Shadows without substance, or, Pretended new lightsShadowes without substance, or, Pretended new lights
Shadows without substance, or, Pretended new lights: together, with the impieties and blasphemies that lurk under them, further discovered and drawn forth into the light: in way of rejoinder unto Mr John Saltmarsh his reply: entitled Shadows flying away. Wherein nothing less is showed to have been performed, then what the title page importeth; or the preface promiseth. As also, divers points of faith and passages of Scripture are vindicated and explained. / By Thomas Gataker, B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith. Published by authority.Shadowes without substance, or, Pretended new lights: together, with the impieties and blasphemies that lurk under them, further discovered and drawn forth into the light: in way of rejoynder unto Mr Iohn Saltmarsh his reply: entituled Shadowes flying away. Wherein nothing lesse is shewed to have been performed, then what the title page importeth; or the preface promiseth. As also, divers points of faith and passages of Scripture are vindicated and explained. / By Thomas Gataker, B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith. Published by authority.
Thomas Gataker 1574–1654London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1646
[2], 52, 53a-62k, 53-114, [2] p. · 52k words · Wing G326 · ESTC R201089
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. I would demand of you, or of any of them that so hold, how any point of Divinity, that is not in express terms laid down in Gods Word, can but by the help of Logic be thence deduced; ⟨p. 20⟩and yet how many points are there of undoubted truth, that have no other necessary ground, such deduction excepted?
1. I would demand of you, or of any of them that so hold, how any point of Divinity, that is not in expresse terms laid down in Gods Word, can but by the help of Logick be thence deduced; ⟨p. 20⟩and yet how many points are there of undoubted truth, that have no other necessary ground, such deduction excepted?
2. Did not our Saviour himself make use of Logic, when from Moses by way of Syllogism, nagainst the Sadducees he confirmed the doctrine of the Resurrection? wheno from the Story of the Creation, and Gods institution of Marriage, he discovered the unwarrantablenesse of groundless Divorces? when from the words of the Psalmist,
the Lawfulness of that which his Disciples did on the Sabbath? Yea, do not the Apostles frequently by Logical Arguments prove points of Divinity, and confirm matters of faith; as Paul
If Paul at Athens disputed with those chief Logicians the Stoics, beware how you object the use of Logic as a fault to any; which that the Apostles, yea, and Christ himself used, can not be denied. But I shall spare to spend more word in pursuit of this point, until Mr. S. further herein explain himself, and let us know what he will own in it, and how far forth he will give those that deal with him leave to make use of their Logic. Sure, if reason be the eye of the soul, and Logic
of using reason aright; they that would debar men of the use of Logic, would have them either put out or seal up their eyes, that being blind or blinded, they may lead them as
the Prophet did the Syrian Troopers smitten with blindness upon his prayer, or transfer and carry them as the Falkner doth the Hank hood-winked, whether themselves please.
2. Did not our Saviour himself make use of Logick, when from Moses by way of Syllogism, nagainst the Saduces he confirmed the doctrine of the Resurrection? wheno from the Story of the Creation, and Gods institution of Marriage, he discovered the unwarrantablenesse of groundlesse Divorces? when from the words of the Psalmist, phe asserted his own Deity; and from a passage of the Prophet Hoshea, qthe Lawfulnesse of that which his Disciples did on the Sabbath? Yea, do not the Apostles freqently by Logicall Arguments prove points of Divinity, and confirm matters of faith; as Paulr justification, not by works, but by faith, sthe necessity of sanctification and newnesse of life, in persons by faith justified; tthe foulnesse of fornication; uthe haynousnesse of feasting with Idolaters in Idoll-Temples, xthe resurrection from the dead and the like: or how think we, disputed he at Athens withy the Stoicks, the menz of most repute for Logicall skill in those times? doth not his Sermon it self shew it? I might well, Sir, say to you, as Augustine to Cresconius, *If Paul at Athens disputed with those chief Logitians the Stoiks, beware how you object the use of Logick as a fault to any; which that the Apostles, yea, and Christ himself used, can not bee denyed. But I shall spare to spend more worde in pursuit of this point, untill Mr. S. further herein explain himself, and let us know what he will own in it, and how farre forth he will give those that deal with him leave to make use of their Logick. Sure, if reason be the eye of the soul, and Logick athe art or way, or methode bof using reason aright; they that would debar men of the use of Logick, would have them either put out or seal up their eyes, that being blind or blinded, they may lead them asc the Prophet did the Syrian Troopers smitten with blindnesse upon his prayer, or transfer and cary them as the Falkner doth the Hank hood-winkt, whether themselves please.
zStoici •ogicam sive Rationalem Philosophiū cum primis excolebant: qam Epicurei, licet repudiarent, tamen cum ambigua discernendi, salsa coargu•ndi, necessitas incumberet, alio nomine, Canonicae scil. introducere cogebantur. Laert in Zenon. & Chrysip. Senec. Epist. 89.Stoici •ogicam sive Rationalem Philosophiū cum primis excolebant: qam Epicurei, licet repudiarent, tamen cum ambigua discernendi, salsa coargu•ndi, necessitas incumberet, alio nomine, Canonicae scil. introducere cogebantur. Laert in Zenon. & Chrysip. Senec. Epist. 89.
*Si Paulus dial•cticus erat, & ideò conferre cum Stoicis, qi Dialectici maximi erant, non timebat; cave ne Dialecticam cuiqam pro crimine objeceris, qa usos Apostolos confiteris. Aug. ad Crescon l. 1. c. 12.13. Sed & Christum ipsum. Ibid. c. 17.
a[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
b[Greek or Hebrew]. Plato Alcib. 1.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Plato Alcib. 1.
