A85314:64
Separation examined
Separation examined: or, a treatise wherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not only unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the work of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.Separation examined: or, a treatise vvherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not onely unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the worke of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.
London: printed by R.I. for Stephen Bowtell, 1652
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3 Formal cause, orderly called, I put in (at least for substance) because I would include many of the Presbyterial men.
3 Formall cause, orderly called, I put in (at least for substance) because I would include many of the Presbyteriall men.
4 Final cause, Ephes. 4.12. the end of the Ministry is, for the perfecting of the Saints, for the work of the Ministry, for the edifying of the Body of Christ. So that no rational man can deny the major.
4 Finall cause, Ephes. 4.12. the end of the Ministry is, for the perfecting of the Saints, for the worke of the Ministry, for the edifying of the Body of Christ. So that no rationall man can deny the major.
Now for the minor, that there are many such Ministers in England, we shall see;
1 For the efficient cause, there is no controversy there.
1 For the efficient cause, there is no controversie there.
2 For the material, that they are sufficiently qualified in that sense above mentioned, who can deny it? many, yea abundance ⟨p. 5⟩qualified with real grace, and experimental workings on their own hearts, besides their Ministerial qualifications, and these many others have, who it may be have not the former, as could be wished; but I hope, though some do whisper, yet they will not undertake to defend it, that there can be no true Minister, unless he have real Grace: I have heard some that have affirmed as much, but they are not such as dare undertake the Question. But as for Ministerial qualifications, I do believe the gifts of Ministers were never larger then now; since the Apostles days never were the truths of God more clearly laid open then now; God doth seem to give out such large measures in these days, as it were in opposition to this wild Generation, that when they are crying out, there are no Ministers, God confutes them, by pouring out more of his Spirit in point of Ministerial abilities upon them, then before; indeed where other holy men have gone before in such Parishes, and places thereabouts, we find not that preaching works now, as it did when it came new to the places, yet I say the gifts of Ministers now are as strong, as they were before; but this is one of the Ministers heavy burdens in our days, their Trading is dead.
2 For the materiall, that they are sufficiently qualified in that sence above mentioned, who can deny it? many, yea abundance ⟨p. 5⟩qualified with reall grace, and experimentall workings on their owne hearts, besides their Ministeriall qualifications, and these many others have, who it may be have not the former, as could be wished; but I hope, though some doe whisper, yet they will not undertake to defend it, that there can be no true Minister, unlesse he have reall Grace: I have heard some that have affirmed as much, but they are not such as dare undertake the Question. But as for Ministeriall qualifications, I doe beleeve the gifts of Ministers were never larger then now; since the Apostles dayes never were the truths of God more clearly layed open then now; God doth seeme to give out such large measures in these dayes, as it were in opposition to this wild Generation, that when they are crying out, there are no Ministers, God confutes them, by pouring out more of his Spirit in point of Ministeriall abilities upon them, then before; indeed where other holy men have gone before in such Parishes, and places thereabouts, we finde not that preaching workes now, as it did when it came new to the places, yet I say the gifts of Ministers now are as strong, as they were before; but this is one of the Ministers heavie burdens in our dayes, their Trading is dead.
Thirdly, formal cause: Our Ministers, abundance of them are orderly called (for substance:) there are but two things that I know of to make up this call, Election and Ordination: For election, many, if not all, of the godly Ministers are elected by the people, some by the whole Parish, and others by the best in the Parishes. But you say the Patron presents: It is true, but not so, as to bring one in against the consent of the people: Verily for Patrons to present an unworthy Minister, and bring him in against the consent, especially of the godly, and orthodox Christians, it is an act of cruel Tyranny, and worthy of a Petition to the Parliament to get such an horrible abuse removed; but you have a way now to help your selves against scandalous Ministers by the Civill-power, and should have had it by Church-power, if once Discipline were set up.
Thirdly, formall cause: Our Ministers, abundance of them are orderly called (for substance:) there are but two things that I know of to make up this call, Election and Ordination: For election, many, if not all, of the godly Ministers are elected by the people, some by the whole Parish, and others by the best in the Parishes. But you say the Patron presents: It is true, but not so, as to bring one in against the consent of the people: Verily for Patrons to present an unworthy Minister, and bring him in against the consent, especially of the godly, and orthodox Christians, it is an act of cruell Tyranny, and worthy of a Petition to the Parliament to get such an horrible abuse removed; but you have a way now to helpe your selves against scandalous Ministers by the Civill-power, and should have had it by Church-power, if once Discipline were set up.
