A85830:444
Shadows without substance, or, Pretended new lightsShadowes without substance, or, Pretended new lights
Shadows without substance, or, Pretended new lights: together, with the impieties and blasphemies that lurk under them, further discovered and drawn forth into the light: in way of rejoinder unto Mr John Saltmarsh his reply: entitled Shadows flying away. Wherein nothing less is showed to have been performed, then what the title page importeth; or the preface promiseth. As also, divers points of faith and passages of Scripture are vindicated and explained. / By Thomas Gataker, B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith. Published by authority.Shadowes without substance, or, Pretended new lights: together, with the impieties and blasphemies that lurk under them, further discovered and drawn forth into the light: in way of rejoynder unto Mr Iohn Saltmarsh his reply: entituled Shadowes flying away. Wherein nothing lesse is shewed to have been performed, then what the title page importeth; or the preface promiseth. As also, divers points of faith and passages of Scripture are vindicated and explained. / By Thomas Gataker, B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith. Published by authority.
London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1646
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. You tell your Reader, that* from pag. 29. to the last, (some 14 or 15 pages) my replies all amount not to any thing of substance, but of qarelsom• and humorous exceptions.
1. You tell your Reader, that* from pag. 29. to the last, (some 14 or 15 pages) my replies all amount not to any thing of substance, but of qarelsom• and humourous exceptions.
- *Conclus. p. 16.
An easy way indeed of reply, as you term this: but whether there be not there some store of such matter as concerned you to answer, and to clear your self of, those that read it impartially will as easily espy.
An easie way indeed of reply, as you term this: but whether there be not there some store of such matter as concerned you to answer, and to cleer your self of, those that read it impartially will as easily espy.
Had I said the like of your whole Reply, from the first to the last, and so left it; those that shall seriously survey and weigh this Rejoinder, will peradventure deem, that I had neither spoken nor done much amiss. Tho those of your own party, it is not unlikely, would have been extolling your work, and have given out, that it was unanswerable. But Sir, your Reply here I have not so either put off, or posted over. I have traced and pursued you, not from page to page only; but from line to line, even through all your idle and extravagant excursions. But I find you here no other then I observe you to be in your Replies upon, and Answers unto others, both annexed to this, and elsewhere. To make up somewhat that may rise a little higher then the common appellation of a Pamphlet, (a term that you much stomach) you entertain your Reader with some impertinent discourses of by-matters; tending mostly, under specious pretences of Love, Peace, and Unity, to plead for a toleration of all abominable opinions, and liberty for every one in matter of religion, to profess, vent, and practice what he please, without check or control by censure, either Ecclesiastical or Civill. What else meansb several spirits, consciences, opinions, judgements, without limitation or exception of any? But what you return Answer to, or reply upon, that you make very short work of: here a snatch, and there a snatch,c as the Egyptian dog, lapping in Nilus, and as Antony in his flight, after his discomfiture by Augustus. dSeventeen sheets posted over ⟨p. 96⟩in a sheet and an half: ewhole pages in a line and an half: ftwo large books in little more then two pages: forty five pages here in seventeen: and yet by-matters sometime in the way plentifully enough prosecuted; and additionals prefixed, to detain and take up the Reader, that your failings in the matter that concerns you may the less be looked after; and your dealing haltingly and by halves, or by snips and shreds rather, the less regarded. Yet in the Front of your writings you pretend and promise to do great matters; but in the works themselves there is so little performed of what is looked for, that the old saying may not unfitly be applied unto them, being verified in them,g There is more in the Title then in the Text.
