening in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an universal history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitive age to these latter times of ours, with the bloody times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions against the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperors, as now lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realm of England and Scotland. Newly revised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time again published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the help of Christ our Lord) John Fox, which desireth thee good reader to help him with thy prayer.Actes and monuments of matters most speciall and memorable, happenyng in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an vniuersall history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitiue age to these latter tymes of ours, with the bloudy times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions agaynst the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperours, as nowe lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realme of England and Scotland. Newly reuised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time agayne published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the helpe of Christ our Lord) Iohn Foxe, which desireth thee good reader to helpe him with thy prayer.
London: printed by John Daye, 1583London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mills. 1We say, that Christ is in or under the sacrament really and corporally, which are the forms of bread & wine, and that there is his body contained invisibly, and the qualities which we do see, as whiteness and roundness. be there without substance by Gods power, as quantity and weight be there also by invisible measure.
MYlles. 1We say, that Christ is in or vnder the sacramēt really and corporally, which are the formes of bread & wyne, and that there is his body conteined inuisibly, and the qualities which we do see, as whitenes and roūdnes. be there without substance by Gods power, as quantitye and weight be there also by inuisible measure.
Bland. This is your own Divinity, to make accidences the Sacrament, and Christs real body invisibly contained in them, and so to destroy the Sacrament. And yet the Doctors say: *Materia Sacramenti est panis & vinum. And GOD by his power worketh no myracles with Hoc est Corpus meum, so to change the substance of bread and wine into his body and blood, in that he maketh accidences to be without their substance by invisible measure. I am ashamed to see you so destroy Christs Sacrament, contrary to your own Doctors, and trifle so with Gods work.
Bland. This is your owne Diuinity, to make accidences the Sacrament, and Christes reall body inuisibly conteyned in them, and so to destroy the Sacrament. And yet the Doctors saye: *Materia Sacramenti est panis & vinum. And GOD by his power woorkerh no myracles with Hoc est Corpus meum, so to chaunge the substaunce of breade and wine into hys bodye and bloud, in that hee maketh accidences to bee without theyr substaunce by inuisible measure. I am ashamed to see you so destroy Christes Sacrament, contrary to your owne Doctours, and trifle so with Gods worke.
Mills. To Christ is given all power in heaven and in earth,* so that by his omnipotent power of his Godhead he may be, and is where he listeth, and is in the Sacrament really and corporally without occupying of place: for a glorified body occupieth on place.
Mylles. To Christe is geuen all power in heauen and in earth,* so that by his omnipotent power of his Godhead he may be, and is where he listeth, and is in the Sacramente really and corporally without occupying of place: for a glorified body occupyeth on place.
Bland. Mark your own reason. All power is given to Christ, both in heaven and earth: by the omnipotent power of his Godhead he may be where he list, Ergo, he is in the sacrament really and corporally, without occupying of place, I deny your argument: for it followeth neither of your Major nor Minor. And first I would learn of you,* how you know that Christ listeth to be present at every Priests list. For if the Priest list not to say your Mass, then Christ listeth not to be there. Again ye say, all power is given unto Christ both in heaven and in earth, so that that is the cause by your reason, that by the omnipotent power of his Godhead, he may be where he list: and by that reason he had not the power of his Godhead, till he had his humane body, and then he was not equal with the father in divinity: for all power was not given to Christ, before the humanity and the Godhead were knit together, neither was he Filius. Here is more danger then ye are ware of: if ye would stand to it with just Judges.
Bland. Marke your owne reason. All power is geuen to Christ, both in heauen and earth: by the omnipotent power of his Godhead he may be where he list, Ergo, hee is in the sacrament really and corporally, without occupying of place, I denye your argument: for it foloweth neyther of your Maior nor Minor. And first I woulde learne of you,* howe you know that Christ listeth to be present at euerye Priestes list. For if the Priest list not to say your Masse, thē Christ listeth not to be there. Agayne ye say, all power is geuen vnto Christ both in heauen and in earth, so that that is the cause by your reason, that by the omnipotēt power of his Godhead, he may be where he list: and by that reason he had not the power of his Godhead, till he had his humayne body, and then he was not equall with the father in diuinity: for all power was not geuen to Christe, before the humanitye and the Godhead were knit together, neither was he Filius. Here is more daunger then ye are ware of: if ye would stand to it with iust Iudges.
Mills. We eat Christs flesh and blood spiritually when we receive it with faith and charity. And we also do eat it corporally in the Sacrament: an the body that we so receive hath life. For the Godhead is annexed thereto. Which although it be received with the body of Christ, yet it is not invisible after a gross sort, and the flesh of Christ that we receive is lively, for it hath the spirit of God joined to it. And if a man be drunken, it is not by receiving of the blood of Christ, for it is contrary to the nature of Christs blood.1 If he be drunken, it is by the qualities and quantities, without substance of blood.
Milles. We eate Christes flesh and bloud spiritually when wee receiue it with fayth and charitye. And wee also doe eate it corporally in the Sacrament: ane the body that we so receiue hath life. For the Godhead is annexed thereto. Which although it be receiued with the body of Christ, yet it is not inuisible after a grosse sort, and the flesh of Christe that we receiue is liuely, for it hath the spirite of God ioyned to it. And if a man be drunken, it is not by receiuinge of the bloud of Christe, for it is contrary to the nature of Christes bloud.1 If he be drunken, it is by the qualities and quā tities, without substance of bloud.
Bland. I am glad that you are so much against all men, to say that Christs body is alive in the Sacrament: it may fortune to bring you to the truth in time to come. Me think it is evil to keep Christs body alive in the Pyx, or else must ye grant that he is alive in receiving, & dead in the Pyx. And ye say truth that it is *not the natural receiving of Christs blood that maketh a man drunken:2 for it is the nature of wine that doth that, which ye deny not. And a more truth ye confess then ye did think, when ye said: If a man be drunken, it is by the qualities and quantities, without the substance of blood: for in deed blood hath no such qualities with it: which is evident that there is no natural blood. If a man be drunken with wine consecrated, it must be a miracle, as I think you will have it, that the said accidences should be without their natural substance, and work all the operations of both substance and accidences: and so it followeth that a man may be drunken by miracle. The body that ye receive, ye say, is alive, because it is annexed to the Godhead, and the flesh that ye receive is lively, because it hath the spirit of God joined to it. This division is of your new inventions to divide the body and the flesh, the one alive by the Godhead, the other lively by Gods spirit, and both one Sacrament: ye make of it a thing so fantastical, that ye imagine a body without flesh, and flesh without a body, as ye do qualities & quantities without substance, and a living body without qualities and quantities.
Bland. I am glad that you are so muche agaynst all men, to saye that Christes body is aliue in the Sacramente: it may fortune to bring you to the truth in time to come. Me thinke it is euill to keepe Christes body aliue in the Pixe, or els must ye graunt that he is aliue in receiuing, & dead in the Pixe. And ye say truth that it is *not the naturall receiuing of Christes bloud that maketh a man drunken:2 for it is the nature of wine that doth that, which ye denye not. And a more truth ye confesse then ye dyd thinke, when ye sayd: If a man be drunken, it is by the qualities and quantities, without the substaunce of bloud: for in deede bloud hath no such qualities with it: which is euident that there is no naturall bloud. If a man be drunken with wine consecrated, it must be a myracle, as I thinke you will haue it, that the sayde accidences should be without theyr naturall substaunce, and worke all the operations of both substaunce and accidences: and so it foloweth that a man may be drunken by myracle. The body that ye receiue, ye say, is aliue, because it is annexed to the Godhead, and the flesh that ye receiue is liuelye, because it hath the spirite of God ioyned to it. This diuision is of your new inuentions to diuide the bodie and the flesh, the one aliue by the Godhead, the other liuely by Gods spirite, and both one Sacrament: ye make of it a thing so fantasticall, that ye imagine a body without flesh, and flesh without a body, as ye do qualities & quantities without substaunce, and a liuing body without qualities and quantities.
Mills. If case so require, and there be a Godly intent in the Minister to consecrate,1 after the consecration thereof there is present the body and blood of Christ, and no other substance, but accidents without substance to a true believer.
Milles. If case so require, and there be a Godlye intent in the Minister to consecrate,1 after the consecration thereof there is present the body and bloud of Christ, and no other substaunce, but accidentes without substaunce to a true beleuer.
Bland. Ye grant three absurdities, that in a Tun of wine consecrate is nothing but accidences, and to increase it withal, ye have brought in two inconveniences: first that it is not the word of God that doth consecrate,1 but the intent of the Priest must help to it: and if that lack, ye seem to grant no consecration, though the Priest speak the word: and yet your Dotours say, that the wickedness of the Priest minisheth not the sacrament. And to an unbeliever ye seem to say, that it is not the same that it is to the true believer: and then must the believer have some thing to do in the consecration. Incidit in scyllam qui vult vitare charibdim.
Bland. Ye graunt three absurdities, that in a Tunne of wine consecrate is nothinge but accidences, and to encrease it withall, ye haue brought in two inconueniences: firste that it is not the worde of God that doth consecrate,1 but the intent of the Priest must helpe to it: and if that lacke, ye seeme to graunt no consecration, though the Priest speake the word: and yet your Dotours say, that the wickednes of the Prieste minisheth not the sacrament. And to an vnbeleuer ye seeme to say, that it is not the same that it is to the true beleuer: and then muste the beleuer haue some thing to do in the consecration. Incidit in scyllam qui vult vitare charibdim.
Mills. The substance of Christs body doth not fill the Mouses belly. For although he doth receive the outward forms of bread and wine, yet he doeth not receive the substance inwardly, but without violation. And a Mouse doth not eat the body of Christ, to speak properly: for it doth not feed him spiritually or corporally as it doeth man, because he doth not receive it to any inducement of immortality to the flesh.
Mylles. The substaunce of Christes bodye doth not fill the Mouses belly. For although he doth receiue the outward formes of bread and wine, yet hee doeth not receiue the substaunce inwardly, but without violation. And a Mouse doth not eate the bodye of Christ, to speake properly: for it doth not feede him spirituallye or corporallye as it doeth man, because hee doth not receiue it to any inducemente of immortality to the flesh.
Bland. Ye make not your doctrine plain to be understand: we must know how a Mouse can receive the substance inwardly and outwardly. Ye say he doth not receive the substance inwardly: but without violation:1 Ergo, with violation he receiveth the substance inwardly. Ye say, that the Mouse cannot violate Christs body. But he violateth the substance that he eateth. And this your proper speech doth import as much, as that the Mouse should eat the sacrament to as great effect▪ and the same thing, as doth the unworthy receiver. For if that be the cause that she properly eateth not the body of Christ, because she doth not feed upon it spiritually nor corporally, nor receiveth it to any inducement of immortality, as ye say: then it followeth, that the unbeliever and the *Mouse receiveth both one thing. And yet it cannot be denied but the *Mouse will live with consecrated bread, & then ye must grant the absurdity, that a substance is nourished and fed only with accidences.
Bland. Yee make not your doctrine playne to be vnderstand: we must know howe a Mouse can recieue the substance inwardly and outwardly. Ye saye hee doth not receiue the substaunce inwardly: but without violation:1 Ergo, with violation he receiueth the substaunce inwardly. Yee saye, that the Mouse cannot violate Christes bodye. But he violateth the substaunce that hee eateth. And this your proper speache doth importe as muche, as that the Mouse should eate the sacrament to as great effecte▪ and the same thing, as doth the vnworthy receiuer. For if that be the cause that shee properly eateth not the body of Christ, because she doth not feede vppon it spiritually nor corporally, nor receiueth it to any inducement of immortality, as ye say: then it followeth, that the vnbeleuer and the *Mouse receiueth both one thinge. And yet it cannot be denyed but the *
Mills. Mens bodies be fed with Christs body, as with immortal meat, by reason of the Godhead annexed to eternal life: but mens bodies be corporally nourished with qualities and forms of bread and wine:1 and we deny, that by the sacramental eating any gross humour turned into blood, is made miraculously in the body.
Milles. Mens bodyes be fedde with Christes body, as with immortall meate, by reason of the Godhead annexed to eternal life: but mens bodyes bee corporally nourished with qualities and formes of bread and wine:1 and we deny, that by the sacramentall eatyng any grosse humor turned into bloud, is made myraculously in the body.
Bland. Where it can not be denied that a man may live, and naturally be nourished in his natural body with the Sacramental bread & wine consecrated: ye cannot avoid that: but then ye turn to the spiritual worshipping of of mans body, by Christs body and Godhead annexed which is nothing to put away the absurdity, that either a mans natural body should be fed naturally with accidences, or else to have them changed into gross humours. But ye say, mens bodies be corporally nourished with qualities and forms of bread and wine:1 and then must ye needs grant that qualities and quantities must be made substance in man. For ex eisdem sunt & nutriuntur mixta, or else is all that is the nutriment in man, accidents and no substance.
Bland. Where it can not bee denyed that a man may liue, and naturally be nourished in his naturall body with the Sacramentall bread & wine consecrated: ye cannot auoyd that: but then yee turne to the spirituall worshipping of of mans bodye, by Christes body and Godhead annexed whiche is nothing to put away the absurditie, that either a mans naturall body shoulde be fedde naturally with accidences, or els to haue them chaunged into grosse humours. But ye say, mens bodyes be corporally noureshed with quallities and fourmes of bread and wyne:1 and thē must ye needes graunt that qualities and quantities must be made substaunce in man. For ex eisdem sunt & nutriuntur mixta, or els is al that is the nutriment in man, acciden•es and no substaunce.