But if the Minister be not an unworthy man, though the Patron did present, as in former times, and he came in without the consent of the people at the first, but had it afterwards; this makes his election good: Hear what the New England Ministers say to this point: Yet sometimes the peoples acceptance and approbation afterward ⟨p. 6⟩may supply the want of election at the first, 1as Jacobs after consent and acceptance of Leah, made her to be his wife, though he chose her not at the first; and by this we hold the calling of many Ministers in England may be excused, who at first came into their places without the consent of the people. So Dr. Ames.
- 1Ans. to the 32. Quest. p. 69. V. Ames Consc. l. 4. c. 25. q. 7.
But are all these Separatists so regular? I doubt not: I can give instance of a Weaver, who lived in a Town, where I had my abode for a little time; the Minister of the place was a very able man, regularly called, and inclining at that time to the Congregational way; yet this Weaver (I think that was his calling) separated from him, and the other Christians, and had his own society, to whom he did preach (as they said) but when the wind did settle in the Independent quarter; this Weaver had a mind to a Pulpit, but I hope then he will look to his orderly calling; he will not dare to venture but by the Gospel-way, that now we shall judge; his way of election was this, as an honest Christian of the same Town, and one of this mans friends told me, that Goodman B. an honest Carrier being a Sequestrator in the Town, he puts him in, and this is one part of his calling, as for Ordination that is a Toy: But is this regular? then let these Separatists for ever hold their tongues; I know not, but if a Sequestrator may put a Weaver (let him be a godly and a pretty man, as some say he is, I love not to judge other folks godliness, I have enough to do at home) into a Parish, when as the people call him not, then may a Patron put in able and godly Divines into their Parishes with the peoples consent first or last: as the noble Earle of Warwick, I believe hath helped many Parishes to as able godly Divines, as any one Sequestrator hath done. I could give the Reader instances of others, but so much I perceive by these kind of men, that I little regard what they say, for if there lye any matter of advantage in their way, they will stretch their principles, as far as they please.
But are all these Separatists so regular? I doubt not: I can give instance of a Weaver, who lived in a Towne, where I had my abode for a little time; the Minister of the place was a very able man, regularly called, and inclining at that time to the Congregationall way; yet this Weaver (I thinke that was his calling) separated from him, and the other Christians, and had his owne society, to whom he did preach (as they said) but when the winde did settle in the Independent quarter; this Weaver had a minde to a Pulpit, but I hope then he will looke to his orderly calling; he will not dare to venture but by the Gospel-way, that now we shall judge; his way of election was this, as an honest Christian of the same Towne, and one of this mans friends told me, that Goodman B. an honest Carrier being a Sequestrator in the Towne, he puts him in, and this is one part of his calling, as for Ordination that is a Toy: But is this regular? then let these Separatists for ever hold their tongues; I know not, but if a Sequestrator may put a Weaver (let him be a godly and a pretty man, as some say he is, I love not to judge other folkes godlinesse, I have enough to doe at home) into a Parish, when as the people call him not, then may a Patron put in able and godly Divines into their Parishes with the peoples consent first or last: as the noble Earle of Warwick, I beleeve hath helped many Parishes to as able godly Divines, as any one Sequestrator hath done. I could give the Reader instances of others, but so much I perceive by these kinde of men, that I little regard what they say, for if there lye any matter of advantage in their way, they will stretch their principles, as far as they please.
As for their sufficient qualification, which should make the material cause of a Minister, we must not question them in our days: Paul indeed said, Who is sufficient for these things? our language is, Who is not sufficient for these things? much might here be said (I am privy to mine own insufficiency, and desire to bewail it) but let me propound one thing to these men, and see how they answer it. Amongst the opinions which Mrs. Hutchison had brought forth in New Eng. this was one, That there was no inherent ⟨p. 7⟩grace in a believer, no new creature, nothing but Jesus Christ, and he was the new creature; one of Mrs. Hutchison's followers, on a Lords day stood up in the Congregation, and would defend it against the learned and reverend Teacher, and told him the text was read so in the original, If any man be in Christ, the new creature, 2 Cor. •.17. [Greek or Hebrew], what can these men say to this that know not the Original, nor Grammar, both which a man must know to answer this: so if another should defend a heresy, and tell you the text is so in the Hebrew: for the Jesuits subtle and crabbed disputations, we must not mention them, these men are doubtless sufficient; not but that I could allow a solid, humble, experienced, orthodox, and well-gifted Christian, called regularly, and set apart to the work of the Ministry, with the neighbour-hood of some learned able Divine to have his recourse to, I say, I could allow such a one to preach in dark corners of the land. But when men will cry out of other Ministers for want of orderly calling, separate from them, and thus carry themselves, that the bones of their ambition stick out, and then through unfoundnesse in opinion, though no way able, though not regularly called, yet they will get into Livings and Pulpits, this is abominable.
