A68831:3270
The whole works of W. Tyndall, John Frith, and Doct. Barnes, three worthy martyrs, and principal teachers of this Church of England collected and compiled in one tome together, being before scattered, [and] now in print here exhibited to the Church. To the praise of God, and profit of all good Christian readers.The vvhole workes of W. Tyndall, Iohn Frith, and Doct. Barnes, three worthy martyrs, and principall teachers of this Churche of England collected and compiled in one tome togither, beyng before scattered, [and] now in print here exhibited to the Church. To the prayse of God, and profite of all good Christian readers.
London: printed by John Daye, 1573London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1573
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
IT needeth not Christen reader (I think) now that thou hast overread and diligently pondered in thine inward senses that the treatise of John Frith, wherein he confuteth all the reason which Rastel, More, and Rochester, made for the maintenance and upholding of the bitter pains of purgatory: to commend unto thee this brief work following, named a subsidy, 1defence, or bulwark to the same. And much less needeth it to dehort thee from the vain & childish fear, which our forefathers have had of that place of purgatory, as their good works which at this day remain upon the earth founded for their thence deliverance, do testify. And forasmuch as thou art a Christen man, and rejoicest in Christ, I dare boldly affirm for thee, that thou takest neither pleasure nor joy of that place, like as some persons 2do, which triumphed of late, and with much joy and clapping of hands sent tidings into all parts, that purgatory was found again: because they read in a book named the Institution of a Christen man, this word Purgatory. And yet have I not heard hitherto, that the self same persons have showed any tokens of gladness, for Gods word translated into english: so that to me they seem to rejoice more, to have the silly souls purged with punishments when they be departed, then to have them purged with the word of God while they be here. Who will think but as they have uttered their hearts concerning Purgatory with their tongues, even so say they in their stomachs, that their holy father the Pope (whom we may as justly call the Bishop of Rome, seeing 3he is there the head of S. Peters church: as we may call the head of S. Pauls church in London, Bishop of London) hath recovered again here in England his old authority, yea that he never yet lost, because they find in their churches copes, ropes, bells and beads, with other like holiness, and on themselves long gowns, shaven crowns, and fingers anointed with the holy oil of idleness. For who will say but that these holy relics declare the bishop of Rome as clerkly as this word purgatory proveth a place to be where souls after the departure from their bodies suffer pains and punishments.
IT neadeth not Christē reader (I thinke) now that thou hast ouerread and diligentlye pondered in thine inward senses that the treatise of Iohn Frith, wherein he confuteth all the reason which Rastel, More, and Rochester, made for the maintenance and vpholding of the bitter paynes of purgatory: to commende vnto thee thys briefe worke folowing, named a subsedy, 1defence, or bulwarke to the same. And much les nedeth it to dehorte thee from the vayne & childish feare, which our forefathers haue had of that place of purgatory, as theyr good woorkes which at this day remayne vppon the earth founded for theyr thence deliueraunce, do testifie. And forasmuch as thou art a Christen man, and reioysest in Christ, I dare boldlye affirme for thee, that thou takest neyther pleasure nor ioy of that place, like as some persons 2do, which triumphed of late, and with much ioy and clapping of handes sent tidinges into all partes, that purgatorye was founde agayne: because they read in a booke named the Institution of a Christen man, this worde Purgatory. And yet haue I not heard hetherto, that the selfe same persons haue shewed any tokens of gladnes, for Gods woorde translated into english: so that to me they seeme to reioyce more, to haue the sely soules purged with punishmentes when they be departed, then to haue them purged with the worde of God while they be here. Who wil think but as they haue vttered theyr hartes concerning Purgatory with theyr tongues, euen so say they in theyr stomakes, that their holy father the Pope (whome we may as iustly call the Bishop of Rome, seeing 3he is there the head of S. Peters church: as we may call the head of S. Paules church in London, Byshop of London) hath recouered agayne here in England his old authority, yea that he neuer yet lost, because they finde in theyr churches copes, ropes, bels and beades, with other lyke holinesse, and on themselues long gownes, shauen crownes, and fingers annointed with the holy oyle of idlenes. For who will say but that these holy reliques declare the byshop of Rome as clarkly as this worde purgatory proueth a place to be where soules after the departure from theyr bodies suffer paines and punishmentes.
