A discourse apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and loud lies in his Merlin or Pasquil for the year 1654. are clearly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fully refuted; and his malicious and murderous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidently evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatory of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. author [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.A discours apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and lowd lies in his Merlin or Pasqil for the yeer 1654. are cleerly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fullie refuted; and his malicious and murtherous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidentlie evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatorie of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. autor [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.
Thomas Gataker 1574–1654London: printed by R. Ibbitson for Thomas Newberry, 1654
[8], 104 p. · 46k words · Wing G319 · ESTC R202124
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To call a man Thief, or a woman Whore, I have heard some say, will bear no action at Law; but to say, You are a thief, and stole such a matter from such an one; or, You are a whore, and were taken in bed with such a man, will. And the reason hereof seems, because those general and indefinite terms are deemed ⟨p. 6⟩stomachful words only, whereas in the other there is a charge with particular matter of fact. Had this Railer therefore kept himself within this compass, and contented him with such general, base, and foul terms, I should never have troubled either my self with writing, or any other with reading these lines. For as for those particulars, that he snaps at, concerning some Authors that I quote, how sorry, poor, idle, frothy, frivolous, yea, and false, his exceptions and allegations are, will soon appear unto any, that shall be pleased to take so much pains, as to consult the Annotations and Vindication of them that are every where together abroad.
To call a man Theif, or a woman Whore, I have heard some say, wil bear no action at Law; but to say, You are a theif, and stole such a matter from such an one; or, You are a whore, and were taken in bed with such a man, wil. And the reason hereof seems, because those general and indefinite terms ar deemed ⟨p. 6⟩stomackful words onelie, whereas in the other there is a charge with particular matter of fact. Had this Railer therefore kept himself within this compass, and contented him with such general, base, and foul terms, I should never have troubled either my self with writing, or anie other with reading these lines. For as for those particulars, that he snaps at, concerning some Autors that I qote, how sorry, poor, idle, frothie, frivolous, yea, and fals, his exceptions and allegations ar, wil soon appear unto anie, that shal be pleased to take so much pains, as to consult the Annotations and Vindication of them that ar everie where together abroad.
. he saith, I prov by Strabo, Lucian, Pliny, and Cicero; whereas of Lucian I have not any one word there; the other three I cite jointly, only to show, That Astrologers were anciently termed Chaldeans; and Pliny apart, to show, What antiquity of observation the Heathen Diviners pretended for their superstitious divinations by the flight of fouls, and from the bowels of beasts; That in my Vindication I quote Lucian, a Scoffer: But to what purpose? To prov ought in controversy by him? No. But to show, That an Impostor in his times used the like shifts that Lily now doth, tho in some kind more wisely, and warily then he. But I quote also there, two Logger-headed Grammarians and Heathens. If his meaning be in sensu composito, that those two Grammarians were Heathens, it is false; they were both Christians, tho they lived in an obscure and corrupt age. But what do I cite them for? To show, that they were sounder, concurring therein with the learned of other, and better ages, in the notation of some words, and distinction of some terms, then some of Lilies Patrons, and Advocates; and the more shame then for them, professing much learning, and charging others with ignorance, to come short in such petty matters of such Logger-headed Grammarians, as their Client saith they were. Or, if he mean in sensu diviso, that I quote other Authors, that are pure Heathens (as elsewhere he saith of Strabo and Cicero) against Astrology. I might demand of him, Whether Strabo and Cicero are more pure Heathen, or any that I quote against Astrology, then Thales and Solon, whom his Advocate quotes for it; or whether Hermes, Proclus, Plotinus, Ptolemy, Albumazar,
⟨p. 7⟩
Hali Rodoan, Baranzanus, &c. be any better then such, whom he quotes for his practise, and on whose authority, next to his good Angels, of whom by his silence, he now seems ashamed, he principally rests and relies. I quote Heathen Authors indeed; but to what purpose? To show, that the wiser sort even among the Heathen discovered the vanity and folly of this pretended skill: As Clemens, Augustine, and others of the Ancients, produce the like, to show, that the wiser sort of them disavowed the multiplicity of their counterfeit Deities. Yea, but I play the fool in producing the judgment of men disaffected to the point in question.
