I answer, if it were lawful to require 1wisdom in a man so wise as M. More is counted, here would I wish him a little more wit, for I think 2there is no wise man that will grant this to be a good argument, that Turks, Saracens, Paynims & Jews believe it to be true, Ergo, we must believe that it is true: for I will show you a like argument. The Turks, Saracens, Paynims & Jews believe that we have not yt right Christ, but that we are all damned which believe in Christ. Is it therefore true? shall we turn our faith because they believe that we be deceived? I think there is no man so foolish as to grant him this. But if M. More will have his reason hold, he must argue on this manner: The miscreants and infidels 3before named believe that there is a Purgatory & their belief is true, therefore we must believe that there is a Purgatory. Now followeth this argument somewhat more formally. Here might I put him to the proof of his Minor: which is, that their belief (in believing Purgatory) is true: which thing he shall never be able to prove. But I have such confidence of the truth on my side that I will take upon me to prove the negative, Cut̄ that their belief is not true as concerning Purgatory. For these miscreants 4which believe Purgatory, believe that there is a Purgatory for us that be Christen: for they believe that we are fallen from all truth and utterly damned. But they think that there is a Purgatory for them selves wherein they shall be purged & punished until they have made full satisfaction for their sins committed: but that is false, for neither Turks, Saracens Paynims nor Jews which believe not in Christ have or ever shall enter into any Purgatory, but they are all ⟨p. 34⟩damned wretches because they believe not in Jesus Christ. John. 3. Now sith 5they be deceived, for they have no Purgatory, but are all damned as many as believe not. Alas what blindness is that to argue that we must follow them which are both blind and out of the right way?
I aūswere, if it were lawfull to require 1wisedome in a man so wise as M. More is counted, here would I wish him a litle more wit, for I thinke 2there is no wiseman that will graunt this to be a good argumēt, yt Turkes, Saracenes, Paynimes & Iewes beleue it to be true, Ergo, we must beleue that it is true: for I will shewe you a like argument. The Turkes, Saracenes, Paynimes & Iewes beleue that we haue not yt right Christ, but that we are all damned which beleue in Christ. Is it therfore true? shal we turne our fayth because they beleue that we be deceaued? I thinke there is no man so foolish as to graūt him this. But if M. More will haue his reasō hold, he must argue on this maner: The miscreauntes and infidels 3before named beleue that there is a Purgatory & their belefe is true, therfore we must beleue that there is a Purgatory. Now foloweth this argument somewhat more formally. Here might I put him to the profe of his Minor: which is, that their belefe (in beleuyng Purgatory) is true: which thyng he shall neuer be able to proue. But I haue such confidence of the truth on my side that I will take vpon me to proue the negatiue, Cut̄ that their belefe is not true as cōcernyng Purgatory. For these miscreauntes 4which beleue Purgatory, beleue that there is a Purgatory for vs that be Christen: for they beleue that we are fallē from all truth and vtterly dāned. But they thinke that there is a Purgatory for them selues wherin they shalbe purged & punished vntill they haue made full satisfactiō for their sinnes committed: but that is false, for neither Turkes, Saracenes Paynimes nor Iewes whiche beleue not in Christ haue or euer shall enter into any Purgatory, but they are all ⟨p. 34⟩dāned wretches because they beleue not in Iesu Christ. Iohn. 3. Now sith 5they be deceaued, for they haue no Purgatory, but are all damned as many as beleue not. Alas what blindnes is that to argue that we must folow them which are both blynd and out of the right way?
- 1Frith.
- 2M. More maketh a false and fond argument.
- 3John Frith amen death M. Mores argument.Iohn Frith amē deth M. Mores argument.
- 4John Frith proveth the negative to be true.Iohn Frith proueth the negatiue to be true.
- 5John. 3.Iohn. 3.