Then left I him, & read: Sir Thomas Mores book, to see what Scripture might be brought for that purpose, and after that made I diligent enquire to come by my Lord of Rochesters book which also writeth on the same matter, and when I had well examined their reasons and had seen the order and process of the Scriptures which they alleged:1 I found that clearly verified which Aulus Gellius sayeth, that it were a great deal better for a man to be sharply rebuked yea and openly to have his faults published of his enemy, then to be coldly and slenderly praised of his friend.2 For a mans enemy ensearcheth narrowly and gathereth together all that he can imagine, and so accuseth a man more of a fumous heat then of any verity: and therefore the audience (if they be wise) consider his words thereafter, and so give very small credence or else none unto them. But if a mans friend before audience do praise him slenderly and coldly, it is an argument that the person is very faulty, for a friend beholdeth all qualities and circumstances, ⟨p. 5⟩his birth, bringing up, & what feats he hath done all his life long: yea and applieth many things unto his friends praise, which serve but sinally for it, for he will lean nothing behind that may be imagined to employ his friends fame and honour. Now if in all these points he can not colour out a glorious apparent laud, but is compelled for lack of matter to praise his friend slenderly, then (if the audience be wise) they may soon conjecture that he is no praise worthy, & also may well doubt whether that small praise which he gave him be true or not. Even so, when I had read these books of Sir Thomas More and my Lord of Rochester, and saw the small probations & slender reasons that those two witty and learned men had brought to confirm Purgatory: considering also that they are the chiefest friends, proctors and patrons thereof, and that they had applied many reasons and Scriptures for their purpose (for lack of matter) that rather made against them: yea and not that only, but also that they dissented between them selves in their probations: for M. More saith that there is no water in Purgatory. And my Lord 3of Rochester saith that there is water. Master More saith that the ministers of the punishment are devils. And my Lord of Rochester saith that the ministers of the punishment are angels.
Then left I him, & read: Syr Thomas Mores booke, to see what Scripture might bee brought for that purpose, and after that made I diligēt enquire to come by my Lord of Rochesters booke which also writeth on the same matter, and when I had well examined their reasons and had sene the order and processe of the Scriptures whiche they alledged:1 I founde that clearely verified whiche Aulus Gellius sayeth, that it were a great deale better for a man to bee sharpely rebuked yea and openly to haue his faultes published of his enemy, then to bee coldly and slenderly praysed of his frende.2 For a mans enemy ensearcheth narrowly and gathereth together all that he can imagine, and so accuseth a man more of a fumous heate then of any veritie: and therfore the audience (if they be wise) consider his woordes therafter, and so geue very small credence or els none vnto them. But if a mans frende before audience doe prayse hym slenderly and coldly, it is an argument that the person is very faultie, for a frende beholdeth all qualities and circumstaunces, ⟨p. 5⟩his byrth, bringyng vp, & what feates hee hath done all hys lyfe long: yea and applieth many thynges vnto his frendes prayse, whiche serue but sinally for it, for he will leane nothing behynd that may be imagined to employ his frendes fame and honour. Now if in all these pointes he can not colour out a glorious apparant laud, but is compelled for lacke of matter to prayse his frēd slenderly, then (if the audiēce be wise) they may soone cōiecture that he is no prayse worthy, & also may well doubt whether that small prayse which he gaue him be true or not. Euē so, when I had read these bookes of Syr Thomas More and my Lord of Rochester, and saw the small probations & slender reasons that those two witty and learned men had brought to confirme Purgatory: considering also that they are the chiefest frendes, proctours and patrones therof, and that they had applied many reasons and Scriptures for their purpose (for lacke of matter) that rather made against them: yea and not that onely, but also that they dissented betwene them selues in their probations: for M. More sayth that there is no water in Purgatory. And my Lord 3of Rochester sayth that there is water. Master More sayth that the ministers of the punishmēt are deuils. And my Lord of Rochester sayth that the ministers of the punishment are aungels.
- 1Aulus Gelius.
- 2The rebuke of an open enemy better then the slender praise of a friend.The rebuke of an open enemy better then the sclender prayse of a frend.
- 3M. More & my Lord of Rochester can not agree.