A80626:138
A modest and clear answer to Mr. Ball's discourse of set forms of prayer.…A modest and cleer ansvver to Mr. Ball's discourse of set formes of prayer.…
A modest and clear answer to Mr. Ball's discourse of set forms of prayer. Written by the reverend and learned John Cotton, B.D. and teacher of the Church of Christ at Boston in New-England. Published for the benefit of those who desire satisfaction in that pointA modest and cleer ansvver to Mr. Ball's discourse of set formes of prayer. Written by the reverend and learned John Cotton, B.D. and teacher of the Church of Christ at Boston in New-England. Published for the benefit of those who desire satisfaction in that point
London: printed for H. Overton, 1642
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But to speak to the grounds of such a censure, though it were granted that the question is not of this or that form of Prayer in particular, yet is of a set form devised by men, and prescribed to be read out of a book for an ordinary Prayer; yea, I might add further, that the occasion of the Question in hand, springeth from an offence taken at some brethren (as appeareth by the letters sent to us about this matter, by sundry Reverend godly brethren, and subscribed amongst others, by your own name) for their not joining with others to worship God in a common stinted Liturgy, known to be devised by men, and prescribed to be read for the public Prayers of all the Churches in the Country; howsoever therefore the question be reduced by your Discourses ab Hypothesi, ad Thesin (& by lawful rules of dispute so may be) yet it is against the rule [Greek or Hebrew], so to palliate the matter, as to draw the question above the kind, and occasion of the question, you may upon occasion of one prescript form of Prayer devised by men, put the question of any prescript form of Prayer devised by men; but it is an utter changing and forsaking of the cause to put off the question in hand to forms of Prayer devised and prescribed by God; what though some that have spoken ⟨p. 47⟩or written in this cause, have waved some forms of Prayer devised by God himself; and have used some arguments, that grasp at more than they can hold?
But to speak to the grounds of such a censure, though it were granted that the question is not of this or that form of Prayer in particular, yet is of a set form devised by men, and prescribed to be read out of a book for an ordinary Prayer; yea, I might adde further, that the occasion of the Question in hand, springeth from an offence taken at some brethren (as appeareth by the letters sent to us about this matter, by sundry Reverend godly brethren, and subscribed amongst others, by your own name) for their not joyning with others to worship God in a common stinted Liturgy, known to be devised by men, and prescribed to be read for the publique Prayers of all the Churches in the Countrey; howsoever therefore the question be reduced by your Discourses ab Hypothesi, ad Thesin (& by lawfull rules of dispute so may be) yet it is against the rule 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, so to palliate the matter, as to draw the question above the kind, and occasion of the question, you may upon occasion of one prescript form of Prayer devised by men, put the question of any prescript form of Prayer devised by men; but it is an utter changing and forsaking of the cause to put off the question in hand to forms of Prayer devised and prescribed by God; what though some that have spoken