For example, All I write on Jer. 10. 2. he saith, I prov by Strabo, Lucian, Plinie, and Cicero; whereas of Lucian I have not anie one word there; the other three I cite joyntlie, onelie to shew, That Astrologers were ancientlie termed Chaldeans; and Plinie apart, to shew, What antiqitie of observation the Heathen Diviners pretended for their superstitious divinations by the flight of fouls, and from the bowels of beasts; That in my Vindication I qote Lucian, a Scoffer: But to what purpose? To prov ought in controversie by him? No. But to shew, That an Impostor in his times used the like shifts that Lilie now doth, tho in some kind more wiselie, and warilie then he. But I qote also there, two Logger-headed Grammarians and Heathens. If his meaning be in sensu composito, that those two Grammarians were Heathens, it is fals; they were both Christians, tho they lived in an obscure and corrupt age. But what do I cite them for? To shew, that they were sounder, coneurring therein with the learned of other, and better ages, in the notation of some words, and distinction of some terms, then some of Lilies Patrons, and Advocates; and the more shame then for them, professing much learning, and charging others with ignorance, to come short in such pettie matters of such Logger-headed Grammarians, as their Client saith they were. Or, if he mean in sensu diviso, that I qote other Autors, that ar pure Heathens (as elswhere he saith of Strabo and Cicero) against Astrologie. I might demand of him, Whether Strabo and Cicero ar more pure Heathen, or anie that I qote against Astrologie, then Thales and Solon, whom his Advocate qotes for it; or whether Hermes, Proclus, Plotinus, Ptolomie, Albumazar, ⟨p. 7⟩Hali Rodoan, Baranzanus, &c. be anie better then such, whom he qotes for his practise, and on whose autoritie, next to his good Angels, of whom by his silence, he now seems ashamed, he principallie rests and relies. I qote Heathen Autors indeed; but to what purpose? To shew, that the wiser sort even among the Heathen discovered the vanitie and follie of this pretended skil: As Clemens, Augustine, and others of the Ancients, produce the like, to shew, that the wiser sort of them disavowed the multiplicitie of their counterfeit Deities. Yea, but I play the fool in producing the judgment of men disaffected to the point in qestion.
Not, I hope, when I produce them to prov, that they are not all such silly Ignoramuses, as Lily and his Advocate would bear the world in hand, that tax his trade, and that it is not out of mere ignorance that they disallow and condemn it; unless he can prov, that they are all also such Logger-heads, as he saith those two were.
Not, I hope, when I produce them to prov, that they ar not all such sillie Ignoramusses, as Lilie and his Advocate would bear the world in hand, that tax his trade, and that it is not out of meer ignorance that they disallow and condemn it; unless he can prov, that they ar all also such Logger-heads, as he saith those two were.
But in all these particulars thus specified, and here carped at, there is nothing of much moment, nor ought that contains in it any matter of scandal. One or two other things there are, wherewith albeit they no way at all concern, either my Charge against him, or his Defence of his own Cause, wherein he is as mute as a fish; yet he strives what he can, to asperse my good name, endeavouring to fasten some particulars upon me, that may tend unto scandal; which I suppose therefore, it may concern me to take notice of, and to clear my self from his false imputations: that which divers of my Friends also have incited me to do.
But in all these particulars thus specified, and here carped at, there is nothing of much moment, nor ought that contains in it anie matter of scandal. One or two other things there are, wherewith albeit they no way at all concern, either my Charge against him, or his Defence of his own Cause, wherein he is as mute as a fish; yet he strives what he can, to asperse my good name, endeavoring to fasten some particulars upon me, that may tend unto scandal; which I suppose therefore, it may concern me to take notice of, and to clear my self from his fals imputations: that which divers of my Friends also have incited me to do.
