A78779:19
The door of truth opened
The door of truth opened: or, A brief and true narrative of the occasion how Mr Henry Burton came to shut himself out of the church-doors of Aldermanbury: published in answer to a paper, called, Truth shut out of doors: for the vindication of the minister and people of Aldermanbury, who are in this paper most wrongfully and unjustly charged; and also for the undeceiving of the underwriters, and of all those that are misinformed about this business. In the name, and with the consent of the whole church of Aldermanburie.The door of truth opened: or, A brief and true narrative of the occasion how Mr Henry Burton came to shut himself out of the church-doors of Aldermanbury: published in answer to a paper, called, Truth shut out of doors: for the vindication of the minister and people of Aldermanbury, who are in this paper most wrongfully and unjustly charged; and also for the undeceiving of the underwriters, and of all those that are misinformed about this businesse. In the name, and with the consent of the whole church of Aldermanburie.
London: printed for Christopher Meredith, 1645
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. This mischief also will follow, That all Presbyterian Ministers, in whose Churches these our brethren preach, with such a resolution made known, must either by their silence be accessary to the misguiding of their people, or by confuting them, make their Pulpits places of strife and contention, to the great disturbance of piety & peace, or do a third thing which will not be very pleasing to them or us.
But it seems strange to us, that M. Burton should think himself bound to preach his particular opinion in every Congregation: And that all truths (as he calls them) are to be preached at all times, in all places. Is it not sufficient to preach his private judgement to his own gathered Church, but he must think himself bound in conscience to come to infect (for so we judge it) all Congregations wheresoever he comes? If this should be the principle likewise (which God forbid) of all his brethren, let the wise Reader consider what a City-devouring fire this principle would quickly kindle.
But it seems strange to us, that M. Burton should thinke himself bound to preach his particular opinion in every Congregation: And that all truths (as he cals them) are to be preached at all times, in all places. Is it not sufficient to preach his private judgement to his own gathered Church, but he must think himself bound in conscience to come to infect (for so we judge it) all Congregations wheresoever he comes? If this should be the principle likewise (which God forbid) of all his brethren, let the wise Reader consider what a City-devouring fire this principle would quickly kindle.
3. Thirdly, M. Burton doth take it for granted, that he did preach no otherwise, Sept. 23. 1645. then is set down in the Narrative. But certainly, if he had preached only, as he saith, against man worship, and will-worship, blind obedience and resting finally upon mens determinations in matters of religion, without looking into the rule of the Word; those of us that heard him, would not have taken the least offence at it: For we have often, and often heard the same doctrine from our own Minister. And therefore we think it very rashly done of him, to charge M. Calamy, That he should in the face of God, and of the Congregation, bring this truth as a grievous sin to be bewailed: for he cannot but know that this is very unlikely, if not impossible to be true.