A85314:49
Separation examined
Separation examined: or, a treatise wherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not only unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the work of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.Separation examined: or, a treatise vvherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not onely unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the worke of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.
London: printed by R.I. for Stephen Bowtell, 1652
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Here are the essential causes of a Church; Ergo, here is a Church.
Here are the essentiall causes of a Church; Ergo, here is a Church.
First, here is the material cause, Visible Saints, the Ministers also, as visible Saints, help make up the matter; but as they are Ministers they make the Churches Organical (which is more.)
First, here is the materiall cause, Visible Saints, the Ministers also, as visible Saints, help make up the matter; but as they are Ministers they make the Churches Organicall (which is more.)
2 Here is the formal cause, their consenting to worship God, &c. he that yields the essential causes, and yet denies the effect, hath lost his reason.
2 Here is the formall cause, their consenting to worship God, &c. he that yeelds the essentiall causes, and yet denies the effect, hath lost his reason.
A Church, is any company of Saints in body, to set up what Ordinances of God they know; This is a true Church, and here God dwells, 1saith Mr. Burroughs.
A Church, is any company of Saints in body, to set up what Ordinances of God they know; This is a true Church, and here God dwels, 1saith Mr. Burroughs.
- 1In Hos. 8.1.
He speaks of a Church, as it is a Homogeneall body, but I go further; the Separatists indeed will catch hold of his definition, as Cyprian saith, the Schismatics in his time did of that text, in Matth. 18.20. to which eh answered very well, De unita Eccles. and hence they will conclude, we are Saints in body; ergo we are true Churches.
He speakes of a Church, as it is a Homogeneall body, but I goe further; the Separatists indeed will catch hold of his definition, as Cyprian saith, the Schismaticks in his time did of that text, in Matth. 18.20. to which eh answered very well, De unita Eccles. and hence they will conclude, we are Saints in body; ergo we are true Churches.
But I pray, are there not visible Saints also in the Churches, from which you irregularly (as I shall prove after) did separate? Are they not as good as your selves? Did not you attain to that visibility of Saint-ship, which you have, while you were in those Churches? Do you set up the Ordinances of God so far as you know (or may know, if error doth not hinder) as they do from whom you have separated? Nay, you cannot ⟨p. 3⟩do it, for you neither have men fit for Office, nor will you endure to come under Officers; and therefore if you look into the ninth verse of the same Chapter, 1you shall find Mr. Burroughs saying, That those, who love to live without Ordinances, from under the government of Christ, are those that love to live in the Wilderness. His words may be applied to many of these Separatists, who call for separation from the word, as well as to those who are in the world. But to my Argument.
But I pray, are there not visible Saints also in the Churches, from which you irregularly (as I shall prove after) did separate? Are they not as good as your selves? Did not you attain to that visibility of Saint-ship, which you have, while you were in those Churches? Doe you set up the Ordinances of God so farre as you know (or may know, if errour doth not hinder) as they doe from whom you have separated? Nay, you cannot ⟨p. 3⟩doe it, for you neither have men fit for Office, nor will you endure to come under Officers; and therefore if you looke into the ninth verse of the same Chapter, 1you shall finde Mr. Burroughs saying, That those, who love to live without Ordinances, from under the government of Christ, are those that love to live in the Wildernesse. His words may be applyed to many of these Separatists, who call for separation from the word, as well as to those who are in the world. But to my Argument.
- 1Faciunt faves vespae, faciunt Ecclesias Marciovitae. Tertul.Faciunt faves vespae, faciunt Ecclesias Marciouitae. Tertul.
All the quarrel will be about the Ministers, 1and the consenting together, &c. as for Mr. Burroughs phrase, there being in Body, this they like well, but so are not those visible Saints I mention, say they. But to take away that Cavil, and so to return to the Ministers, you may know what Mr. B. means by being in body, by showing what makes a Church Covenant; saith he, I know nothing more is required, but to manifest their assent, to join with that Body, to set up all the Ordinances of Christ, so far as they know. And do not those visible Saints actually manifest their assent by their continual attendance upon their Officers in all the Ordinances of God, and maintaining their Officers to that intent, that they may have the Ordinances of Christ set up amongst them? Shall the want of an Adjunct null the Church, when as they do the very thing, which they should express? Put case you express your assent, and do not the things which you express your assent unto, are you therefore a Church, because of your expressing your assent? What then are those who do the things, though they do not express their assent in words, but in Acts? This is good, and sufficient to prove the essence, though both expression and doing is better, but of this more after.
All the quarrell will be about the Ministers, 1and the consenting together, &c. as for Mr. Burroughs phrase, there being in Body, this they like well, but so are not those visible Saints I mention, say they. But to take away that Cavill, and so to returne to the Ministers, you may know what Mr. B. meanes by being in body, by shewing what makes a Church Covenant; saith he, I know nothing more is required, but to manifest their assent, to joyne with that Body, to set up all the Ordinances of Christ, so farre as they know. And doe not those visible Saints actually manifest their assent by their continuall attendance upon their Officers in all the Ordinances of God, and maintaining their Officers to that intent, that they may have the Ordinances of Christ set up amongst them? Shall the want of an Adjunct null the Church, when as they do the very thing, which they should expresse? Put case you expresse your assent, and doe not the things which you express your assent unto, are you therefore a Church, because of your expressing your assent? What then are those who doe the things, though they doe not expresse their assent in words, but in Acts? This is good, and sufficient to prove the essence, though both expression and doing is better, but of this more after.
