A67926:13094
Acts and monuments of matters most special and memorable, happening in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an universal history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitive age to these latter times of ours, with the bloody times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions against the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperors, as now lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realm of England and Scotland. Newly revised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time again published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the help of Christ our Lord) John Fox, which desireth thee good reader to help him with thy prayer.Actes and monuments of matters most speciall and memorable, happenyng in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an vniuersall history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitiue age to these latter tymes of ours, with the bloudy times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions agaynst the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperours, as nowe lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realme of England and Scotland. Newly reuised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time agayne published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the helpe of Christ our Lord) Iohn Foxe, which desireth thee good reader to helpe him with thy prayer.
London: printed by John Daye, 1583London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Arch. Christ meant the wine, and not the cup, though he said: This cup is my blood.
Arch. Christ meant the wyne, and not the cup, though he sayd: This cup is my bloud.
Shut. Then show me whether the words which the priests do speak over the cup, do change the substance, or whether the mind of the priest doth it?
Shet. Then shew me whether the words which the priestes doe speake ouer the cup, do chaunge the substaunce, or whether the minde of the priest doth it?
Arch. The mind of the priest doth it, and not the words.
Arch. The minde of the priest doth it, and not the words.
Shut. If the mind of the priest doth it, and not the words, if the Priest then do mind his harlot, or any other vain thing, that thing so minded was there made, and so the people do worship the priests harlot in stead of Christs blood: and again, none of the people can tell when it is Christs blood, or when it is not, seeing the matter standeth in the mind of the Priest. For no man can tell what the priest meaneth, but himself: and so are they ever in danger of committing idolatry. Then was the Archdeacon somewhat moved, & sate him down, and said to the Commissary? I pray you master Commissary speak you to him an other while,1 for they are unreasonable and perverse answers, as ever I heard of. Then stood up the Commissary, and said.
Shet. If the minde of the prieste doth it, and not ye words, if the Priest then doe minde hys harlot, or any other vaine thing, that thing so minded was there made, and so the people doe worship the priestes harlot in stead of Christes bloud: and agayne, none of the people can tell when it is Christes bloud, or when it is not, seeing the matter standeth in the minde of the Priest. For no man can tell what the priest meaneth, but himselfe: and so are they euer in daunger of committing idolatry. Then was the Archdeacon somewhat moued, & sate hym downe, and sayde to the Commissarye? I pray you maister Commissary speake you to him an other while,1 for they are vnreasonable and peruerse aunsweres, as euer I heard of. Then stode vp the Commissary, and sayd.
Commis. Your arguments is much against your self: for ye grant that the bread is a figure of Christs body▪ but the Cup can be no figure of his blood, nor yet his very blood: and therefore Christ did not mean the cup, but the wine in the cup.
Commis. Your argumentes is much agaynst your selfe: for ye graunt that the bread is a figure of Christes body▪ but the Cup can be no figure of his bloude, nor yet his verye bloud: and therefore Christ did not meane the cup, but the wine in the cup.
Shut. My argument is not against me at all: for I do not speak it to prove that the cup is his blood, nor the figure of his blood, but to prove that the bare words being spoken of the priest, do not change the substance no more of the bread then they do change the cup into blood.
Shet. My argument is not agaynst me at all: for I do not speake it to proue that the cup is his bloud, nor the figure of his bloud, but to proue that the bare wordes being spoken of the priest, do not chaunge the substaunce no more of the bread then they do chaunge the cup into bloud.
Commis. It could not be spoken of the Cup, when he said: This Cup is my blood, but he meant the wine in the cup.
Commis. It coulde not be spoken of the Cup, when hee sayde: This Cup is my bloud, but he meant the wyne in the cup.
Shut. Then it remaineth for you to answer my question to the Archdeacon, that is, whether the mind of the priest when he speaketh over the cup, doth change it into blood or the bare words.
Shet. Then it remaineth for you to answere my question to the Archdeacon, that is, whether the minde of the priest when he speaketh ouer the cup, doth chaunge it into bloud or the bare wordes.