As for their sufficient qualification, which should make the materiall cause of a Minister, we must not question them in our dayes: Paul indeed said, Who is sufficient for these things? our language is, Who is not sufficient for these things? much might here be said (I am privy to mine own insufficiency, and desire to bewail it) but let me propound one thing to these men, and see how they answer it. Amongst the opinions which Mrs. Hutchison had brought forth in New Eng. this was one, That there was no inherent ⟨p. 7⟩grace in a beleever, no new creature, nothing but Jesus Christ, and he was the new creature; one of Mrs. Hutchisons followers, on a Lords day stood up in the Congregation, and would defend it against the learned and reverend Teacher, and told him the text was read so in the original, If any man be in Christ, the new creature, 2 Cor. •.17. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, what can these men say to this that know not the Originall, nor Grammar, both which a man must know to answer this: so if another should defend a heresie, and tell you the text is so in the Hebrew: for the Jesuits subtle and crabbed disputations, we must not mention them, these men are doubtlesse sufficient; not but that I could allow a solid, humble, experienced, orthodox, and well-gifted Christian, called regularly, and set apart to the worke of the Ministry, with the neighbour-hood of some learned able Divine to have his recourse to, I say, I could allow such a one to preach in dark corners of the land. But when men will cry out of other Ministers for want of orderly calling, separate from them, and thus carry themselves, that the bones of their ambition sticke out, and then through unfoundnesse in opinion, though no way able, though not regularly called, yet they will get into Livings and Pulpits, this is abominable.
So much for Election, that part of their calling will hold; as for the other requisite, Ordination, to prove our Ministers have that also; (for the substance of it) here will lye the pinch of the controversy, therefore I reserve it for another place.
So much for Election, that part of their calling will hold; as for the other requisite, Ordination, to prove our Ministers have that also; (for the substance of it) here will lye the pinch of the controversie, therefore I reserve it for another place.
Fourthly, for the final cause, here also the Ministers will appear to be true Ministers; for conversion and edification, the Lord hath honoured the English Ministry with as much success, as any Nation under heaven; the Lord hath set seal to hundreds of our Ministers, in giving them some souls in conversion, and building up many, according as are their several gifts; and for a proof of it, let me appeal to your selves, who have thus separated from them: Cannot you say, that you have found God in their Ministry? I am sure your own words must witness against divers of you, if you deny it, for you have acknowledged, by them you were first awakened, and brought home: Now I beseech you consider what you do, you who are the soberest, and retain the savour of God in your hearts: If Christ shall say to you, Why do you deny these to be true Ministers? I own them to be such, I have qualified them with Ministerial and personal ⟨p. 8⟩gifts; I have sealed to their Ministry, by making them my instruments to bring home many, and to build up those, who were brought home: I have often humbled, awed, cheered, refreshed the hearts of my people by them, your own selves (who are mine) are witnesses of it, I found you out by them, &c. They had their call from the people, and though there were some circumstantial defects in their setting apart to the work, yet those they freely acknowledge, and I do as freely pardon, will not my presence with them make up that defect in your hearts, still to own them, and reverence them, as my Ministers, since I do?