One of the wisest of mere men, that ever was since the fall, telleth us, [Greek or Hebrew] That a good name is a matter 1of more worth, then a precious ointment; (which were said to be [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew], very highly prized in those parts) 2and more to be esteemed of then riches and much treasure. And a Heathen man therefore saith, Famae & fidei damna majora sunt qod q• aestimari possunt; That the wrongs a man receives in his good name and credit, are greater damages then can be valued. We have a common saying among us, That for a man to have a bad name, it is as good, or bad rather, as to be half hanged. But the Greek Orator goes further then so, and saith, [Greek or Hebrew] ⟨p. 8⟩3[Greek or Hebrew], That it were not a greater penalty for a man to be stoned to death or burnt quick, then justly and deservedly, to live in disgrace: And the Greek Father, [Greek or Hebrew], 4That death it self is more tolerable then disgrace: Yea, the Apostle Paul himself professeth to be of the […] ▪5[Greek or Hebrew], that it were better for him to die, that any man should take his life, rather then his glorying away from him. And he admonisheth all Christian men to be very chary in this kind, following [Greek or Hebrew], such things as are of good 6report; providing [Greek or Hebrew] not good only, but goodly, as the word properly signifies; honest things, as we render it, not in the sight of God only, but in the sight of men also; Caventes & nobis à peccato, & ill is à scandalo, as Bernard speaks; being careful to shun, as the offending of God by any carriage▪7simply evil, so of giving occasion of offence to man, by any course that may prov scandalous, [Greek or Hebrew], saith Clemens of Alexandria, That they may not only 8be faithful in regard of God, but of credit also in regard of men. Hence it is, that Julian saith, No• is necessaria est vita nostra, aliis fama nostra; that Our good life is needful for our selves, our good name for others, as well as our selves: And Austine, Opus est bona famâ apud homines, bona conscientiâ apud Deum. Need have we as well of a good report with men, 9as of a good conscience towards God. According to that of the Apostle concerning himself, that it was his constant endeavour and 10exercise to keep [Greek or Hebrew] a conscience free from offence;
One of the wisest of meer men, that ever was since the fall, telleth us, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 That a good name is a matter 1of more worth, then a pretious ointment; (which were said to be 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, very highly prized in those parts) 2and more to be esteemed of then riches and much treasure. And a Heathen man therefore saith, Famae & fidei damna majora sunt qod q• aestimari possunt; That the wrongs a man receives in his good name and credit, ar greater damages then can be valued. We have a common saying among us, That for a man to have a bad name, it is as good, or bad rather, as to be half hanged. But the Greek Orator goes further then so, and saith, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉⟨p. 8⟩3〈non-Latin alphabet〉, That it were not a greater penalty for a man to be stoned to death or burnt qick, then justlie and deservedlie, to live in disgrace: And the Greek Father, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, 4That death it self is more tolerable then disgrace: Yea, the Apostle Paul himself professeth to be of the 〈…〉▪5〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that it were better for him to die, that anie man should take his life, rather then his glorying away from him. And he admonisheth all Christian men to be very charie in this kind, folowing 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, such things as ar of good 6report; providing 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 not good onelie, but goodlie, as the word properlie signifies; honest things, as we render it, not in the sight of God onelie, but in the sight of men also; Caventes & nobis à peccato, & ill is à scandalo, as Bernard speaks; being careful to shun, as the offending of God by anie cariage
that is, from giving occasion thereof unto either, both towards God and men; and therefore, Qi conscientiae fidens famam 1negligit, crudelis est. For a man, saith he, relying upon his conscience, to be retchless and regardless of his good name, it is a kind of cruelty both to others, and to himself.
that is, from giving occasion thereof unto either, both towards God and men; and therefore, Qi conscientiae fidens famam 1negligit, crudelis est. For a man, saith he, relying upon his conscience, to be retchless and regardless of his good name, it is a kind of crueltie both to others, and to himself.
