A78779:23
The door of truth opened
The door of truth opened: or, A brief and true narrative of the occasion how Mr Henry Burton came to shut himself out of the church-doors of Aldermanbury: published in answer to a paper, called, Truth shut out of doors: for the vindication of the minister and people of Aldermanbury, who are in this paper most wrongfully and unjustly charged; and also for the undeceiving of the underwriters, and of all those that are misinformed about this business. In the name, and with the consent of the whole church of Aldermanburie.The door of truth opened: or, A brief and true narrative of the occasion how Mr Henry Burton came to shut himself out of the church-doors of Aldermanbury: published in answer to a paper, called, Truth shut out of doors: for the vindication of the minister and people of Aldermanbury, who are in this paper most wrongfully and unjustly charged; and also for the undeceiving of the underwriters, and of all those that are misinformed about this businesse. In the name, and with the consent of the whole church of Aldermanburie.
London: printed for Christopher Meredith, 1645
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ob. But, saith M. Burton in his conference with M. Calamy, Will you not give credit to me, as well as to those that informed against me?
Answ. If he saith, That these things are not in his notes, or that he intended not to preach thus, we will believe him. But if M. Burton saith directly, He did not preach thus; We conceive it a very unsafe thing for a man to affirm a Negative, when three or four will witness the Affirmative. One that heard him at that time, tells, that when he said, Mistake me not, he added presently, I scorn mistakes. And the party perceived he began a little to be angry. And a man in a passion may say that which was not in his Notes. But if he thinks this harsh dealing, let him but review his Narrative, and consider how he deals with M. Calamy, believing and publishing to all the world what he collected out of his Sermon, but from one man, who is one, as we hear, of his own Congregation; whereas we have witness, more then one, for what we say. And also not believing that M. Calamy was not acquainted with his shutting out (as he calls it) though the Church-wardens came on purpose to certify him of it. And though he himself affirmed it to him: […] the conference he had with him, and though he hath no witness to prove the contrary. So great is his uncharitableness.
Answ. If he saith, That these things are not in his notes, or that he intended not to preach thus, we will believe him. But if M. Burton saith directly, He did not preach thus; We conceive it a very unsafe thing for a man to affirm a Negative, when three or four will witnesse the Affirmative. One that heard him at that time, tells, that when he said, Mistake me not, he added presently, I scorn mistakes. And the party perceived he began a little to be angry. And a man in a passion may say that which was not in his Notes. But if he thinks this harsh dealing, let him but review his Narrative, and consider how he deals with M. Calamy, believing and publishing to all the world what he collected out of his Sermon, but from one man, who is one, as we hear, of his own Congregation; whereas we have witnesse, more then one, for what we say. And also not believing that M. Calamy was not acquainted with his shutting out (as he cals it) though the Church-wardens came on purpose to certifie him of it. And though he himself affirmed it to him: the conference he had with him, and though he hath no witnesse to prove the contrary. So great is his uncharitablenesse.