Now, when the doctrines of men go ⟨p. 47⟩for Scripture,1 you shall see how many errors rush into the Church: for grant but this to Innocentius, as the Papists do, that the bread and wine are changed into Christs body. First, it will follow,§1 that Christs body is not ascended up to heaven, because it remaineth upon earth, and so one of the Articles of our faith shall be falsified,2 which saith, He is ascē dead into heaven or if he be ascended, & descended again, another Article will be falsified,3 which saith, that he sitteth at the right hand of his Father, 4that is as Peter saith, he abideth in heaven. Secondly, it §2will follow, that Christ hath not a true body, but a fantastical body, because it may be in many places at one time: for if his body be in the Sacrament, he must needs have so many bodies as there be Sacraments; nay, he must have so many bodies as there be bits in every Sacrament. Thirdly, it will follow, that his body §3is divided from his soul, and consequently is a dead body, because the bread is only changed into body, and not into his soul. Fourthly, at will follow,§4 ⟨p. 48⟩that the wicked and profane, and reprobate, may receive Christ as well as the godly, because they have a mouth §5to eat as well as the best. Fifthly, it will follow,5 that Christs sacrifice once for all was not sufficient, because we must sacrifice him again, and break his body & shed his blood, as the Jews crucified §6him upon the Cross. Sixthly, it will follow, that the bread being turned into the body of our redeemer, hath a part of our redemption as well as §7Christ. Seventhly, it will follow, that Christ did eat his own body: for all the Fathers say that he did eat the same bread which he gave to his Disciples. §8Lastly, it will follow, that a Massing Priest shall be the creator of his creator, because he makes him which made him: all these absurdities are hatched of Transubstantiation.
Now, when the doctrines of men go ⟨p. 47⟩for Scripture,1 you shall see how many errours rush into the Church: for graūt but this to Innocentius, as the Papists do, that the bread and wine are changed into Christes body. First, it will follow,§1 that Christs body is not ascended vp to heauen, because it remaineth vpō earth, and so one of the Articles of our fayth shall be falsified,2 which saith, He is ascē ded into heauē or if he be ascēded, & descended agayne, another Article will be falsified,3 which saith, that he sitteth at the right hand of his Father, 4that is as Peter saith, he abideth in heauen. Secondly, it §2will follow, that Christ hath not a true body, but a fantasticall body, because it may be in many places at one time: for if his body be in the Sacramēt, he must needes haue so many bodies as there be Sacraments; nay, he must haue so many bodies as there be bits in euerie Sacramēt. Thirdly, it will follow, that his bodie §3is diuided from his soule, and consequētly is a dead bodie, because the bread is onely changed into body, and not into his soule. Fourthly, at will follow,§4 ⟨p. 48⟩that the wicked and prophane, and reprobate, may receiue Christ as well as the godly, because they haue a mouth §5to eate as well as the best. Fiftly, it will follow,5 that Christs sacrifice once for all was not sufficient, because we must sacrifice him againe, and breake his bodie & shed his bloud, as the Iewes crucified §6him vpon the Crosse. Sixtly, it will follow, that the bread being turned into the body of our redeemer, hath a part of our redemption as well as §7Christ. Seauenthly, it will follow, that Christ did eate his owne bodie: for all the Fathers say that he did eat the same bread which he gaue to his Disciples.
- 1Eight absurdities which follow Trā substantiation.Eight absurdities which follow Trā substantiation.
- 2Acts. 19. 11.
- 3Rom. 8. 34.
- 4Acts. 3. 21.
- 5Heb. 9. 28. & 10. 12.