Answ. 2. Many a good Minister that is able to express the necessities of the people, or the doctrine of salvation, in a form of words devised and studied by himself: is not able so to dictate and compose a Psalm to be sung by the people each several occasion, no, though he should meditate and study hard for it: Poetry is not every good Scholars faculty; nor the ⟨p. 57⟩penning of holy Psalms the skill of every good Minister: nor is it required that it should. For seeing the Holy Ghost hath already dictated and composed to our hands divers forms of Psalms for all occasions, it would be superfluous for Ministers to take up their meditations and studies, about the inventing other forms, though they had gifts fit for it: and therefore if such as have the skill to pen Psalms, do nevertheless sing the forms of Psalms set and composed by David, and other Prophets: as they cannot be said, therein to make use of the inventions of men, but of Gods institutions; so neither can they be said to sin upon the other respect, which you mention, because they use an help to them not necessary; whereas others that want their skill, do lawfully use Davids Psalms, because such an help to them, is not arbitrary, but necessary: no, no, we do not approve of that distinction between arbitrary and necessary, in that sense, to that purpose; in that sense I say, for I here see you work upon an equivocation in this word necessary; For there is a double necessity spoken of in this case: a set form of worship may be said to be necessary, either through sinful defects in men, who should be able, but are not, to conceive a form of worship of themselves, or else through the nature and condition of the worship it self, which cannot be performed, but in a set form, whatsoever the gifts of men be; in this latter sense, not in the former, is the singing of Psalms in a set form necessary; for unless a Psalm be expressed in a set form of words, and so set before ⟨p. 58⟩the people, all the people cannot join in voice (as well as heart) singing and praising God together in the same words; we admit of no necessity of any set forms of prayer (or other worship) in the former sense: as concerning such men unfit to be Ministers of the Gospel as want gifts to conceive a prayer according to the present occasion;
Answ. 2. Many a good Minister that is able to expresse the necessities of the people, or the doctrine of salvation, in a form of words devised and studied by himself: is not able so to dictate and compose a Psalm to be sung by the people each several occasion, no, though he should meditate and study hard for it: Poetry is not every good Scholars faculty; nor the ⟨p. 57⟩penning of holy Psalms the skill of every good Minister: nor is it required that it should. For seeing the Holy Ghost hath already dictated and composed to our hands divers forms of Psalms for all occasions, it would be superfluous for Ministers to take up their meditations and studies, about the inventing other forms, though they had gifts fit for it: and therefore if such as have the skill to pen Psalms, do nevertheless sing the forms of Psalms set and composed by David, and other Prophets: as they cannot be said, therein to make use of the inventions of men, but of Gods institutions; so neither can they be said to sin upon the other respect, which you mention, because they use an help to them not necessary; whereas others that want their skill, do lawfully use Davids Psalms, because such an help to them, is not arbitrary, but necessary: no, no, we do not approve of that distinction between arbitrary and necessary, in that sense, to that purpose; in that sense I say, for I here see you work upon an equivocation in this word necessary; For there is a double necessity spoken of in this case: a set form of worship may be said to be necessary, either through sinfull defects in men, who should be able, but are not, to conceive a form of worship of themselves, or else through the nature and condition of the worship it selfe, which cannot be performed, but in a set form, whatsoever the gifts of men be; in this latter sense, not in the former, is the singing of Psalms in a set form necessary; for unlesse a Psalm be expressed in a set form of words, and so set before ⟨p. 58⟩the people, all the people cannot joyn in voyce (as well as heart) singing and praising God together in the same words; we admit of no necessity of any set forms of prayer (or other worship) in the former sense: as concerning such men unfit to be Ministers of the Gospel as want gifts to conceive a prayer according to the present occasion;