In which consideration, that renowned Roman Emperor Mark Antonine, albeit with the Stoic's he reckoned, [Greek or Hebrew] 1[Greek or Hebrew], fame and report, good or bad, in rebus mediis; among those things that were neither simply good, nor evil of themselves; and doth therefore admonish men to rest principally (as the Apostle also professeth that he did) on the inward testimony of their 2own conscience; contenting themselves with that, where the other cannot be had; yea, adviseth them to be content to sustain reproach ⟨p. 9⟩and infamy for the keeping of a good conscience, and to be willing to part with the one for the retaining of the other; doing that that they know to be their duty, [Greek or Hebrew], tho it may 3be deemed infamous, or [Greek or Hebrew], tho they shall be defamed for the doing of it, as Pythagoras before him. That which not our Apostle only resolves with himself, to steer 4his course according to his card and compass, [Greek or Hebrew], passing as well, and as willingly, through good report, and evil report; tho by some reputed [Greek or Hebrew], as an impostor, and a counterfeit, when he was in truth nothing less: 5But Seneca also, Ad honestum consilium per mediam infamiam tendam: I will break, saith he, through the midst of infamy to the accomplishment of an honest act; adding withal, That no man in his judgment sets an higher rate on virtue and well doing, then he, Qi boni viri famam perdidit, ne conscientiam perd• ret; 6Who hazards the loss of being reputed a good man, that he might not loose the reality, and conscientiousness of it. And elsewhere inciting his friend to the like resolution, he tells him. Saepe justus esse debebis cum infamiâ; & tunc, si sapis, mala 7opinio sic parta delectabit: That if he will do as he should do, he must oft-times do that which is just and upright, tho he shall be ill thought of▪ or ill spoken of for it; (that which Antisthenes, 8as some, Alexander, as others, used to say, [Greek or Hebrew], that it was the lot of Kings to hear ill, when they did well;) and that, if he were so wise as he should be, an evil report, or evil repute so gotten, should be so far from daunting or disturbing him, that it ought rather to delight him;
In which consideration, that renowned Roman Emperor Mark Antonine, albeit with the Stoick's he reckoned, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉1〈non-Latin alphabet〉, fame and report, good or bad, in rebus mediis; among those things that were neither simply good, nor evil of themselvs; and doth therefore admonish men to rest principallie (as the Apostle also professeth that he did) on the inward testimonie of their 2own conscience; contenting themselves with that, where the other cannot be had; yea, adviseth them to be content to sustain reproach ⟨p. 9⟩and infamie for the keeping of a good conscience, and to be willing to part with the one for the retaining of the other; doing that that they know to be their dutie, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, tho it may 3be deemed infamous, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, tho they shall be defamed for the doing of it, as Pythagoras before him. That which not our Apostle onelie resolvs with himself, to steer 4his cours according to his card and compass, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, passing as wel, and as willinglie, through good report, and evil report; tho by some repu•ed 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as an imposter, and a counterfeit, when he was in truth nothing less: 5But Seneca also, Ad honestum consilium per mediam infamiam tendam: I wil break, saith he, through the midst of infamie to the accomplishment of an honest act; adding withal, That no man in his judgment sets an higher rate on virtu and wel doing, then he, Qi boni viri famam perdidit, ne conscientiam perd• ret; 6Who hazards the loss of being reputed a good man, that he might not loose the realitie, and conscientiousness of it. And elswhere inciting his friend to the like resolution, he tells him. Saepe justus esse debebis cum infamiâ; & tunc, si sapis, mala
1M. Anton. l. 2. sect. 11.
2Id. l. 4. sect. 12. & l. 6. sect. 2. 22. 1 Cor. 4 3, 4.
as it is said of those two Apostles, Peter and John, after they had been baited 1and beaten in the consistory, they went away, [Greek or Hebrew], rejoicing, that they had been graced so 2much as to be disgraced for Christ; and of Moses, that he reckoned, [Greek or Hebrew] the sustaining of reproach for Christ, 3a greater honour then all the treasures or royalties of Egypt could afford.
as it is said of those two Apostles, Peter and John, after they had been baited 1and beaten in the consistory, they went away, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, rejoycing, that they had been graced so 2much as to be disgraced for Christ; and of Moses, that he reckoned, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the sustaining of reproach for Christ, 3a greater honor then all the treasures or royalties of Egypt could afford.