But Sir, I shall entreat you to give me leave, or shall be so bold as to take leave, whither you list to give it or no, to be a little further troublesome unto you with my Logic in something, wherein forbearing to relate mine Argument, you slubber over the matter after your wonted manner of answering, as if so you said somewhat, it were not material whither or no it were to the purpose. I charge you with making Gods Prophets del•ders of Gods people; which tho it be apparent enough, by what already hath beend said, yet I do by this Argument further make good.
But Sir, I shall intreat you to give me leave, or shall be so bold as to take leave, whither you list to give it or no, to be a litle further troublesome unto you with my Logick in something, wherein forbearing to relate mine Argument, you slubber over the matter after your wonted manner of answering, as if so you said somewhat, it were not materiall whither or no it were to the purpose. I charge you with making Gods Prophets del•ders of Gods people; which tho it be apparent enough, by what already hath beend said, yet I doe by this Argument further make good.
Those that profess to Preach free-grace, and yet propound it with such conditions and qualifications, that tho free-grace may be in the notion of it, yet it is not in the truth of it; they delude the people to whom they so preach.
Those that professe to Preach free-grace, and yet propound it with such conditions and qalifications, that tho free-grace may be in the notion of it, yet it is not in the truth of it; they delude the people to whom they so preach.
But the Prophets of God, say you, tho they profess to preach free-grace, yet they propounded it with such conditions and qualifications, that tho free-grace might be in the notion of it yet it was not in the truth of it.
But the Prophets of God, say you, tho they professe to preach free-grace, yet they propounded it with such conditions and qalifications, that tho free-grace might be in the notion of it yet it was not in the truth of it.
For first, concerning the former part of it, thate the Prophets professed to preach free-grace, you grant and produce as others also of yours dof a passage of Isaiah, to that purpose. And secondly, for the latter part, to wit, that it was by them tempered with such conditions and qualifications, as did eat out the very heart of free-grace, that tho it were in the notion of it, yet it was not in the truth, I thus prove to be yours.
For first, concerning the former part of it, thate the Prophets professed to preach free-grace, you grant and produce as others also of yours doef a passage of Esay, to that purpose. And secondly, for the latter part, to wit, that it was by them tempered with such conditions and qalifications, as did eat out the very heart of free-grace, that tho it were in the notion of it, yet it was not in the truth, I thus prove to be yours.
If the conditions and qualifications used by the Legalists (as you stile them) of these times, in preaching of the Gospel, being no other then such as the Prophets of God formerly used, are such as the free grace may be there in the notion, yet it is not in the truth of it; then was it by the Prophets so tempered, that tho free-grace might be there in the notion of it, yet it was not in the truth of it.
If the conditions and qalifications used by the Legalists (as you stile them) of these times, in preaching of the Gospel, being no other then such as the Prophets of God formerly used, are such as the free grace may be there in the notion, yet it is not in the truth of it; then was it by the Prophets so tempered, that tho free-grace might be there in the notion of it, yet it was not in the truth of it.
But the conditions and qualifications, say you, used by our legal ⟨p. 22⟩teachers in preaching the Gospel, being no other then such as the Prophets of God formerly used, are such as tho free-grace may be there in the notion, yet it is not in the truth of it.
But the conditions and qalifications, say you, used by our legall ⟨p. 22⟩teachers in preaching the Gospel, being no other then such as the Prophets of God formerly used, are such as tho free-grace may be there in the notion, yet it is not in the truth of it.
The Proposition cannot be by any colour denied; for whatsoever destroys the nature and truth of free-grace, must needs be of the same force, wheresoever it is found.
The Proposition cannot be by any colour denyed; for whatsoever destroys the nature and truth of free-grace, must needs be of the same force, wheresover it is found.
And for the Assumption, neither do you, nor can you deny any part of it to be your own: For all that herein you charge the Legalists with, both now again and before, isg preaching the Gospel with such conditions and qualifications as the Prophets did; and of such preaching you say in express terms,h that tho it may have a notion of free grace, yet it hath not the truth of it.
And for the Assumption, neither do you, nor can you deny any part of it to be your own: For all that herein you charge the Legalists with, both now again and before, isg preaching the Gospel with such conditions and qalifications as the Prophets did; and of such preaching you say in expresse termes,h that tho it may have a notion of free grace, yet it hath not the truth of it.
Now Sir, let others judge, whither or no, I have justly charged you, with making Gods Prophets deluders of his people; Yea, with casting an impious and blasphemous aspersion upon God himself, in making himi like a Master, that to seem liberal bad his servants fill his wine out freely, but had before ordered them to burn it so; that it should be too hot for them to drink. But your eagerness against the Legalists, makes you, with others of your strain, to oft too forget your selves, and to aspers Prophets, and Apostles, yea and God himself, together with them.
Now Sir, let others judge, whither or no, I have justly charged you, with making Gods Prophets deluders of his people; Yea, with casting an impious and blasphemous aspersion upon God himself, in making himi like a Master, that to seem liberall bad his servants fill his wine out freely, but had before ordered them to burne it so; that it should be too hot for them to drink. But your eagernesse against the Legalists, makes you, with others of your strain, to oft too forget your selves, and to aspers Prophets, and Apostels, yea and God himself, togither with them.
iOccas. Word, p. 4.
The author
Thomas Gataker 1574–1654
PuritansEngland
Rector of Rotherhithe; member of the Westminster Assembly.