A85827:34
A discourse apologeticalA discours apologetical
A discourse apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and loud lies in his Merlin or Pasquil for the year 1654. are clearly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fully refuted; and his malicious and murderous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidently evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatory of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. author [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.A discours apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and lowd lies in his Merlin or Pasqil for the yeer 1654. are cleerly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fullie refuted; and his malicious and murtherous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidentlie evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatorie of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. autor [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.
London: printed by R. Ibbitson for Thomas Newberry, 1654
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
For howsoever Lilies words are, as we use to say, no slander; he is so well known to be a most notorious liar, and one that regards ⟨p. 11⟩not what he saith; and it is a received rule in the Civil Law, Mendax semel, mendax semper praesumitur. He that hath been once taken in a lie, and much more, one that hath been oft taken (as he hath been) in false tales not a few, is never after to be credited. And again, A bad mans reproach is no dispraise. The commendation of such, is sometime rather deemed a kind of dispraise, making the party whom such commend, suspected to be like those by whom he is commended. And Seneca therefore, Non est infamia infamari ab infamibus. It is no infamy 1for a man to be defamed, by those that are infamous themselves; And therefore, saith he, as it is mere fondness for a man, Laetari, 2qod ab eis laudatur, qos non po•est ipse laudare, to rejoice when he is commended of those, whom himself cannot commend. So is it mere madness for a man, Vereri ne ab infamibus infametur, 3to fear being traduced and defamed, by those that are infamous themselves, and he well knows to be such. Yet because, as Medius, one of Great Alexander's base Parasites, and among his Sycophants, a chief Master, is reported to have delivered this lesson to his Scholars, [Greek or Hebrew] 4That they should boldly and confidently, touch or touch, and snap or bite men with calumnies or slanders, not regarding how untrue, how unlikely they were; for, said he, [Greek or Hebrew]; that is, as Seneca 5renders it, Cum vul[…] sanatum est, manebit cicatrix. Tho the party bitten, lick the wound never so whole again, yet some scar will remain upon the place that was hurt. And the Poet therefore, when he had said, Conscia mens recti vulgi mendacia ridet.6