1Acts •5. 41.
2[Greek or Hebrew] •lega•s. Casaub.〈non-Latin alphabet〉•lega•s. Casaub.
Yet notwithstanding all this, of that worthy Emperor doth Julius Capitolinus, report, That he was famae suae curiosissimus, 1exceeding chary and regardful of his good name; in so much, That malè loqentium dict is vel literis, vel Sermone respondebat; 2he was careful to return answer, either by word of mouth, ⟨p. 10⟩or in writing, unto the sayings of such as had raised evil reports of him. Among other things, he saith, Nihil aliud magis timuit & deprecatus est qam avaritiae famam; do qâ see multis 3epistolis purgat. He was solicitous to devolve and depel from himself nothing more then the note of avarice; (cast upon him by some, it seems, as on Pius before him, for his frugality, and moderating of public expenses, that he might nor be overburdensome 4to the subject) whereof he laboured to purge himself in divers of his Epistles. So careful are good men, and have ever been, both to gain, and to retain a good report; and the Apostle requires it, as a matter of much concernment in a Minister of the Gospel, [Greek or Hebrew], That he have 5a good report, even from those that are without; that he may be the fitter and better able to do good, as well on those without, by converting and bringing them in, as on those within, by confirming and building them up, having a good repute with, and being well thought of by either: To which purpose he adds, [Greek or Hebrew], That he may not fall under 6reproach, and into the snare of the calumniater or slanderer; as the same term would be also rendered in the same Chapter in those words, Not a novice, [Greek or Hebrew], lest being puffed up, he fall under the censure of the calumniater; 7as also in those words elsewhere, [Greek or Hebrew], nor give place to the calumniater, back-biter, or talebearer: Such as are wont by false reports, as with fuel, to 8foment and seed the fire of anger and ill will, where they find it already kindled; as also are persons so affected no less prone, lying in wait to that purpose, to take occasion by any flying, tho never so false report to traduce Gods Ministers, and blast their credit, all they can. And as all Christian people therefore, so Christian Ministers much more, ought to be very chary and tender of their reputation:
Yet notwithstanding all this, of that worthy Emperor doth Julius Capitolinus, report, That he was famae suae curiosissimus, 1exceeding chary and regardful of his good name; in so much, That malè loqentium dict is vel literis, vel Sermone respondebat; 2he was careful to return answer, either by word of mouth, ⟨p. 10⟩or in writing, unto the sayings of such as had raised evil reports of him. Among other things, he saith, Nihil aliud magis timuit & deprecatus est qam avaritiae famam; do qâ se multis 3epistolis purgat. He was solicitous to devolv and depel from himself nothing more then the note of avarice; (cast upon him by some, it seems, as on Pius before him, for his frugalitie, and moderating of publick expences, that he might nor be overburdensom 4to the subject) whereof he labored to purge himself in divers of his Epistles. So careful ar good men, and have ever been, both to gain, and to retain a good report; and the Apostle reqires it, as a matter of much concernment in a Minister of the Gospel, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, That he have 5a good report, even from those that ar without; that he may be the fitter and better able to do good, as wel on those without, by converting and bringing them in, as on those within, by confirming and building them up, having a good repute with, and being wel thought of by either: To which purpose he adds, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, That he may not fall under 6reproach, and into the snare of the calumniater or slanderer; as the same term would be also rendred in the same Chapter in those words, Not a novice, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, lest being puffed up, he fal under the censure of the calumniater; 7as also in those words elswhere, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, nor give place to the calumniater, back-biter, or talebearer: Such as ar wont by fals reports, as with fewel, to
As the Apostle Paul apparently showeth himself to have been, when he takes so much pains, and spends so many almost whole Chapters, in the Vindication of it, against those false brethren, and counterfeit Apostles, who had at 1Corinth endeavoured to wrong him therein. And I suppose some necessity lies upon me at present also to do.