Doth not this pretty pageant of purgatory signify and prognosticate what Tragedy they will play ⟨p. 61⟩hereafter, when the word of God shall blow and scatter from the face of the earth, the dark clouds and mists of mens inventions, and shall scour away yt rust of fleshly understanding of the scriptures in other things likewise as it hath done in this, if ought may be found in that book wherewith they may resist? that such things may be picked out of it, the fruit which commonly hath come of all counsels, convocations, and synods since the Apostles time (very few excepted) causeth me somewhat to fear: for if a man weigh the good with the bad that hath sprung from them, he will perchance think that the lay people of all estates may well and justly say, farewell the one with the other: and no marvel, for they have not been all the children of one father that have been in counsels, as they have not been all sheep that have gone in sheep's clothing: and oft times the greater part overcometh the better. Which things gathered by experience and by reading, causeth me oftentimes to wish, that they which would be counted sincere and true ministers of the Gospel, either might and would clean abstain from such counsels, that they have no part in them, or else that they would give no more place to the fruits of infidelity (I mean mans inventions and carnal interpretations which the faith in Christ never begat) then S. Paul gave to Peter his colleague, when he left the table of the Gentiles and went to the Jews, which fact of Peter in my judgement Paul might more conveniently have approved, seeing Peter did it to the intent he would not offend his weak brethren the Jews with his eating: then the true and sincere ministers of Christ in the Gospel may wink at many things used in these days among the disciples of the Gospel: much less may they approve them with the fashion of their own living, and confirm them with the authority of a Council, and with preaching they say it is not time to speak against them: yet is it time to leave them, and no longer to seem to allow them, unless they intend always to walk in them. Had the author of this book looked after a time, as some do, he had not written against Purgatory when he did. I fear me some maintain blindness more with their simulation, then they open the light with their preaching.
Doth not this preaty pageant of purgatory signifie and prognosticate what Tragedye they will play ⟨p. 61⟩
But this have I spoken (good Reader) besides my purpose, which was none other then to admonish the 1that although Rochester, More, and Rastell, have all three (as thou perceivest by reading this former treatise) stiffly defended one heresy, yet shouldest thou not have of all three, one judgement or opinion.
But this haue I spoken (good Reader) besides my purpose, which was none other then to admonish the 1that although Rochester, More, and Rastell, haue all three (as thou perceiuest by reading thys former treatise) stiffely defended one heresie, yet shouldest thou not haue of all three, one iudgement or opinion.
More and Rochester were men of high dignity in this world, the one a Bishop, the other Chancellor of this noble realm of England, both ancient in years, of so great wit, and so 1singular erudition in all kind of learning, esteemed as well of themselves, as of many other, that no two like might in all this land be found: it was thought that for their dignity no man durst, for their years wit and learning no man was able to gay••ayt them: wherefore they were persuade to be the most meet of all other to •ake in hand the defence of the terrible pains of purgatory, either the very room datiō, or else the chief building se• upon yt foundation of the church of Rome. Rastell had nothing common with them. But only many years, and a wit sophistical, which he called natural reason. As 2appertaining to Gods word, he acknowledged himself ignorant thereof: notwithstanding he had such opinion of his wit, that he thought he could as well prove purgatory by it, as the other two had done by the scriptures, wherein I think he was not deceived. And as these three persons were not like, so took they the answer made to them not a like: More and Rochester 3thought foul scorn (see what the glory of this world, and high estimation of our selves doth) that a young man of small reputation should take upon him so clean contrary to their opinion to write against them, and (to be short) took the matter so grievously, that they could never be at quiet in their stomachs until they had drunken his blood. Rastell though he perceived his natural reason to be sore said to, yet was he not malicious, as the other were: and therefore wrote he again. Which work of Rastell came 4to his hands, when he was prisoner in the Tower of London, where he made the answer following to the same: which answer after Rastel had read, he was well content to count his natural reason foolishness, and with hearty thanks given to God, became a child again, and sucked of the wisdom which cometh from above and ⟨p. 62⟩
Amen.
Brother Rastell I thank you that it hath pleased you to be so favourable unto me a poor prisoner, as to show me a copy of your book which you have written to confute my reasons and Scripture that I have alleged against Purgatory, for that hath caused me to make a subsidy defence and bulwark to my book, which by Gods grace shall be an occasion to open more light, although not to you, yet at the leastwise unto them whose hearts the prince of this world hath not blinded but 1that the light of the Gospel and glory of Christ may shine in them. And where as you write and protest that you will bring no Scripture against me. But only rehearse my Scripture again which I have alleged unperfectly and wound me with mine own darts, and will but even do as one that playeth at tens with an other tossing the ball again, I do very well admit your similitude.
BRother Rastell I thāke you that it hath pleased you to be so fauourable vnto me a poore prisoner, as to shew me a copie of your booke whiche you haue written to confute my reasons and Scripture that I haue alledged agaynst Purgatory, for that hath caused me to make a subsidie defēce and bulwarke to my booke, whiche by Gods grace shalbe an occasion to open more light, although not to you, yet at the lestwise vnto them whose hartes the prince of this world hath not blinded but 1that the light of the Gospell and glorie of Christ may shyne in them. And where as you write and protest that you will bryng no Scripture agaynst me. But onely rehearse my Scripture agayne which I haue alledged vnperfeitly and woūde me with myne owne dartes, and will but euen do as one that playeth at tennes with an other tossing the balle agayne, I doe verye well admitte your similitude.
