A85827:189
A discourse apologeticalA discours apologetical
A discourse apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and loud lies in his Merlin or Pasquil for the year 1654. are clearly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fully refuted; and his malicious and murderous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidently evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatory of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. author [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.A discours apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and lowd lies in his Merlin or Pasqil for the yeer 1654. are cleerly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fullie refuted; and his malicious and murtherous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidentlie evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatorie of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. autor [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.
London: printed by R. Ibbitson for Thomas Newberry, 1654
Title page typeset from the transcription.
An Advertisement concerning two Allegations in Lilies Postscript.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In two things especially he is just of the same stamp and temper with his friend Lily, who hath good cause therefore to like him the better; And it was reported abroad that he had received money of Lily to write in defence of him against my former Vindication; which being told him by a friend of mine, occasionally meeting him in the street, he acknowledged that he had been indeed lately with Lily, who had spoken to him his pleasure of me, but that he was resolved not to write in defence of him, because he knew his practise to be condemned in divers Counsels, whose authority he regarded more then any private mans opinion. But howsoever behind Lilies back he give in his verdict thus against him, which peradventure he will not do to his face, yet in some things he and Lily so exactly resemble either other, that were their parentage uncertain, and were by conjecture to be gathered from their similitude of disposition and demeanour, they might well be ⟨p. 83⟩deemed, like Plautus his Menechmi, to be gemini germani, two twins of one birth, or at least, fratres uterini, both births of one belly. The one good quality, wherein they are so like either to other, is, that the manner of them both is rather to rail and revile, then by arguing and reasoning to refel and refute: The other is, their extreme malice and rage against the Presbyterian party, the Genevan Discipline, and Calvin by name; both which may easily appear of this latter (for of the other enough hath been said and showed already, both in this, and in a former Discourse) as well by that parcel of stuff, that his friend Lily here presents us with, as by other passages also abundantly, yea luxuriantly, in other his writings elsewhere.
In two things especiallie he is just of the same stamp and temper with his frend Lilie, who hath good cause therefore to like him the better; And it was reported abroad that he had received money of Lilie to write in defence of him against my former Vindication; which being told him by a frend of mine, occasionallie meeting him in the street, he acknowledged that he had been indeed lately with Lilie, who had spoken to him his pleasure of me, but that he was resolved not to write in defence of him, because he knew his practise to be condemned in divers Councels, whose autoritie he regarged more then anie privat mans opinion. But howsoever behind Lilies back he give in his verdict thus against him, which peradventure he wil not do to his face, yet in some things he and Lilie so exactlie resemble either other, that were their parentage uncertain, and were by conjecture to be gathered from their similitude of disposition and demeanure, they might well be