Had I said the like of your whole Reply, from the first to the last, and so left it; those that shall seriously survey and weigh this Rejoynder, will peradventure deem, that I had neither spoken nor done much amisse. Tho those of your own party, it is not unlikely, would have been extolling your work, and have given out, that it was unanswerable. But Sir, your Reply here I have not so either put off, or posted over. I have traced and pursued you, not from page to page onely; but from line to line, even through all your idle and extravagant excursions. But I find you here no other then I observe you to be in your Replies upon, and Answers unto others, both annexed to this, and elsewhere. To make up somewhat that may rise a little higher then the common appellation of a Pamphlet, (a term that you much stomack) you entertain your Reader with some impertinent discourses of by-matters; tending mostly, under specious pretences of Love, Peace, and Ʋnity, to plead for a toleration of all abominable opinions, and libertie for every one in matter of religion, to professe, vent, and practice what he please, without check or controll by censure, either Ecclesiasticall or Civill. What else meansb severall spirits, consciences, opinions, judgements, without limitation or exception of any? But what you return Answer to, or reply upon, that you make very short work of: here a snatch, and there a snatch,c as the Egyptian dog, lapping in Nilus, and as Antonie in his flight, after his discomfiture by Augustus. dSeventeen sheets posted over ⟨p. 96⟩in a sheet and an half: ewhole pages in a line and an half: ftwo large books in little more then two pages: forty five pages here in seventeen: and yet by-matters sometime in the way plentifully enough prosecuted; and additionals prefixed, to detain and take up the Reader, that your failings in the matter that concerns you may the lesse be looked after; and your dealing haltingly and by halvs, or by snips and shreds rather, the lesse regarded. Yet in the Front of your writings you pretend and promise to do great matters; but in the works themselves there is so little perf•rmed of what is looked for, that the old saying may not unfitly be applied unto them, being verified in them,g There is more in the Title then in the Text.
- bReasons for &c. Sect. 4.
- cQod canis in Nilo, bibit, & fugit. Constat enim in regionibus illis canes raptu crocodilorum exterritos curer & bibere. Macrob. Sat. l. 2. c. 2. De hoc Aelian. l. 1. c. 4. Plin. l. 8. c. 40.Qod canis in Nilo, bibit, & fugit. Constat enim in regionibus illis canes raptu crocodilorum exterritos currere & bibere. Macrob. Sat. l. 2. c. 2. De hoc Aelian. l. 1. c. 4. Plin. l. 8. c. 40.
- dLetter to Mr. Ley, p. 3. After-reckon. p. 7.
- eRepl p. 9. See Rejoinder.Repl p. 9. See Rejoynder.
- fAnsw. to Mr. Edwards, and After-reckoner.
- gPlus habet rubium qam nigrum.
2. In stead of what you should have done, you tell meh what I might have done, Indeed, I suppose, you would rather have had me done any thing, then have meddled with the ulcerous sores of your book. But Sir, you are not to cut me out my work. And for the Argument you would here have put me upon, such an one as those of your strain every-where condemn and cry out against, I have somewhat largelyi done elsewhere already; and that (I bless God for it) with some good success, as I understand from those, who having made use of it, profess to have received much comfort thereby.
2. In stead of what you should have done, you tell meh what I might have done, Indeed, I suppose, you would rather have had mee done any thing, then have medled with the ulcerous sores of your book. But Sir, you are not to cut mee out my work. And for the Argument you would here have put mee upon, such an one as those of your strain every-where condemn and cry out against, I have somewhat largelyi done elsewhere already; and that (I blesse God for it) with some good successe, as I understand from those, who having made use of it, professe to have received much comfort thereby.
- hConclus. Ibid.
- iMeditation on Psal. 97.11. in Signs of sincerity.
3. Yet to quit me of that labour, (in way of kindness no doubt) you tell me, thatk I say of my self, (how becoming such a one, you leave) that I am an old Steed that neighs, and prances, but is past service; so as you must take this of mine age and infirmity, as a fuller answer, or supplement of what I have failed in against you.
3. Yet to quit mee of that labour, (in way of kindnesse no doubt) you tell mee, thatk I say of my self, (how becoming such a one, you leave) that I am an old Steed that neighs, and prances, but is past service; so as you must take this of mine age and infirmitie, as a fuller answer, or supplement of what I have failed in against you.
