A69536:172
The judgment of non-conformists about the difference between grace and morality
London : s.n., 1676
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Prop. 16. This holdeth about the very Negative Laws of the Decalogue, e. g. To kill a Man is in it self no moral Evil; else it were sin to Execute Malefactors; and Kings, Judges, and Soldiers were the most criminal sinners: To kill a Man Authoritatively, that is, a Traitor, or Murderer, is good; that is, an Act with its due Mode and Object, which are Accidents that make it good. And to kill the Innocent, or without Authority, is sin by this Accident, of an undue Mode and Object.
Prop. 16. This holdeth about the very Negative Laws of the Decalogue, e. g. To kill a Man is in it self no moral Evil; else it were sin to Execute Malefactors; and Kings, Judges, and Souldiers were the most criminal sinners: To kill a Man Authoritatively, that is, a Traytor, or Murderer, is good; that is, an Act with its due Mode and Object, which are Accidents that make it good. And to kill the Innocent, or without Authority, is sin by this Accident, of an undue Mode and Object.
To take another Mans Goods or Money is not Malum per se; for it may be done as a Mulct, or by Law on just Cause, or for the Public defence by Authority, or by his Consent: But to take it without Consent, Right, or Authority, is sin by this Accident. So also of the seventh Commandment. The Law forbids the Act as Clothed with its undue Accidents. The Names of Injustice, Coveting, Murder, Adultery, Theft, False-witness, &c. all signify the Acts with the undue prohibited Accidents. One of our Casuists excepteth only Lying, as simply per se Evil: But he that Lieth, sinneth not because he speaketh those same words, but because he speaketh words that, in relation to his own mind, and to the matter, and to the hearers understanding, are false and deceitful: And that Relative Incongruity of the words is the accident that maketh them sinful.
To take another Mans Goods or Money is not Malum per se; for it may be done as a Mulct, or by Law on just Cause, or for the Publick defence by Authority, or by his Consent: But to take it without Consent, Right, or Authority, is sin by this Accident. So also of the seventh Commandment. The Law forbids the Act as Clothed with its undue Accidents. The Names of Injustice, Coveting, Murder, Adultery, Theft, False-witness, &c. all signifie the Acts with the undue prohibited Accidents. One of our Casuists excepteth only Lying, as simply per se Evil: But he that Lyeth, sinneth not because he speaketh those same words, but because he speaketh words that, in relation to his own mind, and to the matter, and to the hearers understanding, are false and deceitful: And that Relative Incongruity of the words is the accident that maketh them sinful.