Answ. Not to speak much to the Connection here, which lies open enough to just exception: *for God may punish sin, and yet not reward obedience. In our obedience (if it were perfect) we do but what we should do, as Christ hints it to us, in Luk. 17.10. When you have done all which is commanded you, say, you are unprofitable servants, and have but done that which was your duty to do. But when we sin, we do that which we should not do: and therefore may God punish the one, and yet not reward the other. The punishment of our sin is but the just demerit of our evil; but the reward of our obedience is the gift of his own mercy: athe Apostle speaks so much when he tells us, The wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus ⟨p. 268⟩Christ our Lord, 3Rom. 6.23. Man may provoke God to justice, but cannot tempt God to mercy; our sins draw out his justice, but his mercy is the issue of his own heart. We can do that for which God may damn us; but we cannot do that for which he may save us: and therefore you see though the parts be granted to be true, yet the connection lies open to just exception. But secondly, it is granted that blessings are promised to obedience, and punishments are threatened to sin: but shall we judge nothing blessings but the enjoyment of temporal and outward good things: may not losses be blessings as well as enjoyments? and may not enjoyments be punishments, when yet losses are blessings? Certainly they may be so in truth, though not in name; they may be so in Gods intention, though not in our apprehension. bAnd to speak truth, nothing is adverse but what doth obstacle our eternal happiness; and nothing prosperous, but what is advantageous to it. ⟨p. 269⟩Thirdly, it is granted again that God doth reward obedience, and punisheth sin: but it is one thing for God to reward obedience, and another thing for man to eye reward in his obeying. It is granted to be the end of the work; but this is disputed, whether it should be the end of the workman, and upon those considerations propounded. And though God doth reward obedience, and punish sin, yet as we do not avoid sin, because of temporal punishment; so we do not perform duty because of reward: — I say, reward, as it is restrained here to temporal enjoyments.
Answ. Not to speake much to the Connexion here, which lies open enough to just exception: *for God may punish sinne, and yet not reward obedience. In our obedience (if it were perfect) we doe but what we should doe, as Christ hints it to us, in Luk. 17.10. When you have done all which is commanded you, say, you are unprofitable servants, and have but done that which was your duty to do. But when we sin, we do that which we should not doe: and therefore may God punish the one, and yet not reward the other. The punishment of our sinne is but the just demerit of our evil; but the reward of our obedience is the gift of his owne mercy: athe Apostle speakes so much when he tels us, The wages of sinne is death; but the gift of God is eternall life through Iesus ⟨p. 268⟩Christ our Lord, 3Rom. 6.23. Man may provoke God to justice, but cannot tempt God to mercy; our sinnes draw out his justice, but his mercy is the issue of his owne heart. We can doe that for which God may damne us; but we cannot doe that for which he may save us: and therefore you see though the parts be granted to be true, yet the connexion lies open to just exception. But secondly, it is granted that blessings are promised to obedience, and punishments are threatened to sinne: but shall we judge nothing blessings but the enjoyment of temporall and outward good things: may not losses be blessings as well as enioyments? and may not enioyments be punishments, when yet losses are blessings? Certainly they may be so in truth, though not in name; they may be so in Gods intention, though not in our apprehension. bAnd to speake truth, nothing is adverse but what doth obstacle our eternall happinesse; and nothing prosperous, but what is advantagious to it. ⟨p. 269⟩Thirdly, it is granted againe that God doth reward obedience, and punisheth sinne: but it is one thing for God to reward obedience, and another thing for man to eye reward in his obeying. It is granted to be the end of the worke; but this is disputed, whether it should be the end of the workeman, and upon those considerations propounded. And though God doth reward obedience, and punish sinne, yet as we doe not avoyd sinne, because of temporall punishment; so we do not performe duty because of reward: — I say, reward, as it is restrained here to temporall enjoyments.
- *Lex obligat ad obediendum et obedientem debita mercede compensat, transgredientem vero punit, quanquam non tam necesse fit obedienti suam mercedem esse, quam transgredienti poenam, quia lex imperat ea, quae jam ex officie dehentur, sed hoc nunc nihil ad nos. Chamier.
- aRom. 6.23. [Greek or Hebrew] Photius apud Occum. in locum.Rom. 6.23. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Photius apud Occum. in locum.
- 3Cui redderet justus judex coronam si non donasset gratiam misericors pater? et quomodo esset justitia, nisi praecessit gratia quae justificat impium? quomodo ista debita redderentur, nifi prius ista indebita darē tur? Aug. Multum invenies domine unde damnes, nihil unde salves. Aug. Amat deus, non aliunde hoc habet, sed ipse est unde amat, et ideo vehementius amat— Bern. Quomodo censeret deus opera nostra mercede digna, nifi quod in illis quod poena dignum est immensa benignitate aboleret? Aug.Cui redderet justus judex coronam si non donasset gratiam misericors pater? et quomodo esset justitia, nisi praecessit gratia quae justificat impium? quomodo ista debita redderentur, nifi prius ista indebita darē tur? Aug. Multum invenies domine unde damnes, nihil unde salves. Aug. Amat deus, non aliunde hoc habet, sed ipse est unde amat, et ideo vehementius amat— Bern. Quomodo censeret deus opera nostra mercede digna, nifi quod in illis quod poena dignum est immensa benignitate aboleret? Aug.
- bSi vera loqui velimus, quid est adversum, nifi quod nobis obstat ad aeternam foelicitatem properantibus? quid prosperum. nisi quod eo conducit? Consul. Epist. (ad Synod. Lond) ab Eccles. Walach. conscript.