A80614:70
The controversy concerning liberty of conscience in matters of religion, truly stated, and distinctly…The controversie concerning liberty of conscience in matters of religion, truly stated, and distinctly…
The controversy concerning liberty of conscience in matters of religion, truly stated, and distinctly and plainly handled, by Mr. John Cotton of Boston in New-England. By way of answer to some arguments to the contrary sent unto him, wherein you have, against all cavils of turbulent spirits, clearly manifested, wherein liberty of conscience in matters of religion ought to be permitted, and in what cases it ought not, by the said Mr. Cotton.The controversie concerning liberty of conscience in matters of religion, truly stated, and distinctly and plainly handled, by Mr. John Cotton of Boston in New-England. By way of answer to some arguments to the contrary sent unto him, vvherein you have, against all cavils of turbulent spirits, clearly manifested, wherein liberty of conscience in matters of religion ought to be permitted, and in what cases it ought not, by the said Mr. Cotton.
London: printed for Thomas Banks, 1646
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I come now to your third and last argument taken from the judgment of ancient writers, yea even of Papists themselves, who have condemned persecution for conscience sake.
You begin with Hilary, whose testimony we might admit without any prejudice to the truth; for it is true the Christian Church doth not persecute, but is persecuted, but to excommunicate a Heretic is not to persecute, that is not to punish an innocent, but a culpable and damnable person, and that not for conscience, but for persisting in error against light of conscience whereof it hath been convinced.
You begin with Hilary, whose testimony we might admit without any prejudice to the truth; for it is true the Christian Church doth not persecute, but is persecuted, but to excommunicate a Heretique is not to persecute, that is not to punish an innocent, but a culpable and damnable person, and that not for conscience, but for persisting in error against light of conscience whereof it hath been convinced.
It is true also what he saith, that the Apostles did, neither may we ⟨p. 12⟩propagate Christian Religion by the Sword, but if Pagans cannot be won by the Word, they are not to be compelled by the Sword: Nevertheless this hindereth not, but that if they or any other should blaspheme the true God and his true Religion, they ought not to be severely punished, and no less do they deserve, who seduce from the truth to damnable Heresy or Idolatry.
It is true also what he saith, that the Apostles did, neither may we ⟨p. 12⟩propagate Christian Religion by the Sword, but if Pagans cannot be won by the Word, they are not to be compelled by the Sword: Neverthelesse this hindreth not, but that if they or any other should blaspheme the true God and his true Religion, they ought not to be severely punished, and no lesse do they deserve, who seduce from the truth to damnable Heresie or Idolatry.