Phil. M. Doctor, I have considered how you do weigh ⟨p. 1812⟩S. Augustine:1 and contrary to his meaning and words, you wou•d infer your false conclusion. As concerning that it was called by him the Apostolical Sea, that is not material to prove the church of Rome now to be the catholic church. I will grant it now that it is the Apostolic sea in respect that Paul and Peter did once there preach the Gospel, and abode there for a certain season. I would you could prove it to be the Apostolical sea of y• true religion and sincerity as the Apostle left it, and did teach the same: the which if ye could do, you might boast of Rome as of the Apostolical sea: otherwise it is now of no more force, then if the Turk at Antioch & at Jerusalem should boast of the Apostolic seas, because the Apostles once did there abide, and founded the church of Christ.
And where as that the whole Council of Carthage did write unto Pope Innocentius, certifying him of that was done in the general council, & willing him to set his helping hand to the suppressing of the Donatists, as they had done, that fact of the Council proveth nothing the supremacy of the B. of Rome, no more then if the whole Convocation house now gathered together, and agreeing upon certain articles, might send the same to some bishop, that upon certain impediments is not present, willing him to agree thereto, & to set them forth in his diocese. The which fact doth not make any such bish. of greater authority then the rest, because his consent is brotherly required.
And touching the succession of the Bishops of Rome brought in by s. Austen, it maketh nothing now thereby to prove the same catholic church, unless you can conclude with the same reason as s. Austen doth. And the rehearsal of the succession of the bishops doth tend to this only, to prove y• Donatists to be heretics, because they began aswell at Rome as in Africa, to found an other church of their own setting up then was grounded by Peter and Paul, and by their successors, whom he reciteth until his time, which all taught no such doctrine, neither no such church as the Donatists. And if presently you be able to prove by the bishops of Rome (whereof you do glory) that such doctrine hath ben taught by any of the successors of Peters sea, as is now taught & believed of us, you have good reason against us:
Phil. M. Doctour, I haue considered how you do weigh ⟨p. 1812⟩S. Augustine:1 and contrary to his meaning and wordes, you wou•d inferre your false cōclusion. As cōcerning that it was called by him the Apostolicall Sea, that is not material to proue the church of Rome now to be ye catholicke church. I will grau•t it now that it is the Apostolicke sea in re•pect that Paule and Peter did once there preach the Gospell, and abode there for a certaine season. I woulde you could prooue it to be the Apostolicall sea of y• true religion and sinceritie as the Apostle left it, and did teach the same: the which if ye could doe, you might boast of Rome as of the Apostolicall sea: otherwise it is nowe of no more force, then if the Turke at Antioch & at Ierusalem should boast of the Apostolike seas, because the Apostles once did there abide, and founded the church of Christ.
And where as that the whole Councell of Carthage did wryte vnto Pope Innocentius, certifying him of that was done in the general councell, & willing him to set his helping hand to the suppressing of the Donatistes, as they had done, that facte of the Councell prooueth nothing the supremacie of the B. of Rome, no more then if the whole Conuocation house now gathered together, and agreeing vpon certaine articles, might send ye same to some bishop, that vppon certaine impediments is not present, willing him to agree therto, & to set them forth in his dioces. The which fact doth not make any such bish. of greater authoritie then ye rest, because his consent is brotherly required.
And touching the succession of the Bishops of Rome brought in by s. Austen, it maketh nothing nowe thereby to proue ye same catholike church, vnles you can conclude wt the same reason as s. Austen doth. And the rehersall of the succession of the bishops doth tende to this only, to proue y• Donatistes to be heretickes, because they began aswell at Rome as in Affrica, to founde an other church of their own setting vp then was grounded by Peter and Paul, and by their successors, whome he reciteth vntill his time, which all taughte no such doctrine, neither no suche church as the Donatists. And if presently you be able to prooue by the bishops of Rome (wherof you do glory) that such doctrine hath ben taught by any of the successors of Peters sea, as is nowe taught & beleeued of vs, you haue good reason against vs:
- 1[…] The •cope of S. Augustines argument is […] the Church of Rome therefore […] in the doctrine because it hath […] Bishops from the Apostles, but […] Donatists to be schismatics, […] Church of Rome continuing […] the doctrine of the Apostles, […] still succession of […] the Apostles time, yet they […] the unity of that Church, […] other Church of their own. The Argument is this. […] from that Church which […] succession of Bishops […] Apostles, and keepeth the […] still in faith and doctrine, is […] the unity of the Church, and to […]. The Donatists do so from the Church […], having no just cause of doctrine […] to do. […] ▪ the […] ▪〈…〉 The •cope of S. Augustines argument is 〈…〉 the Church of Rome therfore 〈…〉 in the doctrine because it hath 〈…〉 Bishops from the Apostles, but 〈…〉 Donatistes to be schismatickes, 〈…〉 Churche of Rome continuing 〈…〉 the doctrine of the Apostles, 〈…〉 still succession of 〈…〉 the Apostles tyme, yet they 〈…〉 the vnitye of that Churche, 〈…〉 other Churche of their owne. The Argument is this. 〈…〉 from that Churche which 〈…〉 succession of Bishops 〈…〉 Apostles, and keepeth the 〈…〉 still in fayth and doctrine, is 〈…〉 the vnitye of the Churche, and to 〈…〉. The Donatistes doe so from the Church 〈…〉, hauing no iust cause of doctrine 〈…〉 to doe. 〈…〉 ▪ the 〈…〉 ▪