Fourthly, for the finall cause, here also the Ministers will appeare to be true Ministers; for conversion and edification, the Lord hath honoured the English Ministry with as much successe, as any Nation under heaven; the Lord hath set seale to hundreds of our Ministers, in giving them some soules in conversion, and building up many, according as are their severall gifts; and for a proofe of it, let me appeale to your selves, who have thus separated from them: Cannot you say, that you have found God in their Ministry? I am sure your owne words must witnesse against divers of you, if you deny it, for you have acknowledged, by them you were first awakened, and brought home: Now I beseech you consider what you doe, you who are the soberest, and retaine the savour of God in your hearts: If Christ shall say to you, Why doe you deny these to be true Ministers? I owne them to be such, I have qualified them with Ministerial and personal ⟨p. 8⟩gifts; I have sealed to their Ministry, by making them my instruments to bring home many, and to build up those, who were brought home: I have often humbled, awed, cheared, refreshed the hearts of my people by them, your owne selves (who are mine) are witnesses of it, I found you out by them, &c. They had their call from the people, and though there were some circumstantiall defects in their setting apart to the worke, yet those they freely acknowledge, and I doe as freely pardon, will not my presence with them make up that defect in your hearts, still to owne them, and reverence them, as my Ministers, since I doe?
Now I say, what would you answer to the Lord Jesus? I doubt not, though many have their infirmities (as who have not many infirmities) yet Christ doth own them for his Ministers, and Paul, or the Apostles, if they now were alive, would not deny it.
Now I say, what would you answer to the Lord Jesus? I doubt not, though many have their infirmities (as who have not many infirmities) yet Christ doth owne them for his Ministers, and Paul, or the Apostles, if they now were alive, would not deny it.
Object. If you say, that indeed God did go along with the old Ministers, but not with these.
Object. If you say, that indeed God did goe along with the old Ministers, but not with these.
Answ. But the same argument you give against these Ministers from their Ordination, doth make as much against these old Ministers, as these now living, they were no true Ministers neither by your opinion.
2. We can say, that even with the labours of these Ministers doth Christ go along, though not so much as he did before, when the Gospel came first into places, for edification we find it, which is one end in that Ephes. 4.12. and I pray take heed that your scorning of them, be no occasion to hinder their work, for you must answer for it, what ever the Decrees of God be. So much for my first argument.
2. We can say, that even with the labours of these Ministers doth Christ goe along, though not so much as he did before, when the Gospel came first into places, for edification we finde it, which is one end in that Ephes. 4.12. and I pray take heed that your scorning of them, be no occasion to hinder their worke, for you must answer for it, what ever the Decrees of God be. So much for my first argument.
2. I would use a second argument to prove we have true Ministers, &c. And here I would propound one question to these men, who thus deny the Ministry: It is this, Were there ever any true Ministers and Churches (let me put in them also) since the Apostles days? I hope you will say yes: But I pray how long were there such Ministers and Churches? in which Century did there cease to be true Ministers, and true visible Churches? I suppose you will say, when Antichrist began (here now you would do us a good turn, if you could make it out clear to us when that was, that so we might know how long our miseries shall last) if so, then to be sure for the first three hundred years after Christ, which were times of persecution, yea, and divers years after, you must grant there were true Ministers. ⟨p. 9⟩Let us then compare our Ministers, and Churches with them; for our Ministers, many are godly, as well as those, all the Ministers then were not truly gracious I believe; nay by stories we can learn they were not. As for Ministerial gifts, those who have skill to compare the works, and Sermons of our Ministers now, with their works and Homilies, shall find that the Presbyterial Ministers are not behind them, but in opening the doctrines of Free-grace, Christ, promises, which are the glory of the Gospel, as also for discovering of Hypocrisy (without any dishonour to those Ancients,) I may say they do excel them.
2. I would use a second argument to prove we have true Ministers, &c. And here I would propound one question to these men, who thus deny the Ministry: It is this, Were there ever any true Ministers and Churches (let me put in them also) since the Apostles dayes? I hope you will say yes: But I pray how long were there such Ministers and Churches? in which Century did there cease to be true Ministers, and true visible Churches? I suppose you will say, when Antichrist began (here now you would doe us a good turne, if you could make it out cleare to us when that was, that so we might know how long our miseries shall last) if so, then to be sure for the first three hundred yeares after Christ, which were times of persecution, yea, and divers yeares after, you must grant there were true Ministers. ⟨p. 9⟩Let us then compare our Ministers, and Churches with them; for our Ministers, many are godly, as well as those, all the Ministers then were not truly gracious I beleeve; nay by stories we can learne they were not. As for Ministeriall gifts, those who have skill to compare the workes, and Sermons of our Ministers now, with their workes and Homilies, shall finde that the Presbyterial Ministers are not behinde them, but in opening the doctrines of Free-grace, Christ, promises, which are the glory of the Gospel, as also for discovering of Hypocrisie (without any dishonour to those Ancients,) I may say they do excell them.