- kConclus. Ibid.
True It is, Sir, in regard of mine age, being now upon seventy two complete, and infirmity by a late sore sickness accruing, having never been of much strength, and finding my natural abilities, as well inward as outward, (l the one usually suffering with the other) memory especially, much impaired; I ⟨p. 97⟩am willing rather to set others of younger years, fresher parts, and better endowments, on work, to prosecute the discovery and discomfiture of these monsters, which the Sectaries of these our times daily produce, and to undertake some further and larger survey of your Treatise, which, but upon occasion of being called in by you to attest for you, I had not at all taken notice of; it may be, had never seen: and do therefore in acknowledging mine own inability to undertake such an over-burdensome employment, compare my self, not as he in the Tragic Scene only, but as one of the Greek Fathers, to an old Steed, who tho past years of such service as the field and fight requires; yet by bestirring himself as well as he may, incites others to do that which himself is not able to do. And this is that which Mr. S. is so much pleased to play upon, and to make sport with, that he began with it in his Introduction, and returns now again to it in his Conclusion; as being bare and barren of better matter, to make up his Reply with, and enforced therefore with renewed patches to piece it out.
True It is, Sir, in regard of mine age, being now upon seventy two complete, and infirmitie by a late sore sicknesse accrewing, having never been of much strength, and finding my naturall abilities, as well inward as outward, (l the one usually suffering with the other) memory especially, much impaired; I ⟨p. 97⟩am willing rather to set others of younger yeers, fresher parts, and better endowments, on work, to prosecute the discovery and discomfiture of these monsters, which the Sectaries of these our times daily produce, and to undertake some further and larger survey of your Treatise, which, but upon occasion of being called in by you to attest for you, I had not at all taken notice of; it may be, had never seen: and doe therefore in acknowledging mine own inability to undertake such an over-burdensome employment, compare my self, not as hee in the Tragick Scene onely, but as one of the Greek Fathers, to an old Steed, who tho past yeers of such service as the field and fight reqires; yet by bestirring himself as well as he may, incites others to do that which himself is not able to do. And this is that which Mr. S. is so much pleased to play upon, and to make sport with, that hee began with it in his Introduction, and returns now again to it in his Conclusion; as being bare and barren of better matter, to make up his Reply with, and enforced therefore with renewed patches to piece it out.
- l[Greek or Hebrew]. Aristot. Physiogn. cap. 4. [Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. cap. 1. Animus, languente corpore, nec membris, nec sensibus uti potest: Cicer. de Divin. Animo qi aegrotat, videmus corpore hunc signum dare: Tum doloribus confectum corpus animo obsistere: Lucil. lib. 26.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Aristot. Physiogn. cap. 4. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. cap. 1. Animus, languente corpore, nec membris, nec sensibus uti potest: Cicer. de Divin. Animo qi aegrotat, videmus corpore hunc signum dare: Tum doloribus confectum corpus animo obsistere: Lucil. lib. 26.
But Sir, neither do I suppose it any uncomely thing, for any Minister of the Gospel, much broken with age and sickness, to acknowledge himself either well near, or wholly past some kind of service: mGod himself was after some term of years content to discharge his Attendants in the Tabernacle and Temple of some more laborious employments. Nor do I plead either of these in way of excuse for, or (as you speak; which to me seems little better then non-sense) as a supplement to what I have failed in against you: which if in ought I have done, it is your part to show, not barely to say; but to declare, why I took no further pains with you; but contented my self with such parcels of your broken wares, as I thought good to deal with at present. And truly Sir, unless you can better discharge and defend your self and your Assertions in the things objected and excepted against either, then in this your Reply hitherto you have done; there will be little need to wade further into your work: there is folly and unsoundness enough discovered in it already to make it worthily to be abhorred.
