5. I had almost said, It is as great a fault to keep out visible repenting believers willing to subject to all ordinances, as it is to tolerate wicked persons in a Church. If the Presbyterial brethren are guilty of the latter, the Congregational are guilty of the former. I think it as great a fault to sin against the lenity of Christ, as against the severity of Christ. It is true, these wicked ones are a dishonour to Christ, leaven to the lump, [but yet suspended from the Lord's Supper] and they have not that means applied which might help to their souls salvation; but it is ⟨p. 42⟩that which these Ministers would gladly reach if they could, they allege the words of the Apostle, their authority is for edification, not destruction. On the other side, to keep out those who visibly appear like Christians, when men have power to take in, is to hinder these from being leavened with true grace, a great offence to the godly, discouragement of souls, and Magisterially to set up Rules which the Lord never appointed. Who blame Bishops for setting up their posts by God's posts? I know the word visible Believer is a contentious word, but I understand one plainly thus; Here is one that hath a competent knowledge of those grounds which are essential to salvation, and believes them. His estate by nature he understandeth, and professeth he believeth in the Lord Jesus for life and salvation; his conversation doth not confute his profession; worships God in his family, and subjects to all Christ's Ordinances; [for the private conferences of Christians and private fastings, which sometimes they have, though this were desirable to have them frequent them, yet these [in such a manner] being free-will offerings, I dare not tie up men to these, or else debar them] if he hath been scandalous, he declareth his repentance, cordially so far as charity can judge, and proves it by some time, would the Apostles have debarred such a person from the Church? but [I speak what I know] persons who go thus far, and further, cannot yet be admitted to Church-fellowship.
5. I had almost said, It is as great a fault to keep out visible repenting believers willing to subject to all ordinances, as it is to tolerate wicked persons in a Church. If the Presbyterial brethren are guilty of the latter, the Congregational are guilty of the former. I think it as great a faultto sin against the lenity of Christ, as against the severity of Christ. It is true, these wicked ones are a dishonour to Christ, leaven to the lump, [but yet suspended from the Lord's Supper] and they have not that means applied which might help to their souls salvation; but it is ⟨p. 42⟩that which these Ministers would gladly reach if they could, they alledge the words of the Apostle, their authority is for edification, not destruction. On the other side, to keep out those who visibly appear like Christians, when men have power to take in, is to hinder these from being levened with true grace, a great offence to the godly, discouragement of souls, and Magisterially to set up Rules which the Lord never appointed. Who blame Bishops for setting up their posts by God's posts? I know the word visible Believer is a contentious word, but I understand one plainly thus; Here is one that hath a competent knowledg of those grounds which are essential to salvation, and believes them. His estate by nature he understandeth, and professeth he believeth in the Lord Jesus for life and salvation; his conversation doth not confute his profession; worships God in his family, and subjects to all Christ's Ordinances; [for the private conferences of Christians and private fastings, which sometimes they have, though this were desireable to have them frequent them, yet these [in such a manner] being free-will offerings, I dare not tie up men to these, or else debar them] if he hath been scandalous, he declareth his repentance, cordially so far as charity can judge, and proves it by some time, would the Apostles have debarred such a person from the Church? but [I speak what I know] persons who go thus far, and further, cannot yet be admitted to Church-fellowship.