As the Apostle Paul apparentlie sheweth himself to have been, when he takes so much pains, and spends so manie almost whole Chapters, in the Vindication of it, against those fals brethren, and counterfeit Apostles, who had at 1Corinth endeavored to wrong him therein. And I suppose some necessitie lies upon me at present also to do.
For howsoever Lilies words are, as we use to say, no slander; he is so well known to be a most notorious liar, and one that regards ⟨p. 11⟩not what he saith; and it is a received rule in the Civil Law, Mendax semel, mendax semper praesumitur. He that hath been once taken in a lie, and much more, one that hath been oft taken (as he hath been) in false tales not a few, is never after to be credited. And again, A bad mans reproach is no dispraise. The commendation of such, is sometime rather deemed a kind of dispraise, making the party whom such commend, suspected to be like those by whom he is commended. And Seneca therefore, Non est infamia infamari ab infamibus. It is no infamy 1for a man to be defamed, by those that are infamous themselves; And therefore, saith he, as it is mere fondness for a man, Laetari, 2qod ab eis laudatur, qos non po•est ipse laudare, to rejoice when he is commended of those, whom himself cannot commend. So is it mere madness for a man, Vereri ne ab infamibus infametur, 3to fear being traduced and defamed, by those that are infamous themselves, and he well knows to be such. Yet because, as Medius, one of Great Alexander's base Parasites, and among his Sycophants, a chief Master, is reported to have delivered this lesson to his Scholars, [Greek or Hebrew] 4That they should boldly and confidently, touch or touch, and snap or bite men with calumnies or slanders, not regarding how untrue, how unlikely they were; for, said he, [Greek or Hebrew]; that is, as Seneca 5renders it, Cum vul[…] sanatum est, manebit cicatrix. Tho the party bitten, lick the wound never so whole again, yet some scar will remain upon the place that was hurt. And the Poet therefore, when he had said,
Conscia mens recti vulgi mendacia ridet.6
For howsoever Lilies words ar, as we use to say, no slander; he is so wel known to be a most notorious lier, and one that regards ⟨p. 11⟩not what he saith; and it is a received rule in the Civil Law, Mendax semel, mendax semper praesumitur. He that hath been once taken in a lie, and much more, one that hath been oft taken (as he hath been) in fals tales not a few, is never after to be credited. And again, A bad mans reproach is no dispraise. The commendation of such, is sometime rather deemed a kind of dispraise, making the partie whom such commend, suspected to be like those by whom he is commended. And Seneca therefore, Non est infamia infamari ab infamibus. It is no infamie 1for a man to be defamed, by those that are infamous themselves; And therefore, saith he, as it is meer fondness for a man, Laetari, 2qod ab eis laudatur, qos non po•est ipse laudare, to rejoyce when he is commended of those, •hom himself cannot commend. So is it meer madness for a man, Vereri ne ab infamibus infametur, 3to fear being traduced and defamed, by those that are infamous themselvs, and he wel knows to be such. Yet because, as Medius, one of Great Alexanders base Parasites, and among his Sycophants, a cheif Master, is reported to have delivered this lesson to his Schollers, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉4That they should boldlie and confidentlie, touch or twich, and snap or bite men with calumnies or slanders, not regarding how untru, how unlikelie they were; for, said he, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉; that is, as Seneca 5renders it, Cum vul〈…〉 sanatum est, manebit cicatrix. Tho the partie bitten, lick the wound never so whole again, yet some scar wil remain upon the place that was hurt. And the Poet therefore, when he had said,
Conscia mens recti vulgi mendacia ridet.6
Sed nos in vitium (and so, in vituperium) credula turba sumus. People are commonly over-credulous, too prone to entertain evil reports, and to conceive evil surmises; too many men are naturally of a suspicious disposition; and as the Mimic hath it,
Seqiorem in partem strenua est suspicio.1
Suspition is wont to warp and bend more strongly to the worst side. Whence that saying so frequent in most mens mouths, There is seldom any smoke, but where there is some fire; and ⟨p. 12⟩yet in truth, there is smoke oft, yea, and much smoke, such as the by word relateth to, even a great smother of foggy fumes, raised by slanderous tongues, where no small spark of fire, or ember of truth at all is to be found.