Commis. Both together doth it, the words and the mind of the priest together: yea the intent and the words together doth it.
Commis. Both together doth it, the wordes and ye mind of the priest together: yea the intent and the wordes together doth it.
Shut. If the words and intents together do change the substance, yet must the cup be his blood,1 and not the wine, for as much as the words are, This cup is my blood, and the intent, ye say, was the wine: or else the words take none effect, but the intent only. After, the Commissary in his chamber said, it was the intent of the priest before he went to mass, without the words: for the Priest did intend to do as holy Church had ordained, then the intent made the sacrament to take effect.
Shet. If the wordes and intentes together doe chaunge the substaunce, yet must the cup be his bloud,1 and not the wyne, for as much as the wordes are, This cup is my bloud, and the intent, ye say, was the wyne: or els the words take none effect, but the intent onely. After, the Commissary in his chamber sayd, it was the intent of the priest before he went to masse, wythout the wordes: for the Priest did intend to doe as holy Churche had ordayned, then the intent made the sacrament to take effect.
Shut. If the Sacraments take effect of the intent of the Priest, and not of Gods word, then many Parishes having a Priest that intendeth not well, are utterly deceived,1 both in Baptising, and also worshipping that thing to be God, which is but bread, because for lack of the priests intent, the words do take none effect in it: so that by this, it is ever doubtful whether they worship Christ, or bread, because it is doubtful what the Priests do intend.
Shet. If the Sacramentes take effect of the intent of the Priest, and not of Gods word, then manye Parishes hauing a Priest that intendeth not wel, are vtterly deceiued,1 both in Baptising, and also worshipping that thing to be God, whiche is but bread, because for lacke of the priestes intente, the wordes doe take none effecte in it: so that by this, it is euer doubtfull whether they worship Christe, or bread, because it is doubtfull what the Priestes doe intende.
Commis. Then the Commissary would prove to me, that Christs Manhood was in two places at one time,1 by these words of Christ in Joh. the third Chapter, where he saith, No man ascendeth up to heaven, but he that came down from heaven, that is to say, the son of man which is in heaven. By this he would prove, that Christ was then in heaven, and in earth also, naturally and bodily.
Commis. Then the Commissary would proue to me, that Chrystes Manhood was in two places at one tyme,1 by these woordes of Christ in Ioh. the thyrd Chapiter, where he sayth, No man ascendeth vpp to heauen, but hee that came downe from heauen, that is to say, the sonne of man whiche is in heauen. By this he would proue, that Christe was then in heauen, and in earth also, naturally and bodily.
Shut. This place and other must needs be understand for the unity of persons, in that Christ was God & man, and yet the matter must be referred to the Godhead, or else ye must fall into great error.
Shet. This place and other must needes be vnderstand for the vnitie of persons, in that Christe was God & man, and yet the matter must be referred to the Godhead, or els ye must fall into great errour.
Commis. That is not so: for it was spoken of the manhood of Christ, for as much as he saith, the son of man which is in heaven.
Commis. That is not so: for it was spoken of the manhoode of Christ, for as much as he sayth, the sonne of man whiche is in heauen.
Shut. If ye will needs understand it to be spoken of Christs manhood,1 then must ye fall into the error of the Anabaptists, which deny that Christ took flesh of the virgin Mary: for if there be no body ascended up, but that which came down, where is then his incarnation? for then he brought his body down with him.
Shet. If yee will needes vnderstande it to be spoken of Christes manhoode,1 then must ye fall into the error of the Anabaptistes, which deny that Christ took fleshe of ye virgin Mary: for if there be no bodye ascended vpp, but that whiche came downe, where is then his incarnation? for then he brought his body downe with him.
Commis. Lo how ye seek an error in me, and yet see not how ye err your self. For it cannot be spoken of the Godhead, except ye grant that God is passible, for God cannot come down because he is not passible.
Commis. Loe how ye seeke an errour in me, and yet see not how ye erre your selfe. For it cannot be spoken of the Godhead, except ye graunt that God is passible, for God cannot come downe because he is not passible.