- 1The Presbyterians speak the same Language, if the words in Body please you, the Correlatum of Ecclesiastical Power is a people embodied in a Church, or a Spiritual corporation, Gillesp. Aar. rod. 191. Iren. p. 102.The Presbyterians speake the same Language, if the words in Body please you, the Correlatum of Ecclesiasticall Power is a people embodied in a Church, or a Spirituall corporation, Gillesp. Aar. rod. 191. Iren. p. 102.
But the Ministers are those who spoil all; there are those who cannot deny there are Ordinances, but there are none to administer them; and this was the reason, which one of the chief Members of a Church in London (who did use to Prophesy (as they call it) in the absence or weariness of the Pastor) gave to an honest man, who was troubled, because he fell off from the Church, and exercising his gifts, and turned Seeker. I name not the man, nor the Church, but it is too true.
But the Ministers are those who spoyle all; there are those who cannot deny there are Ordinances, but there are none to administer them; and this was the reason, which one of the chiefe Members of a Church in London (who did use to Prophesie (as they call it) in the absence or wearinesse of the Pastor) gave to an honest man, who was troubled, because he fell off from the Church, and exercising his gifts, and turned Seeker. I name not the man, nor the Church, but it is too true.
Now suppose I could not prove the Ministers to be true Ministers, yet those visible Saints which I named before, and those whom you call Presbyterians, do meet together, confer, pray, and fast together; watch one over another, and so, if you will ⟨p. 4⟩consider them as Homogeneall Bodies, they are as good Churches as those Separatists, which have no Officers; therefore still there are true visible Churches in England, besides the Separatists, and so my Argument stands firm. But I will prove there are many true Ministers, even amongst those, whom you call Presbyterial Ministers, thus:
Now suppose I could not prove the Ministers to be true Ministers, yet those visible Saints which I named before, and those whom you call Presbyterians, doe meet together, conferre, pray, and fast together; watch one over another, and so, if you wil ⟨p. 4⟩consider them as Homogeneall Bodies, they are as good Churches as those Separatists, which have no Officers; therefore still there are true visible Churches in England, besides the Separatists, and so my Argument stands firme. But I will prove there are many true Ministers, even amongst those, whom you call Presbyterial Ministers, thus:
Where there are men sufficiently qualified by God, orderly (at least for substance) called to the Ministry, and do that work, which Christ appointed his Ministers to do, there are true Gospel-Ministers.
Where there are men sufficiently qualified by God, orderly (at least for substance) called to the Ministry, and doe that worke, which Christ appointed his Ministers to doe, there are true Gospel-Ministers.
But in many of the Churches of England, there are such men, ergo in many of the Churches of England there are true Gospel-Ministers.
I put in the word many, 1because I am sure I shall maintain my ground, for why should I have undertaken to prove that all the Ministers in England are true Gospel-ministers? and that in every Parochial Congregation in the blind corners of England, there are such visible Saints, as ought to be, in the constitution of a Church (enough I mean to make a Church) I should have had a hard task; but by this word many I include abundance both Churches and Ministers, besides our Congregational Ministers; now to my Argument.
I put in the word many, 1because I am sure I shal maintaine my ground, for why should I have undertaken to prove that all the Ministers in England are true Gospel-ministers? and that in every Parochiall Congregation in the blinde corners of England, there are such visible Saints, as ought to be, in the constitution of a Church (enough I meane to make a Church) I should have had a hard taske; but by this word many I include abundance both Churches and Ministers, besides our Congregationall Ministers; now to my Argument.
- 1I dare venture far here, but that I would save my self against those whom I oppose.I dare venture farre here, but that I would save my selfe against those whom I oppose.
The major cannot be denied, for all the causes are there set down, which are required to a true Minister.
The major cannot be denied, for all the causes are there set downe, which are required to a true Minister.
1 The efficient cause, God;
2 Material cause, a man sufficiently qualified, I mean according to Pauls phrase, 2 Tim. 2.2. [Greek or Hebrew], the same word with 2 Cor. 2 16 who is sufficient? two distinctions would clear this latter text, but I spare the reader.
2 Materiall cause, a man sufficiently qualified, I meane according to Pauls phrase, 2 Tim. 2.2. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, the same word with 2 Cor. 2 16 who is sufficient? two distinctions would cleare this latter text, but I spare the reader.
3 Formal cause, orderly called, I put in (at least for substance) because I would include many of the Presbyterial men.
3 Formall cause, orderly called, I put in (at least for substance) because I would include many of the Presbyteriall men.