The second Scripture is this. Abstain 1for a time that ye may the better give attendance to prayer. On this text disputeth the pope on this manner. Paul commandeth (saith he) lay men to abstain for a time. Ergo, much more are priests bound to abstain always. The which must always pray, and be in a continual sacrificing. This argument is also false, and not concluded after Saint Pauls mind. For S. Paul would not by this text forbid marriage, by the reason of prayer. For how could he say then, Abstain for a time? Unmarried men must abstain always, and not for a time only. Nor it is no commandment unto lay men (as the pope saith) to abstain. For S. Paul will, that they shall not abstain, except that they be both agreed. Yea and also in a case, that is, where their abstaining should be an occasion of more prayer. But if ⟨p. 334⟩their abstaining may be the occasion of uncleanness: Or else, if the one party will abstain, and the other can not: Then will blessed S. Paul that neither of them shall defraud the other. For they are more bound in this case to use them selves in the office of matrimony, then pro illo loco, & tempore to pray. For yt text is clear Uxori vir debitum reddat. Let men mark my saying well. For though we be bound to pray by the Gospel, yet I think that the circumstance of time, and place, is of mans law, & reader debitum, is in this case of the Gospel. Wherefore the other must give place. Take my words charitably, and after learning. But yet grant it a commandment. How can it follow there out, that priests shall never marry? because that lay men are bound (as the pope saith) to abstain for a time? Why doth not the pope 2rather bind his priests in time, and place requisite to matrimony, for avoiding of fornication, as S. Paul doth? All the world knoweth, that priests doth not always pray. Wherefore then doth not the pope grant them that same liberty, that S. Paul doth. For he w•ll (lest yt devil should tempt them by incontinency) that they should return again after their prayer to yt office of matrimony.
The second Scripture is this. Abstayne 1for a tyme that ye may the better geue attendaunce to prayer. On this texte disputeth the pope on this maner. Paule commaundeth (sayth hée) laye men to abstayne for a tyme. Ergo, much more are priestes bounde to abstayne alwayes. The whiche must alwayes pray, and bée in a continuall sacrifiyng. This argument is also false, and not concluded after Saint Paules mynde. For S. Paule woulde not by this text forbydde mariage, by the reason of prayer. For howe could hée saye then, Abstayne for a tyme? Ʋnmaryed men must abstayne alwayes, and not for a tyme onely. Nor it is no commaundement vnto lay men (as the pope sayth) to abstayne. For S. Paule will, yt they shall not abstayne, except that they be both agréed. Yea and also in a case, yt is, where their abstayning should bée an occasyon of more prayer. But if ⟨p. 334⟩their abstayning may bée the occasyon of vncleanenes: Or els, if the one party will abstayne, and the other can not: Then will blessed S. Paule that neyther of them shall defraude the other. For they are more bounde in thys case to vse them felues in the offyce of matrimonye, then pro illo loco, & tempore to pray. For yt text is clere Ʋxori vir debitum reddat. Let men marke my saying well. For though we bée bound to pray by the Gospell, yet I thynke that the cercumstance of tyme, and place, is of mans lawe, & reddere debitum, is in this case of the Gospell. Wherefore the other must geue place. Take my wordes charitably, and after learning. But yet graūt it a commaundement. How can it folowe there out, that priestes shall neuer marry? because that lay men are bound (as the pope sayth) to abstaine for a tyme? Why doth not the pope 2rather bynde his priestes in tyme, and place requisite to matrimony, for auoyding of fornication, as S. Paule doth? All the world knoweth, yt priests doth not alwayes pray. Wherefore then doth not the pope graunt them that same lybertie, yt S. Paule doth. For he w•ll (lest yt deuyll should tēpt them by incontenency) yt they should returne againe after their prayer to yt office of matrimony.
- 1Dist. 31. c• ▪ Nam sicut. Abstinete ad tempus, ut vacet is orationi.Dist. 31. c• ▪ Nam sicut. Abstinete ad tempus, vt vacet is orationi.
- 2The popes doctine is repugnant to the doctrine of S. Paul.The popes doctine is repugnaunt to the doctrine of S. Paule.