That reason (saith Rastell)1 proveth not only that there is no Purgatory, but also that there should be neither heaven nor hell. For if a man have lived so virtuously in earth, that he ought to be saved & go to the joys of heaven, (let us pardon him this lye, for the Prophet saith that no man shall be justified in the sight of God, if he enter into judgement with us Psalm. C. xliij.2 And yet did never meritorious act but only when the soul was joined with the body, then should he never be rewarded, but here in earth while his soul is joined with the body. 3Here may ye perceive what 4Rastell thinketh of heaven and hell, even thus that the body shall never come in heaven nor hell, which point I will touch more largely a none. First where Comingo in his argument saith, that it should seem convenient for Purgatory to be upon earth, there saith Rastell that he would take away the liberty, prerogative, and authority of God. As by example, if I would say, It should seem convenient that the Bishop of London's palace should be in London, partly because it is the chiefest City of his Diocese, 5and partly because it is nigh the Court whereto he may the better resort to get further promotion, there would Rastell say by and by that I took the Bishops liberty, prerogative, and authority that he might not set it where he would: belike this man hath drunk of a merry cup. He affirmeth also that this argument taketh 6away both heaven and hell: why so? Because he supposeth it convenient that Purgatory should be here upon earth? Albeit he say it is convenient, yet saith he not that it must needs be. Nay, but there is an other thing that Rastels sore yes can not abide. What is that? verily for he added that it were most convenient that the body which is partaker in committing the crime, should also be purged and punished with the soul. And that as ye know plucketh Rastell by the beard, for he went about to prove the 7contrary in the first chapter, that the body hath neither pain nor pleasure. &c. But how should this take away heaven and hell? for sooth on this manner. Rastell thinketh not that God can and will join the body again with the soul after this transitory life that they may together receive joy or pain for it passeth his natural Philosophy. But thus he imagineth, when the body and soul are once departed, then say they adieu for ever and a day.
That reason (sayth Rastell)1 proueth not onely that there is no Purgatory, but also that there should be neither heauen nor hell. For if a man haue lyued so vertuouslye in earth, that he ought to be saued & goe to the ioyes of heauen, (let vs pardon hym this lye, for the Prophet sayth that no man shall be iustified in ye sight of God, if he enter into iudgement with vs Psalme. C. xliij.2 And yet did neuer meritorious acte but onely when the soule was ioyned with the body, then should he neuer be rewarded, but here in earth while his soule is ioyned with the body. 3Here may ye perceaue what 4Rastell thinketh of heauen and hell, euen thus that the body shall neuer come in heauen nor hell, whiche poynte I will touche more largely a none. First where Comingo in hys argument sayth, that it should séeme conuenient for Purgatory to be vpō earth, there sayth Rastell yt he would take away the libertie, prerogatiue, and authoritie of God. As by example, if I would say, It should séeme cō uenient that the Byshop of Londons palace should be in Londō, partly because it is ye chiefest Citie of his Diocesse, 5and partly because it is nigh the Court whereto he may the better resort to get further promotion, there would Rastell say by and by that I tooke the Byshops libertie, prerogatiue, and authoritie that he might not set it where he would: belike this mā hath dronke of a mery cuppe. He affirmeth also that this argument taketh 6away both heauen and hell: why so? Because hee supposeth it conuenient that Purgatory should be here vppon earth? Albeit he say it is conuenient, yet sayth hee not that it must needes be. Nay, but there is an other thyng that Rastels sore yes can not abyde. What is that? verelye for he added that it were most conuenient that the body whiche is partaker in committyng the crime, should also be purged and punished with the soule. And that as ye knowe plucketh Rastell by the beard, for he went about to proue the 7contrary in the first chapter, that ye body hath neither payne nor pleasure. &c. But how should this take away heauen and hell? for sooth on this maner. Rastell thinketh not that God cā and will ioyne the body agayne with the soule after this transitory life that they may together receaue ioye or payne for yt passeth his natural Philosophy. But thus he imagineth, when the body and soule are once departed, thē say they adieu for euer and a day.
- 1Rastelles solution.
- 2Psal. 143.
- 3Rastels reason faileth him.Rastels reason fayleth hym.
- 4Frith.
- 5Rastell doth to much abuse him self.Rastell doth to much abuse him selfe.
- 6Rastell. Frith.
- 7Rastell is contrary to him self.Rastell is contrary to hym selfe.