Notwithstanding you know right well that it is not enough for a man playing at tens to toss the ball again, but he 1must so toss it that the other take it not. For if the other smite it over again then is the game in as great jeopardy as it was before, besides that he must take heed that he neither smite to short of the line not yet under, for then it is a loss and he had been better to let it go. And finally sometime a man smiteth over and thinketh all won, and yet an ungracious post standeth in the way and maketh the ball to rebound back again over the cord & so loseth the game. And that will anger a man, and I ascertain you that ye have tossed never a ball but ye offend in one of these points, & yet besides that some time ye play a touch of legerdemain and cast me a ball which when it cometh I perceive to be none of mine, and all the court shall judge the same. These points shall be declared when we come to them and now I will answer in order.
Notwithstanding you know right well that it is not inough for a man playing at tennes to tosse the balle agayne, but he 1must so tosse it that the other take it not. For if the other smite it ouer agayne then is the game in as great ieoberdy as it was before, besides that hee must take heede that he neither smite to short of the line not yet vnder, for then it is a losse and he had bene better to let it goe. And finally sometyme a man smiteth ouer and thynketh all won, and yet an vngracious post standeth in the way and maketh the ball to rebounde backe againe ouer the corde & so loseth the game. And that wil anger a man, and I assartayne you that ye haue tossed neuer a ball but ye offende in one of these pointes, & yet besides that some tyme ye playe a touche of legerdemayne and cast me a ball which whē it commeth I perceaue to be none of mine, and all the court shall iudge the same. These poyntes shalbe declared when we come to them and now I will aunswere in order.
1IN your Prologue you assigned two causes of the making of your first book of purgatory with out alleging any texts of scripture for the proof thereof, which are the controversy of two sorts of people. One sort you 2say be those that believe not in Christ, but deny Christ and his Scripture as be the Turks Paynims and such other miscreants. An other sort be they that believe in Christ & his scripture nor will deny no text of holy scripture, but yet they will construe expound and interpret these texts after their own wills and obstinate mind. &c.
1IN your Prologue you assigned two causes of the making of your first booke of purgatory with out allegyng any textes of scripture for ye profe therof, which are the controuersie of two sortes of people. One sorte you 2say be those that beleue not in Christ, but deny Christ and his Scripture as bee the Turkes Paynimes and such other miscreauntes. An other sort be they that beleue in Christ & his scripture nor wil deny no text of holy scripture, but yet they will construe expounde and interprete these texts after theyr owne willes and obstinate mynde. &c.
Now let us consider your foresaid causes & ponder whether your book have or may do any such good as you say pretended, & whether it have converted those sorts of people, or else be any thing likely to do such a fact. And first let us see what it profiteth yt first sort which are infidels not believing in Christ nor his scripture. Our saviour Christ saith, he that believeth 1is not damned, & John Baptist confirmeth the same saying: he that believeth in the son hath everlasting life, but he that believeth not in the son shall not see life, but the wrath of God abideth upon him. Here it is evident not by my exposition, but by the consent of all Christen men, that those infidels are damned, for what intent then should Rastell teach them that there is a Purgatory: without Christ there is no way but damnation, as scripture & all faithful men testify. Then would I know by what way he would persuade that there were a Purgatory (which should be away & a mean to salvation and not to damnation) for them which believe not in Christ. This 2I am sure of (and I think Rastell be leaveth it also) that the infidels shall never come in it though there were one? This you may see that his first cause is very vain, and that if they did believe it they were in deed deceived.
Now let vs consider your foresayd causes & ponder whether your booke haue or may do any such good as you say pretended, & whether it haue conuerted those sortes of people, or els be any thyng lykely to do such a fact. And first let vs sée what it profiteth yt first sort which are infidels not beleuyng in Christ nor his scripture. Our sauiour Christ sayth, he that beleueth 1is not damned, & Iohn Baptist confirmeth the same saying: he that beleueth in ye sonne hath euerlastyng lyfe, but he that beleueth not in the sonne shal not sée life, but the wrath of God abydeth vpon hym. Here it is euidēt not by my exposition, but by the consent of all Christen men, that those infidels are damned, for what entent then should Rastell teach them that there is a Purgatory: without Christ ther is no way but dānation, as scripture & all faythfull men testifie. Then would I know by what way he wold persuade that there were a Purgatory (which should be away & a meane to saluation and not to damnatiō) for thē which beleue not in Christ. This
Now let us proceed unto the second sort of people (which believe in Christ and his scripture) and yet misconstrue it expounding it after their own wills. And let us see what fruit they take of this book & what it profiteth them & we shall find that it less serveth these men then the first: for if ⟨p. 63⟩this men believe in Christ and in his Scripture, then is it not possible that they should receive or admit that thing which is against the Scripture both by the exposition of them selves & of all the world. For this is both against Scripture and all faithful men that there should be any way to health if we exclude Christ and his Scripture. And sith Purgatory is counted away to health, he that would go about to prove it (secluding Christ and Scripture) is against Scripture and all faithful men.
