A69533:1207
Five disputations of church-government and worship
Five disputations of church-government and worship by Richard Baxter.
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1659
Qu. Whether a stinted Liturgy, or form of Worship, be a desirable m… › Proposition 1
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Major is undoubted, because nothing but a Prohibition can make a thing unlawful. Sin is a transgression of a Law: Where there is no Law, there is no transgression: And yet I have heard very Reverend men answer this, that it is enough that it is not commanded, though not forbidden. Which is plainly to deny both Scripture and Civil Principles. Precept makes Duty, or a Necessity ex praecepto: Prohibitions make an action sinful, which is prohibited, as Precepts prove an Omission sinful of the Duty commanded. But Licitum which is between Duty and sin, is that which is neither commanded nor forbidden. And such an act is not Actus Moralis, being neither good nor evil.
The Major is undoubted, because nothing but a Prohibition can make a thing unlawfull. Sin is a transgression of a Law: Where there is no Law, there is no transgression: And yet I have heard very Reverend men answer this, that it is enough that it is not commanded, though not forbidden. Which is plainly to deny both Scripture and Civil Principles. Precept makes Duty, or a Necessity ex praecepto: Prohibitions make an action sinfull, which is prohibited, as Precepts prove an Omission sinfull of the Duty commanded. But Licitum which is between Duty and sin, is that which is neither commanded nor forbidden. And such an act is not Actus Moralis, being neither good nor evill.
Here note these two things. 1. That though we say that a Liturgy is in it self lawful, and that all things not forbidden are ⟨p. 360⟩Lawful; yet in the actual exercise hic & nunc, it will be hard to find one actual use of it, which is not a duty, or a sin (For though I am not of their mind that think every act both simply and respectively considered is a duty, or a sin (For 1. then every act must be Actus Moralis, and so deliberate and chosen, which is not true; as for instance, the winking of the eye, &c. 2. Then nothing were indifferent. 3. Then every act must have a Reason for it. 4. And the Consciences of Christians must be perpetually tormented: as e. g. to give a reason when I walk, why I set the right foot forward before the left; or when two eggs of a bigness are before me, why I take one rather then the other: these are not moral acts.) Yet I must needs think that in the worship of God, its hard to imagine such a case, in which the using of a Liturgy will do neither good nor harm: Or in which a man cannot discern, whether it be like to do more good or harm: and so make it the matter of election or refusal. And therefore as Paul makes Marriage indifferent in it self, when its hard to find a case, in which it shall not be a duty or a sin to particular persons, so say I of the point in question: and yet possibly sometime such cases there may be. A man sometimes in Prudence may find that constantly to use a form would be to him a sin, by reason of the ill consequents, and so it would be constantly to disuse it: And therefore may find himself bound (by accident) sometimes to use, and sometimes to disuse it: And yet may see no reason at all, as to the particular day and hour, why he should use or disuse it this day rather then another, or in the the Morning rather then the Evening.