A80626:215
A modest and clear answer to Mr. Ball's discourse of set forms of prayer.…A modest and cleer ansvver to Mr. Ball's discourse of set formes of prayer.…
A modest and clear answer to Mr. Ball's discourse of set forms of prayer. Written by the reverend and learned John Cotton, B.D. and teacher of the Church of Christ at Boston in New-England. Published for the benefit of those who desire satisfaction in that pointA modest and cleer ansvver to Mr. Ball's discourse of set formes of prayer. Written by the reverend and learned John Cotton, B.D. and teacher of the Church of Christ at Boston in New-England. Published for the benefit of those who desire satisfaction in that point
London: printed for H. Overton, 1642
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Disc. Be that all the Churches may err in this, yet I hope no moderate man can censure them of obstinacy, as men not willing to consent to the truth showed and manifested; how then cometh it to pass, that none of them hitherto have subscribed to this opinion, and to the practice of our brethren of the Separation? The true Churches of God cannot err fundamentally, nor obstinately against knowledge; but how can they be freed from one of these, let the opposites themselves judge.
Disc. Be that all the Churches may erre in this, yet I hope no moderate man can censure them of obstinacy, as men not willing to consent to the truth shewed and manifested; how then cometh it to passe, that none of them hitherto have subscribed to this opinion, and to the practice of our brethren of the Separation? The true Churches of God cannot erre fundamentally, nor obstinately against knowledge; but how can they be freed from one of these, let the opposites themselves judge.
Answ. Though we do not believe (as you do) that the true Churches of Christ cannot err fundamentally, but do conceive for a time they may (as the Church of Israel in the golden Calf, and afterwards more dangerously in the crucifying of Christ, and many Christian Churches almost all, in that time, when Hierome complaineth the whole world was become an Arian) yet we do not look at the reading of devised prescript forms, as a fundamental error: howbeit any error or sin persisted in against light, will in time argue an unsound and corrupt heart in the bottom. And although we dare not excuse true Churches (as you do) from possibility of obstinacy, at least in some degree (for we see Moses and the Prophets often taxing the Church of Israel of rebellion and obstinacy, Deut. 31.27. Jer. 22.21. Ezek. 3.7.) yet we dare not think that the Churches of Christ do sin of obstinacy (especially of reigning obstinacy) in this case; For many of them never saw the grounds, as have born witness against set and prescript read forms of Prayer; and those that have seen their grounds, have not been convinced of the solidity of them; and therefore may not be charged with obstinacy, till after they have been convict of sin herein, and yet persist herein against light of conscience, which God forbid.