But Sir, neither doe I suppose it any uncomely thing, for any Minister of the Gospel, much broken with age and sicknesse, to acknowledge himself either well neer, or wholly past some kind of service: mGod himself was after some term of yeers content to discharge his Attendants in the Tabernacle and Temple of some more laborious employments. Nor do I plead either of these in way of excuse for, or (as you speak; which to me seems little better then non-sense) as a supplement to what I have failed in against you: which if in ought I have done, it is your part to shew, not barely to say; but to declare, why I took no further pains with you; but contented my self with such parcels of your broken wares, as I thought good to deal with at present. And truly Sir, unlesse you can better discharge and defend your self and your Assertions in the things objected and excepted against either, then in this your Reply hitherto you have done; there will be little need to wade further into your work: there is folly and unsoundnesse enough discovered in it already to make it worthily to be abhorred.
4. Howbeit,n two or three things, you say there are (in that riff-raf of so many pages, which you told us even now had not any matter of substance in them) more observable then the rest.
4. Howbeit,n two or three things, you say there are (in that rif-raf of so many pages, which you told us even now had not any matter of substance in them) more observable then the rest.
- nConcl. Ibid.
But you repented you, it seems, again of what you had said; or you had no great lust to deal much with any observable matter. For instead of two or three, you present us (as I remember a greato Cardinal sometime) with a first, without second or third: so that your first must be such a first, as the Lawyers speak of in some cases; such a first asp none follows; and must therefore go for both first and last: for it is all you produce.
But you repented you, it seems, again of what you had said; or you had no great lust to deal much with any observable matter. For instead of two or three, you present us (as I remember a greato Cardinall sometime) with a first, without second or third: so that your first must be such a first, as the Lawyers speak of in some cases; such a first asp none follows; and must therefore goe for both first and last: for it is all you produce.
- oBellarm. de sac. Euchar. l. 3. cap. 19.
- pPrimus est qem nemo praecedit, etiamsi nullus seqatur, Reg. Jur.
qFirst therefore, you say, that I tax you for saying, The marks in the Epistles of John and James, (where Sir, you leave outr your &c.) are delivered rather as marks for others, then our selves to know us by. And this, say you, I affirm again; not excluding that other of our selves, but rather for others. To which purpose you instance 1. in James 2.24, 18, 21. where works, you say, are made a sign rather to others, then our selves. Which how Is show to be not agreeable to the Apostles main scope, who directs his speech there to the party, thereby to undeceive him in himself; you pass by, and return no answer unto. 2. In 1 John 3.14. concerning which passage, how absurd and senseless it is so to say, how directly contrary, both to the Apostles scope in that Epistle, and to his express words in that very place, tho the bare reading of the Text be sufficient to make evident, yet I shall refer my Reader (tot avoid needless prolixity, and unnecessary repetitions) to what I have saidu in mine Answer; whereunto there is no one word here replied: And much less to that of Peter; which ought to come within compass of your & caetera; but you have no mind at all to take notice of: and that the rather, because with it this your rather, wherewith you would evade, could have no colour, as here also it hath no truth.
qFirst therefore, you say, that I tax you for saying, The marks in the Epistles of John and James, (where Sir, you leave outr your &c.) are delivered rather as marks for others, then our selves to know us by. And this, say you, I affirm again; not excluding that other of our selves, but rather for others. To which purpose you instance 1. in James 2.24, 18, 21. where works, you say, are made a sign rather to others, then our selves. Which how Is shew to be not agreeable to the Apostles main scope, who directs his speech there to the partie, thereby to undeceive him in himself; you passe by, and return no answer unto. 2. In 1 John 3.14. concerning which passage, how absurd and senselesse it is so to say, how directly contrary, both to the Apostles scope in that Epistle, and to his expresse words in that very place, tho the bare reading of the Text be sufficient to make evident, yet I shall refer my Reader (tot avoid needlesse prolixitie, and unnecessary repetitions) to what I have saidu in mine Answer; whereunto there is no one word here replied: And much lesse to that of Peter; which ought to come within compasse of your & caetera; but you have no mind at all to take notice of: and that the rather, because with it this your rather, wherewith you would evade, could have no colour, as here also it hath no truth.
- qConclus. Ib.
- rTreat. p. 32.
- sAnsw. p. 29.
- t[Greek or Hebrew] Suid. in Pythag.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Suid. in Pythag.
- uAns. ubi. supr.
And Sir, for what being enforced by evidence of truth, shining forth so strongly and brightly in your face, that in spite of your teeth it strikes through your eye-lids, tho you close them as fast as you can possibly against it, you do in a scanty and malignant manner elsewherex acknowledge; (which also I conceal not, buty give it expressly in your own words) after you have spent all your fleam and spittle upon it, to bespatter it, and throw so much dirt and filth on the face of it, to deface and disgrace it; it neither makes amends for your former abuse of it, nor doth it take off ought that is herein charged on you.
And Sir, for what being enforced by evidence of truth, shining forth so strongly and brightly in your face, that in spite of your teeth it strikes through your eye-lids, tho you close them as fast as you can possibly against it, you doe in a scanty and malignant manner elsewherex acknowledge; (which also I conceal not, buty give it expresly in your own words) after you have spent all your fleam and spittle upon it, to bespatter it, and throw so much dirt and filth on the face of it, to deface and disgrace it; it neither makes amends for your former abuse of it, nor doth it take off ought that is herein charged on you.
- xTreat. p. 81.
- yAns. p. 27, 28.
And for your pitiful complaint therefore ofa my pulling your Treatise in pieces, to make my self work; and then binding it up again after mine own fashion;
And for your pitifull complaint therefore ofa my pulling your Treatise in pieces, to make my self work; and then binding it up again after mine own fashion;
- aConcl. Ibid.
It is so poor, as mightb move even a professed adversary to pity you; and shows indeed how inconsistent your Work is, one part of it with another.
It is so poor, as mightb move even a professed adversary to pity you; and shews indeed how inconsistent your Work is, one part of it with another.
- b[Greek or Hebrew] Suid. vel Priamo miseranda: Mar. l. 12.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Suid. vel Priamo miseranda: Mar. l. 12.
But Sir, I want not work at home; that I should, withc the Lydian, go to seek some abroad. much less wanted I any then, when my work rather wanted me, I being neither fit almost for any work at all, and wanting workmen for that work, which God had at that time disabled me unto. Nor had I any reason to undertake that task that then I did, had I not conceived a kind of necessity in it.
But Sir, I want not work at home; that I should, withc the Lydian, go to seek some abroad. much lesse wanted I any then, when my work rather wanted me, I being neither fit almost for any work at all, and wanting workmen for that work, which God had at that time disabled me unto. Nor had I any reason to undertake that task that then I did, had I not conceived a kind of necessitie in it.
- c[Greek or Hebrew] Suid. Zenob. Plut. ad Colot.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Suid. Zenob. Plut. ad Colot.
Yet neither have I pulled your book in pieces; nor have I bound it up again after my fashion. Your book lies by me still entire; bound up in the same manner as it was brought me at first: only I have made bold to pick out of it, and lay open some neither sound, nor savoury passages of it, and have dressed them indeed as they deserved; but representing them no otherwise then as I found them in the book: the precise words whereof you have not hitherto showed, that I have any where swerved from; nor suppose I, that I did amiss in so doing: for neither did I undertake to deal with the whole book, but to give some taste of what it contained: nor if any thing be sound in it, will that serve to excuse and justify ought, that is rotten and unsound.
Yet neither have I pulled your book in peeces; nor have I bound it up again after my fashion. Your book lies by me still intire; bound up in the same manner as it was brought mee at first: onely I have made bold to pick out of it, and lay open some neither sound, nor savoury passages of it, and have dressed them indeed as they deserved; but representing them no otherwise then as I found them in the book: the precise words whereof you have not hitherto shewed, that I have any where swarved from; nor suppose I, that I did amisse in so doing: for neither did I undertake to deal with the whole book, but to give some tast of what it contained: nor if any thing be sound in it, will that serve to excuse and justifie ought, that is rotten and unsound.
As ford the story of the Lady, what you except against my speech to her, it is already answered elsewhere, where the proper place of it was, and where all this might have come in more seasonably, then it doth here. But in steed of it, Sir, you might have done well, not to say over the same things again; but to have asserted and confirmed by Scripture, that way of assurance, thate you propound as the only Scripture way, and in regard whereof all other assurances (those that Peter, James and John hold out, not excepted) are affirmed to be but rotten stuff; to wit, That we are to believe, that Christ hath believed for us; and we have believed in him; that he hath repented for us; and we have repented in him. For this, Sir, being one of your main shores, yea the only main shore in effect, (your immediate enthusiasm excepted) ⟨p. 100⟩erected and set up by you for the support of poor afflicted Spirits, when you have beaten them off from all other, ought not to have been deserted by you, where you found it opposed, much less dissembled, and shifted off, and shuffled, or shovelled away, as a thing not worthy of any notice, among the rubble and rubbish, wherein you say, there is nothing of any substance. And the truth is, I am therein of the same mind with you, if you think as you speak, as concerning this particular, that it is a mere shadow without substance; and such therefore as is no more able to afford any true stay, or sound satisfaction to a wavering soul, or a wearied spirit, thenf the shadow of the sheeps shoulder that the dog catched at in the water, or some delineation of the like on the wall, to relieve and refresh an hungry body. Take heed, Sir, how whilst you dally and delight your self with such sublimated notions, distilled through the limbeck of your own quaint invention; you delude Gods people, and cause them, as Jonah spake, while theyg follow lying vanities, to forsake their own mercy; and so attract a greater guilt, then you are aware of, or at least consider well of at present.
As ford the story of the Ladie, what you except against my speech to her, it is alredy answered elsewhere, where the proper place of it was, and where all this might have come in more seasonably, then it doth here. But in steed of it, Sir, you might have done well, not to say over the same things again; but to have asserted and confirmed by Scripture, that way of assurance, thate you propound as the only Scripture way, and in regard whereof all other assurances (those that Peter, James and John hold out, not excepted) are affirmed to be but rotten stuffe; to wit, That we are to beleive, that Christ hath beleived for us; and we have beleived in him; that he hath repented for us; and we have repented in him. For this, Sir, being one of your main shores, yea the onely main shore in effect, (your immediate enthusiasm excepted) ⟨p. 100⟩erected and set up by you for the support of poor afflicted Spirits, when you have beaten them off from all other, ought not to have been deserted by you, where you found it opposed, much lesse dissembled, and shifted off, and shuffled, or shoveled away, as a thing not worthy of any notice, among the rubble and rubbish, wherin you say, there is nothing of any substance. And the truth is, I am therein of the same mind with you, if you think as you speak, as concerning this particular, that it is a meer shadow without substance; and such therfore as is no more able to afford any true stay, or sound satisfaction to a wavering soul, or a wearied spirit, thenf the shadow of the sheeps shoulder that the dog catched at in the water, or some delineation of the like on the wall, to releive and refresh an hungry body. Take heed, Sir, how whilst you dally and delight your self with such sublimated notions, distilled through the limbeck of your own qaint invention; you delude Gods people, and cause them, as Jonas spake, while theyg follow lying vanities, to forsake their own mercy; and so attract a greater guilt, then you are aware of, or at least consider well of at present.
- dConcl. p. 16, 17.
- eTreat. p. 84, 85.
- fAesopi fab.
- gJon. 2.8.