Now let vs procéede vnto the second sort of people (which beleue in Christ and his scripture) and yet misconstrue it expoundyng it after theyr own willes. And let vs sée what frute they take of this booke & what it profiteth them & we shall finde that it lesse serueth these men then the first: for if ⟨p. 63⟩this men beleue in Christ and in hys Scripture, then is it not possible that they should receaue or admitte that thyng which is agaynst the Scripture both by the exposition of them selues & of all the world. For this is both agaynst Scripture and all faithfull mē that there should be any way to health if we exclude Christ and hys Scripture. And sith Purgatory is counted away to health, he that would go about to proue it (secludyng Christ and Scripture) is agaynst Scripture and all faythfull men.
Besides that if they be so obstinate that they will not receive the very Scripture but expound it after their own wills & wrest it after the same, then will they much less receive your book which is so plain against scripture, & therefore if you would think that they could be tamed by your book which notwithstanding so wresteth Scripture, then may I very well 1liken you to him that hath a wild horse to tame which when he perceiveth that he can not hold him with a Scottish snaffle will yet labour to break him with a rotten twine third: So that I can espy no manner of profit that can come of your book if you can allege no better causes then you yet show, but that it had been a great deal better unwritten.
Besides that if they be so obstinate that they will not receaue the verye Scripture but expounde it after their own willes & wrest it after the same, then wil they much lesse receaue your booke which is so playne agaynst scripture, & therfore if you would thinke that they could bee tamed by your booke which notwithstandyng so wresteth Scripture, then may I very wel 1lyken you to hym that hath a wilde horse to tame which when he perceiueth that hee can not hold hym with a scoktishe snafle will yet labour to breake him with a rootē twine threde: So that I can espye no maner of profite that cā come of your booke if you can alledge no better causes then you yet shew, but that it had bene a great deale better vnwritten.
And brother Rastel where you say 1that I advance & boast my self much more then becometh me, and that I detract and slander my neighbours, & that I provoke all men that read my book rather to vice then to virtue with such other things as ye lay to my charge, I trust I shall declare my inconvenience and give you a sufficient answer.
And brother Rastel where you say 1that I auaunce & boast my selfe much more then becommeth me, and that I detract and slaūder my neighbours, & that I prouoke all men that read my booke rather to vyce then to vertue with such other thynges as ye lay to my charge, I trust I shall declare my inconuenience and geue you a sufficient aunswere.
More and Rochester were men of high dignitie in thys worlde, the one a Byshop, the other Chauncelor of this noble realme of England, both auncient in yeares, of so great wit, and so 1singular erudition in all kinde of learning, esteemed as well of themselues, as of many other, that no two lyke might in all this land be found: it was thought that for theyr dignity no man durst, for theyr yeares witte and learning no man was hable to gay••ayt them: wherfore they were persw•d to be the most meete of all other to •ake in hand the defence of the terrible paynes of purgatory, eyther the very •oū datiō, or els the chief building se• vpō yt foūdatiō of ye church of Rome. Rastell had nothing cōmon wt them. But onely many yeares, and a witte sophisticall, which he called naturall reason. As 2appartayning to Gods worde, he acknowledged himselfe ignoraunt therof: notwtstanding he had such opinion of his witte, that he thought he could as well proue purgatory by it, as the other two had done by the scriptures, wherin I thinke he was not deceiued. And as these three persons were not like, so tooke they the aunswer made to them not a like: More and Rochester 3thought foule scorne (see what the glory of this world, and high estimation of our selues doth) that a yong man of small reputation shoulde take vppon him so cleane contrary to theyr opinion to write against them, and (to be short) tooke the matter so greuouslye, that they could neuer be at quiet in theyr stomackes vntill they had dronken his bloud. Rastell though he perceaued his naturall reason to be sore sayd to, yet was he not malicious, as the other were: and therfore wrote he agayne. Which worke of Rastell came 4to his handes, when he was prisoner in the Tower of London, where he made the aunswere following to the same: which aunswer after Rastel had read, he was well content to count his naturall reason foolishnes, and wyth harty thankes geuen to God, became a childe againe, and sucked of the wisedome which commeth from aboue and ⟨p. 62⟩saueth all that be norished therewith: In the which he continued to his liues end with the honor and glory of God. To whome be prayse for euer.