¶ I was brought afore my Lord Cardinal into his gallery, and there 1he read all mine articles, till he came to this, and there he stopped, & said, that this touched him, and therefore he asked me, if I thought it wrong, that one bishop should have so many cities underneath him, unto whom I answered, that I could no 2farther go, then to S. Pauls text, which set in every city a bishop. Then asked he me, if I thought it now unright (seeing the ordinance of the church) that one bishop should have so many cities? I answered, ye I knew none ordinance of the church (as concerning this thing) but S. Pauls saying only. Nevertheless I did see a contrary custom and practise in the world, but I know not the original thereof. Then said he, ye 3in the Apostles time, there were divers cities, some 7. mile, some vj. mile long, and over them was there set but one bishop, & of their suburbs also. So likewise now, a bishop hath but one city to his cathedral church and the country about, is as suburbs unto it. Me thought this was far fetched, but I durst not deny it, because it was so great authority, and of so holy a father, and of so great a 4divine. But this dare I say, that his holiness could never prove it by scripture, nor yet by any authority of doctors, nor yet by any practise of the Apostles, and yet it must be true, because a pillar of the church hath spoken it. But let us see what the doctors say to mine article. Athanasius doth 5declare this text of the Apostle, I have left thee behind. &c. He would not commit unto one bishop a whole ylde but he did enjoin, that every city should have his proper pastor, supposing, ye by this means they should more diligently over see the people, & and also that the labour should be more easy to bear. &c. Also Chrysostom 6on that same text. He would not ye a whole country should be permitted unto one man, but he enjoined unto every man his cure, by the means he knew, that the labour should be more easy, and the subjects should be with more diligence governed, if the teachers were not distract with the governing of many churches, but had cure, and charge of one church only. &c. Me thinketh these be plain words, and able to move a man to speak as much as I did. But grant, that you may have all these cities, yet can you make it none heresy.
¶ I was brought afore my Lorde Cardinall into his galary, and there 1hée reade all myne articles, tyll hée came to this, and there hée stopped, & sayde, that this touched hym, and therefore hée asked me, if I thought it wronge, that one byshop shoulde haue so many cityes vnderneath hym, vnto whom I answered, that I could no 2farther goe, then to S. Paules texte, which set in euery cytye a byshop. Then asked hée mée, if I thought it now vnright (séeing the ordinaunce of the church) that one byshop should haue so many cities? I aunswered, ye I knew none ordinaunce of ye church (as concerning this thinge) but S. Paules sayinge onelye. Neuertheles I did sée a contrary custome and practise in the world, but I know not the originall thereof. Then sayde hée, ye 3in the Apostles tyme, there were dyuers cities, some 7. myle, some vj. myle long, and ouer them was there set but one byshop, & of their subbards also. So likewise now, a byshop hath but one citye to his cathedrall churche and the country about, is as subbards vnto it. Me thought this was farre fetched, but I durst not denye it, because it was so greate auctorite, and of so holy a father, and of so greate a 4deuine. But this dare I say, that his holynes could neuer proue it by scripture, nor yet by any auctorite of doctours, nor yet by any practise of the Apostles, and yet it must bée true, because a piller of the church hath spoken it. But let vs sée what ye doctours say to myne article. Athanasius doth 5declare this text of the Apostle, I haue left thée behinde. &c. Hée woulde not commit vnto one bythop a whole ylde but hée did inioyne, that euery cytye shoulde haue his proper pastor, supposing, ye by this meanes they shoulde more diligently ouer sée the people, & and also that ye labour should bée more easye to beare. &c. Also Chrisostome 6on that same texte. Hée would not ye a whole countrey shoulde bée permitted vnto one man, but hée enioyned vnto euery mā his cure, by ye meanes hée knew, that the labour shoulde bée more eaysye, and the subiectes should bée with more diligēce gouerned, if the teachers were not distract with ye gouerning of many churches, but had cure, and charge of one church onely. &c. Mée thinketh these bée plaine wordes, and able to moue a man to speak asmuche as I did. But graunte, that you may haue all these cities, yet can you make it none heresy.
- 1The Cardinal and Doctor Barnes reasoned together.The Cardinall and Doctour Barnes reasoned togither.
- 2But therefore was. I an heretic.But therefore was. I an heretick.
- 3O sigmentū.O sigmētū.
- 4If I feigned sut• thing […] should be an heretic.If I fayned sut• thynge 〈…〉 shoulde bee an heretick.
- 5Athanasius.
- 6Chrysostom.Chrisostome.