Sed nos in vitium (and so, in vituperium) credula turba sumus. People ar commonlie over-credulous, too prone to entertain evil reports, and to conceiv evil surmises; too manie men ar naturallie of a suspitious disposition; and as the Mimik hath it,
Seqiorem in partem strenua est suspicio.1
Suspition is wont to warp and bend more stronglie to the worst side. Whence that saying so freqent in most mens mouths, There is seldom anie smoak, but where there is some fire; and ⟨p. 12⟩yet in truth, there is smoak oft, yea, and much smoak, such as the by word relateth to, even a great smother of foggie fumes, raised by slanderous tongues, where no smal spark of fire, or ember of truth at all is to be found.
The premises seriously considered, and all things well weighed, after much debate to and fro within my self, at length I resolved to follow the precedent of that thrice noble and renowned Emperor; the more noble and renowned and worthy of imitation, because so Philosophical, and tho no Christian, yet Christian-like in moralities, as well for practise as precept; and by some few lines at least, to clear my self from those soul, but false aspersions, wherewith this Sycophants calumniating pen hath endeavoured to stain my good name; the rather, for that my courses and carriages, having lived in an obscure corner, may in that regard be less known abroad; and my former works and writings, whereby some things objected here are to be cleared, being now either wholly out of print, or not easily procured, may not be obvious or read•e at hand for others, to make use of in the trial of the present debate.
The premises seriously considered, and all things wel weighed, after much debate to and fro within my self, at length I resolved to follow the precedent of that thrice noble and renowned Emperor; the more noble and renowned and worthie of imitation, because so Philosophical, and tho no Christian, yet Christian-like in moralities, as wel for practise as precept; and by some few lines at least, to cleer my self from those soul, but fals aspersions, wherewith this Sycophants calumniating pen hath endeavored to stain my good name; the rather, for that my courses and carriages, having lived in an obscure corner, may in that regard be less known abroad; and my former works and writings, whereby some things objected here ar to be cleered, being now either wholie out of print, or not easilie procured, may not be obvious or read•e at hand for others, to make use of in the trial of the present debate.
Mr. Gataker formerly a stiff Prelate, preaching impudently for the Liberties or Sports of the Sabbath, viz. Cards, Dice, &c. Afterward in hope of Bishops, Deans, or Chapter-Lands, a pretended Presbyterian; since its decay, the poor m•n is mute, &c. For what followeth will be best fitted to his after-charge.
Mr. Gataker formerlie a stiff Prelate, preaching impudentlie for the Liberties or Sports of the Sabbath, viz. Cards, Dice, &c. Afterward in hope of Bishops, Deans, or Chapter-Lands, a pretended Presbyterian; since its decay, the poor m•n is mute, &c. For what followeth wil be best fitted to his after-charge.
simplie evil, so of giving occasion of offence to man, by anie cours that may prov scandalous, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, saith Clemens of Alexandria, That they may not onelie
be faithful in regard of God, but of credit also in regard of men. Hence it is, that Julian saith, No• is necessaria est vita nostra, aliis fama nostra; that Our good life is needful for our selvs, our good name for others, as wel as our selvs: And Austine, Opus est bona famâ apud homines, bona conscientiâ apud Deum. Need have we as wel of a good report with men,
opinio sic parta delectabit: That if he wil do as he should do, he must oft-times do that which is just and upright, tho he shal be ill thought of▪ or ill spoken of for it; (that which Antisthenes,
as some, Alexander, as others, used to say, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that it was the lot of Kings to hear ill, when they did well;) and that, if he were so wise as he should be, an evil report, or evil repute so gotten, should be so far from daunting or disturbing him, that it ought rather to delight him;
foment and seed the fire of anger and ill wil, where they find it alreadie kindled; as also ar persons so affected no less prone, lying in wait to that purpose, to take occasion by anie flying, tho never so fals report to traduce Gods Ministers, and blast their credit, all they can. And as all Christian people therefore, so Christian Ministers much more, ought to be verie charie and tender of their reputation: