A85830:485
Shadows without substance, or, Pretended new lightsShadowes without substance, or, Pretended new lights
Shadows without substance, or, Pretended new lights: together, with the impieties and blasphemies that lurk under them, further discovered and drawn forth into the light: in way of rejoinder unto Mr John Saltmarsh his reply: entitled Shadows flying away. Wherein nothing less is showed to have been performed, then what the title page importeth; or the preface promiseth. As also, divers points of faith and passages of Scripture are vindicated and explained. / By Thomas Gataker, B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith. Published by authority.Shadowes without substance, or, Pretended new lights: together, with the impieties and blasphemies that lurk under them, further discovered and drawn forth into the light: in way of rejoynder unto Mr Iohn Saltmarsh his reply: entituled Shadowes flying away. Wherein nothing lesse is shewed to have been performed, then what the title page importeth; or the preface promiseth. As also, divers points of faith and passages of Scripture are vindicated and explained. / By Thomas Gataker, B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith. Published by authority.
London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1646
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. Your main drift herein (and that not concealed, but professedly held forth) is, in plain terms, impious. For it is (as hath already in part also been showed) directly to contradict the Apostle John, and to make him a liar: for he telleth us, that hereby we may know and have assurance, that we are in the state of grace and life; qif we walk in light, rif we love the brethren; sif we do those things that are well-pleasing unto God. And on the other side, you tell us, that we cannot hereby know, or have any assurance of it: and what is this, but in express terms to contradict what he saith, and to give the holy Ghost speaking by him the lie? Or what other end can you pretend that you propounded to your self in this your prolix and curious sifting and shriving of Mr. G. but to make this assertion good? And yet, alas, Sir, what is he? a feeble wretch,t beset one every side with manifold infirmities; a sorry creature, made up of a multitude of imperfections; one of the meanest in his Lords house, of the most unserviceable in his Masters family. Why should you pick him out as a pattern, or an instance, whereby to disprove the Apostle? For what if Mr. G. a man of so many failings, were not able to make out any good account of his assurances from such grounds as John there gives; or were found so faulty, that he could not pass the trial, and attain approbation, by such marks, as he there propounds: and that Mr. S. here had laid such load of iniquity and hypocrisy upon him, as must of necessity force him off from his hold. Yet what is that to the truth of the Apostles doctrine, or the proving of it to be vain, and fruitless, and useless, and frivolous, and such as no other, tho sincere and upright, might ⟨p. 109⟩gather ground of assurance from? To what purpose then is it, Sir, that youu bring him thus here on the stage? either it is only to traduce him: and that is mere malignity; or else it is to cross the doctrine it self delivered by the Apostle; and that is gross impiety. Make your choice, Sir, your self, for whether of the two, you reserved this to the last: and let it then go for an assay of the rest, if you so please.