A76988:1535
The arraignment of errorThe arraignment of errour
The arraignment of error: or, A discourse serving as a curb to restrain the wantonness of mens spirits in the entertainment of opinions; and as a compass, whereby we may sail in the search and finding of truth; distributed into six main questions. Quest. 1. How it may stand with Gods, with Satan's, with a mans own ends, that there should be erroneous opinions? Quest. 2. What are the grounds of abounding errors? Quest. 3. Why so many are carried away with error? Quest. 4. Who those are that are in danger? Quest. 5. What are the examens, or the trials of opinions, and characters of truth? Quest. 6. What ways God hath left in his Word for the suppressing of error, and reducing of erroneous persons? Under which general questions, many other necessary and profitable queries are comprised, discussed, and resolved. And in conclusion of all; some motives, and means, conducing to an happy accommodation of our present differences, are subjoined. / By Samuel Bolton minister of the Word of God at Saviours-Southwark.The arraignment of errour: or, A discourse serving as a curb to restrain the wantonnesse of mens spirits in the entertainment of opinions; and as a compasse, whereby we may sail in the search and finding of truth; distributed into six main questions. Quest. 1. How it may stand with Gods, with Satans, with a mans own ends, that there should be erroneous opinions? Quest. 2. What are the grounds of abounding errours? Quest. 3. Why so many are carried away with errour? Quest. 4. Who those are that are in danger? Quest. 5. What are the examens, or the trials of opinions, and characters of truth? Quest. 6. What waies God hath left in his Word for the suppressing of errour, and reducing of erroneous persons? Under which generall questions, many other necessary and profitable queries are comprized, discussed, and resolved. And in conclusion of all; some motives, and means, conducing to an happy accommodation of our present differences, are subjoyned. / By Samuel Bolton minister of the Word of God at Saviours-Southwark.
London: printed by G. Miller for Andrew Kembe, 1646
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. Retract unjust charges in consequential, or strained deductions fastened upon either. It is a usual fault in controversies, to extend disagreements beyond the purpose or thoughts of the persons dissenting; if they do not differ, they will make them differ; if they disagree in a little, and come not up to their thoughts, they will make their disagreements too wide ever to be composed. How ordinarily do men by drawing deductions and consequences from their adversaries assertions, fasten such opinions and tenets on them, which they abhor, and neither apprehended nor granted? I grant there is some use to be made of such reasonings; we may labour to make an opinion odious to the maintainers of it, by discovering to them what consequences and absurdities do follow, and what deductions may be made from such a doctrine, but we must not strain their assertions, and make inconsequential deductions, much less must we be so unbrotherly as to fasten all those consequences and deductions we make upon them, as their own sense, and professed assertions. Though Tertullian and others held the propagation of the soul, which certainly was an error, yet they never held it to be mortal, they expressly disclaimed that, and yet who sees not but from the one, the other might be inferred. The Calvinists charge the Lutherans with Eutychianisme, which they utterly disclaim, but yet may be inferred from their erroneous doctrine of Consubstantiation. They again charge us for making God the author of sin, which we deservedly abhor, and yet they ⟨p. 356⟩think it may be gathered from our assertions of predestination and providence.1 One of our own learned Divines, who did cast in his labours to the healing of the differences of the German Churches, allegeth this passage out of Bucer, We must not so much consider what will follow in the thing it self from every assertion, as what will follow from it in the judgment of those who do maintain such assertions — And he gives this reason, for as he who assents to the truth of some principle, cannot therefore be said properly to believe and understand — what ever may be deduced from it, so neither can he who maintains an error, justly be thought to hold all those absurdities, which abler men may infer from such an opinion, &c.
4. Retract unjust charges in consequentiall, or strained deductions fastened upon either. It is a usuall fault in controversies, to extend disagreements beyond the purpose or thoughts of the persons dissenting; if they doe not differ, they will make them differ; if they disagree in a little, and come not up to their thoughts, they will make their disagreements too wide ever to be composed. How ordinarily do men by drawing deductions and consequences from their adversaries assertions, fasten such opinions and tenents on them, which they abhorre, and neither apprehended nor granted? I grant there is some use to be made of such reasonings; we may labour to make an opinion odious to the maintainers of it, by discovering to them what consequences and absurdities do follow, and what deductions may be made from such a doctrine, but we must not strain their assertions, and make inconsequentiall deductions, much lesse must we be so unbrotherly as to fasten all those consequences and deductions we make upon them, as their own sense, and professed assertions. Though Tertullian and others held the propagation of the soul, which certainly was an errour, yet they never held it to be mortall, they expressely disclaimed that, and yet who sees not but from the one, the other might be inferred. The Calvinists charge the Lutherans with Eutychianisme, which they utterly disclaim, but yet may be inferred from their erroneous doctrine of Consubstantiation. They again charge us for making God the authour of sin, which we deservedly abhor, and yet they