A80626:134
A modest and clear answer to Mr. Ball's discourse of set forms of prayer.…A modest and cleer ansvver to Mr. Ball's discourse of set formes of prayer.…
A modest and clear answer to Mr. Ball's discourse of set forms of prayer. Written by the reverend and learned John Cotton, B.D. and teacher of the Church of Christ at Boston in New-England. Published for the benefit of those who desire satisfaction in that pointA modest and cleer ansvver to Mr. Ball's discourse of set formes of prayer. Written by the reverend and learned John Cotton, B.D. and teacher of the Church of Christ at Boston in New-England. Published for the benefit of those who desire satisfaction in that point
London: printed for H. Overton, 1642
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Our answer is ready, and plain, just and short, we deny both the Major Proposition, and the ground of the Minor; for (to speak first to the former) it doth not follow that prescript form of prayer invented by men is lawful, because a form prescribed of God is good and allowable; the Reason whereof is sound and evident; though God forbid men to make themselves any Image, or likeness in his worship, yet he hath not forbidden himself this power to prescribe any Image or form to us; he appointed his people to make the Cherubims to worship him before them, both in the Tabernacle and Temple; but yet when Jeroboam made to himself the like form at Dan and Bethel, ⟨p. 45⟩and prescribed them to the people, it was a manifest breach of the second Commandment; what reply doth the Discourser return to this?
Answ. Our answer is ready, and plain, just and short, we deny both the Major Proposition, and the ground of the Minor; for (to speak first to the former) it doth not follow that prescript form of prayer invented by men is lawfull, because a form prescribed of God is good and allowable; the Reason whereof is sound and evident; though God forbid men to make themselves any Image, or likenesse in his worship, yet he hath not forbidden himselfe this power to prescribe any Image or form to us; he appointed his people to make the Cherubims to worship him before them, both in the Tabernacle and Temple; but yet when Jeroboam made to himself the like form at Dan and Bethel, ⟨p. 45⟩and prescribed them to the people, it was a manifest breach of the second Commandement; what reply doth the Discourser return to this?
Disc. A mere shift (say you) instead of an answer: for the question is not of this or that form in particular, but of a prescript form in it self considered; the Lords Prayer was indited, or prescribed by our Saviour himself, and they yet deny the use thereof as a prayer, and most of the Reasons which they bring, do conclude against every set form of prayer, as well as against any one; thus they argue: If a set form of Prayer be lawful, then a man may carry his prayers in his pocket; buy them at the Book-binders shops, &c. and doth not this Reason disallow all penned and printed forms as well as ours?